'Thinking outside the box ...' iii by Amber Javis

Third response to a blog post by Amber Jarvis on The Mental Elf:

Thinking outside the box: alternatives to standard inpatient mental health care

Amber's post considers a study by:

Griffiths, J. L., Baldwin, H., Vasikaran, J., Jarvis, R., Pillutla, R., Saunders, K. R., … & Johnson, S. (2025). Alternative approaches to standard inpatient mental health care: development of a typology of service models. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 19(1), 1-13: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40247283/

A Community Psychiatric Nurse since 1985, on first contact patients were often upset initially at the prospect of a visit. Not the fact it was a nurse, but a psychiatric, 'mental' nurse. If the patient was OK about it, their family may have had qualms. Discretion was always exercised, essential in terms of maintaining confidentialty. Not infrequently, as a team we had a conflict of interest. A colleague already had a client a few doors down; or they lived around the corner. Socio-politically, there was never an issue back then with shop fronts, but homelessness has a long history of course. I've worked in intermediate support, visiting someone 2-3 times in a day. That continuity helps, in contrast to the experience of older adults in social care. It could be that the potential stigma elicited by intensive home care is now attenuated by:

• The public's increased awareness mental health & illness;
• The fragmentation of neighbourliness means people really aren't interested?

In the conclusion on Griffith's et al's study Amber notes:

'The authors’ classification of alternative service models could help planners and commissioners understand ‘the whole range of options’ when deciding which improvements to prioritise and invest in.

However, future studies should investigate the implementation challenges surrounding these alternative models – that is, what might make certain models easier or more difficult to introduce? Research investigating their effectiveness in practice is also required – are there particular models that are better suited to certain individuals, at particular times? As the authors put it: “what works best for whom, when and how”!'

The government in England has launched a trial regards people who are sick, and their work status:

'GP surgeries in England can offer advice to patients on getting back to work, including career coaching or exercise classes, as part of a pilot project to reduce the number of people who are signed off work sick.

The aim is to help people return to the workplace more quickly to reduce the length of time they need fit notes - better known as sick notes.

These are issued by health professionals if a patient is unwell or cannot work for more than seven days.

A total of £1.5m is being made available to 15 regions in England, and will be shared between GP practices in these areas to hire coaches or occupational therapists to support patients in their return to work.'

Hugh Pym, Health editor: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwyx880d1w8o 

Individual

|

      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               

HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      

 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 

|

Group

Career coaching Exercise classes Counselling Reduce time spent 'ill - sick - off-work' Motivation - Mindset	FIT - SICK: physically only of course! Seven days What can't I do? What can I do?
Social Prescribing Occupational Therapists Physiotherapist Support workers Horticultural groups Local history	FIT NOTES - SICK NOTES £1.5m across 15 regions Policy Welfare budget Behavioural Economics Integrated Care & Social Policy

Given the rise of mental health related provblems in the population, some might argue that increased awareness of, and education about mental illnesses is part of the problem. But this isn't literacy then?

With the standing of the mental health nursing curriculum called into question, policymakers have some serious decisions to make. Social prescribers and care navigators are not the only people preoccupied with signposting. Griffith et al. write:

'Inpatient care is also costly; even though only 3% of people in England accessing mental health care in 2018/19 received inpatient mental health care, National Health Service (NHS) trusts in England still invest more in inpatient than community services [8].'

Hodges' model: Axes & Domains

You can appreciate just how far away prevention and a health literate population truly are. Budgets will have to be re-directed. Now that is 'care-ordination'.

Griffith et al. and Amber's response, calls care that is simultaneous person-centred and service-centred. 

In Hodges' model it is as if the vertical axis, is turned and the 'individual' aligned with the humanistic (person-centred) and group - the mechanistic (service-centred) axis. This gives us self-care, individualised healthcare, personalised medicine through to population health.

Griffith does not venture into literacy and education (not their study's purpose, of course); but using Hodges' model, we can see two critical related issues. In addition to reducing the time a person is physically, and mentally indisposed, unwell, ill, sick ...

1. We need to improve the lot of children excluded from school;
2. Seriously address the determinants of health socio-politically.

'Thinking outside the box ...' i

ii 'Thinking outside the box ...'

ii 'Thinking outside the box ...' by Amber Javis

Second reply to a blog post by Amber Jarvis on The Mental Elf:

Thinking outside the box: alternatives to standard inpatient mental health care

Amber's post considers a study by:

Griffiths, J. L., Baldwin, H., Vasikaran, J., Jarvis, R., Pillutla, R., Saunders, K. R., … & Johnson, S. (2025). Alternative approaches to standard inpatient mental health care: development of a typology of service models. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 19(1), 1-13: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40247283/

Jarvis highlights concern within inpatient services of:

'use of coercive practices ... (Nyttingnes et al., 2018; Belayneh et al., 2024). These include physical restraint (physically holding a person), seclusion (holding a person in a locked room) and chemical restraint (the use of sedating medication to manage distress or behaviour, sometimes administered “as needed” rather than as part of any planned treatment). Poor relationships between staff and service users have also been noted, ...'

Reflecting since the previous post, I realise that I encountered efforts to prevent admission and treat in the community prior to going part-time. A short stay unit at a general hospital. Being a member of Intermediate Support for older adults; shifts ran 0800-2000 - early or late. Then working part-time, there were short-stay placements in the community that the recovery team would visit providing support.

Mental distress is distressing (a truism of course), both as lived experience (with or without self-awareness in-situ/crisis) and for others in the vicinity. Family, friends - who see a person they thought they knew, perhaps even thought they were a friend, a person who loved them; but now!? They present as distant, aggressive, subdued, agitated, unpredictable, inconsolable and possibly expressing thoughts of self-harm, threats to harm others, or totally bizarre, 'psychotic' ideas. This is not the person they thought they knew. For the person affected, familiars are strangers. A relational breakdown. We forget the severely mentally ill at our peril. A pervasive sense of helplessness is readily transferred: the reflex conclusion that help is needed - and fast.

To say we are creatures of habit, is to also acknowledge that change our environment results in a change in our behaviour. When relatives did arrive on the psychogeriatric ward I mentioned previously, they cried. Apologising for the environment, yes; efforts to reassure ensued and eventually family, friends were won over. They shouldn't have been. Unless we're in a game, play, or movie, who wants to find themselves in a Victorian era institution?

I've posted previously (or is it in draft?) on the importance of design in the design of care environments. It was a relative's visit to a care home, that resulted in a nursing home design business (Sunday Times). 

A person who is severely mentally ill needs service-centred care, not purely person-centred care. Person-centredness is key, but safety of self, and the public soon makes itself known. We also forget this at our peril. The problem is that control, and law literally take over. Plus, it's our place not yours. Loss of power the person struggling, ill, in crisis then follows. Amber continues:

'The concerns described above chime uncomfortably with modern mental health agendas of prioritising autonomy, compassion, trauma-informed and person-centred care. In light of these tensions, and the growing number of crisis alternatives – ranging from crisis cafes to intensive home treatment services – researchers  at the NIHR Policy Research Unit in Mental Health set out to map current alternatives to traditional inpatient care, both nationally and internationally. Griffiths and Baldwin’s findings raise important questions about how mental health services could evolve to better suit people’s needs, providing a valuable starting point for service planners considering developments in care.'

Hodges' model is ideal to help reflect and critique the relation-ship between 'a person' and 'the service'. I passed two gentlemen in London over the weekend. Clearly unkempt, standing but gesticulating, freely verbalising, incoherent on passing. Neither appeared intoxicated ( but I wasn't that close) or 'stoned'. That's the other question; passing-by what was I going to do? Does the 'community' care? On 'X' you encounter the extremes of debate. Anti-psychiatry, resort to and risks of dependence on medication - anti-depressants, anxiolytics; the damage from anti-psychotic drugs and atypical antipsychotics. The continuous debate about ECT. A dizzying stream of texts about mental health, over-diagnosis and wellbeing:

Medical prescribing has a partner. Social prescribing is well established, with organisations, events, publications and research emerging. People, have scoffed at the suggestion that gardening can help; or going for a run. Especially when you can't get out of bed. Chronic fatigue syndrome, long-COVID are seemingly monolithic in their resistance to change. A real challenge and so counter to the person's 'pre-morbid' personality and lifestyle.

For several years the state of mental health nursing as a specialty has been questioned. Is the mental health nursing curriculum being genericised? Enrollment of students nurses in learning disability has also dropped.

RCN questions separation of mental health nurse training (28 March 2025)

Medical prescribing has a partner. Social prescribing is well established, with organisations, events, publications and research emerging. People, have scoffed at the suggestion that gardening can help; or going for a run. Especially when they can't get out of bed. Chronic fatigue syndrome, long-COVID are seemingly monolithic in their resistance to change. A real challenge and so counter to the person's 'pre-morbid' personality and lifestyle. As a conceptual framework Hodges' model is ideal as a semantic net, to reflect and critique concepts that stretch and so disrupt (for a time) out norms. Concepts with a dual character. If social prescribing is one example, take crisis cafe mentioned by Jarvis above. If you think in physical - environmental terms where do you envisage a crisis occuring or playing out? What about a cafe? What is the ambience of these places?

I noticed a little visual game, an animation of characters running, jumping, climbing over an obstacle course. You focus on one figure and follow them for a time. This makes a difference, called distraction. In psychosocial intervention and managment of psychosis and anxiety audio - music, poetry, repetition has also bee used. The essence here must be when the intervention begins. Recognising relapse triggers, requires preparatory work. The Griffith reference is provided, but Jarvis begins to describe the results:

'Researchers identified 65 alternative service models to standard inpatient care. These were organised broadly organised according to the setting (e.g., community-based, hospital-based, or cross-setting) and the target population (e.g., adults versus children). Across these categories, ‘community-based alternatives’ were the most common category of alternative service models, followed by hospital-based and cross-setting approaches. We’ll explore each of these in more detail below.'

In post (i) and here I suppose I am advocating for mental health nursing as a distinct programme of study, practice and proven competence. For several years the state of mental health nursing as a specialty has been questioned. Is the mental health nursing curriculum being genericised? Enrollment of students nurses in learning disability has also dropped. 

RCN questions separation of mental health nurse training (28 March 2025)

There is a saying: 'You get what you pay for'. There is a sense that there are people who would like to ignore, deny, erase 'mental health'. After all, the truth really is that you can 'see' a broken leg. This isn't an issue if you can afford a private psychotherapist, or a psychoanalyst.

The elephant here (well, there always is one) is education and the literacies. For prevention: the ultimate change - this is where we must focus. But of course for the problem at hand - and mind it is too late.

(Post iii likely to follow.)

Individual

|

      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               

HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      

 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 

|

Group

subjectivity          mental state - crisis - mind quality	objectivity hand - physical state - crisis quantity
Social prescribing Cafe	Housing - crisis Cost of living - crisis

See also: 'literacy' : 'prevention' : 'service' : 'severe' : 'change'

'Thinking outside the box ...' i

iii 'Thinking outside the box ...'

'Thinking outside the box: alternatives to standard inpatient mental health care' by Amber Jarvis

c/o The Mental Elf on 'X' I came across a blog post by Amber Jarvis:

Thinking outside the box: alternatives to standard inpatient mental health care

Amber's post considers a study by:

Griffiths, J. L., Baldwin, H., Vasikaran, J., Jarvis, R., Pillutla, R., Saunders, K. R., … & Johnson, S. (2025). Alternative approaches to standard inpatient mental health care: development of a typology of service models. International Journal of Mental Health Systems, 19(1), 1-13: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40247283/

At an online meeting this evening, near the close the discussion loosened and alighted on AI. The ability of AI to summarise a large text file, a *.pdf and create discrete web HTML pages. The racial bias 'built-in' by human coders, reflected in outputs; that point to structural racism. 

Finding this paper on X, boxes are the bread and butter of Hodges' model. Not just thinking outside a box, or inside one, but several and with a final twist - to follow. Amber begins:

'Inpatient mental health care involves staying in a hospital or specialised facility to receive intensive, round-the-clock support for serious mental health needs (Staniszewska et al., 2019). Whereas acute inpatient services typically respond to immediate crises, longer-term wards support individuals with more complex needs and a higher level of ongoing risk.

Inpatient services are a core component of our mental health system — whether someone stays for a night, weeks, or even several years. However, inpatient care has recently come under growing scrutiny – and for good reason.'

A Community Mental Health Nurse since 1985, my in-patient experience is a tad misty, but not misty-eyed. As the wards: psychogeriatrics, long-stay, female acute admission were simultaneously challenging, rewarding - in the sense of being able to make a positive difference, changing what were institutionalised practices, no personal clothes, lockers, tea urn, no banking, few visitors (admission wards excepted). It was all very quotidian: check the bath book. Then tell, confirm, assure the patient, 'yes!'. It is your bath day. I've posted previously about critical mental health. You do (should?) quickly learn you are part of a system, a machine; and the distinction between person- patient-centred and service-centred care. The need to do my 'general' quickly emerged too. 

As ever, two words, across Amber's post and Griffith et al's title, stand out; 'map' and 'typology'. I must revisit and post about:

Macduff C. (2007). Typologies in nursing: a review of the literature. Nurse researcher, 14(2), 40–50. https://doi.org/10.7748/nr2007.01.14.2.40.c6020

Part-time work since 2020, in two adult CMHTs and a recovery team, has provided an update. The first as COVID emerged, was a bit of a shock in terms of diagnoses, caseness, the proximity to the law and forensic psychiatry, thresholds for referral, changes to mental health law (that were now more practical) and the management of patient's finances. 

So, to return to last night's brief online discussion, the observation of how racism is ongoing, brought up the fact of racism being structural and institutional (Dean & Thorpe, 2022). The change needed is an intergenerational break, which doesn't bear thinking about. The National HEALTH Service faces the same challenges in the shift to prevention, and addressing racism. Where is the workforce, going to come from, to help recovery, health and related literacies (media, emotional, financial)?

It is easy in boxes like Hodges' model (and others) to be idealistic. Ideally as I learned of Community Psychiatric Nurses being recruited, six of us, we all should have asked:

What is the plan?

What is the model of care?

What characterises 'care in the community'?

How do we prevent relapse, readmission?

Is there a 'halfway house'*?

We did, to an extent. There was great enthusiasm, motivation, idealism, co-ordination, collaboration  (Tyrer & Gelder, 1990) and leadership. 'We' had an association,^ and a journal. Back then the Royal College of Psychiatry produced a report on CPNs. Is there a message in this? Progress was and has been made, but the promise has not been delivered. With care in the community having regressed, an incomplete 'project'.

I will read more and revise this post, or more likely add another: with less 'history' ...

Individual

|

      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               

HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      

 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 

|

Group

Model of Care	Model of care
Model of Care Care in Community Children - Schools - Education	Model of care 'Care Leavers'

*'Cross-settings' in Griffith et al.

^https://www.unitetheunion.org/what-we-do/unite-in-your-sector/health-sector/mental-health-nurses-association

Lorraine T Dean, Roland J Thorpe, What Structural Racism Is (or Is Not) and How to Measure It: Clarity for Public Health and Medical Researchers, American Journal of Epidemiology, Volume 191, Issue 9, September 2022, Pages 1521–1526, https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwac112

Tyrer P, Gelder M. The future of community psychiatric nursing: some research findings. Psychiatric Bulletin. 1990;14(9):550-551. doi:10.1192/pb.14.9.550

ii 'Thinking outside the box ...'

iii 'Thinking outside the box ...'

See also: 'institution' : 'racism' : 'typology' : 'map' : 'Forensic'

'What Kingdom' by Fine Gråbøl

client - person - individual - self - patient

|

INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES

humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic

SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL

|

group

What Kingdom

'Gråbøl was lucky. Eventually she started seeing a new psychiatrist, who looked at that record "and was like, "Wow, you receive So much more medicine than all the other people who live there. Why is that?'" She didn't know. Gradually, though, she was able to come off the drugs; and two doctors decided that she didn't, in fact, have borderline personality and bipolar disorders, removing the diagnoses that had shaped her sense of her self. In time, she left the unit and rebuilt her life. She's no longer on medication today, but the ghosts of her past diagnoses haunt her. She wonders whether the conditions are merely in hibernation and she'll wake up one day and enter another depressive episode. She doesn't wish she'd never been diagnosed, but does feel that her doctors underestimated the effect those labels would have on her development. At 17, she points out - the age she was diagnosed as bipolar - most teenagers don't yet know who they are. "You want to find a box or language to define yourself, so that you can close yourself in. And one way of getting that sense is getting into the psychiatric system." Since returning to "normal" life, she has also struggled with survivor's guilt: the feeling that while she made it out of the system, others did not.

'Above all, she wishes that the emphasis would shift away from the suffering individual and onto their broader context. We need to become better, as a society, at making room for people who aren't fully functional citizens. Gråbøl's narrator phrases it as a question: "Could we not imagine treatments that are instead externally directed involving the outside world gearing itself towards a wider and more comprehensive emotional spectrum?" Gråbøl's answer, though, is the same as my own: "I don't know."'

the system citizens?

My source:
Leaf Arbuthnot, Interview. We need to make room for the mentally ill. Review, The Daily Telegraph, 21 September 2024, pp.8-9.

Image:
https://images3.penguinrandomhouse.com/cover/9781953861849

Interview study: Exploring psychological safety in inpatient mental health settings

Are you a healthcare professional, with experience of working on adult #inpatient #psychiatricwards in the UK? We’re interested in hearing about your experience of providing psychologically safe care. See details below! @LeedsMedHealth @UoL_MHN @yqsrdotorg @YHPSRC

— Beth Griffin 🌸 (@BethLGriffin) September 9, 2024  

[And my source: plus c/o @LainidiO]

 

ImROC: Briefing Paper 24 - Recovering Adult Acute Psychiatric Inpatient Wards

"Explanation, compassion and a holistic understanding of the person’s situation are critical (Royal College of Psychiatrists, 2017)." p.39.

(my emphasis)

"It requires practitioners to critically reflect on their values, beliefs, and biases and actively work to reduce as far as is possible the oppressive systems and practices within inpatient wards." p.15.

What models / frameworks for/of care do practitioners use? 

What models invite - are primed for:

• critical reflection (individually, or as a group, p.56)?
• recognition of oppressive situations, phenomena, ethical dilemmas?
• citizenship - citizenry (p.18)?
• deciding whether it is a journey, or not?
• a possible role in burnout (p.54) mitigation?
• reflection, development, and restoration (p.56)?
• are all models situated?

Individual
   |

      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               

HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      

 SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 

|

Group

neurotypical neurodivergent/autistic [Yes.] Can what has been stressed for decades - compassion, listening, validating, empathy, rapport, the therapeutic alliance, seeing the person ... in mental health nurse education, theory and practice, be strengthened through review of skill-mix, and workforce? Whilst, in-turn, being sensitive to the pressures on mental health RNs, as cohorts of students, seek to assure their learning experiences; and as qualified nurses old and new seek to protect their professional identity, values, standards, and ethics - responsive to the demands of the 21st century.

close to home transport physical environment: noise, smells, space, decor, light.. While (originally?) aimed at elective in-patient care, the mantra of discharge planning begins upon admission (even before) has reached mental health services and community mental health teams. Even as the reduced number of beds (perversely) provides ideal conditions, this should (must) not mean the 'game' becomes 'pass the parcel', 'musical chairs' - the person lost in the many processes.

Hell is other people - as the saying goes ... When the therapeutic value and potential of relationships are recognised, the need for a tool to identify and critique what is relational is even more critical. Not just to realise what has long-been psycho-social, but the 'alt-def' of person-centred. This demands simultaneity in assurance. We contrast the humanistic with the mechanistic - service-centred. Let's not forget the need for integrated** care. See community/society as the safety net it can be. So DO NOT: raise a patient's / family's expectations (p.49) only to let them down.

least restrictive Let's not re-learn the lessons of history, but if you insist...?^ One mention of (social) 'determinants' (p.37)! Please take a look out of the [safety] window; and beyond the APPG Committee room...  Wither ambition, courage in policy - to discover what is evidence-based (the lesson since 5th July 1948)? In-patient care is too late.* For sustainable health services and systems we need to act sooner, educate, to try to address all the determinants. Please remember what 'you' (through policy..) have done to the patient as a concept: patiency. <- Recovery carries political heft.

Please remember what 'you' (through policy..) have done to the patient as a concept: patiency. Recovery carries political heft. No one wants to create, foster, instill dependency, but (emotional labour) care delivery demands space and time: being with, or at least available.

*If this was the guiding principle for all disciplines, stakeholders, policymakers, researchers could this:

• place emphasis (again) on prevention; staying well - relapse prevention;
• help generate alternate modalities for therapy / care;
• help concentrate services to deliver person-centred, recovery and trauma informed in-patient experiences - where therapeutic outcomes are  at least feasible/possible;
• begin from literacy-first stance: take up educational focus in schools - PSHE, work-place;
• health career - life chances?

**physical-mental, care context, philosophy of care - trauma - recovery - strengths, funding, disciplines, pastoral, health - social care - housing ...

^Dept. of Health. Caring for people: the CPA for people with a mental illness referred to specialist mental health services. London: 1990

Joint Health/Social Services Circular  C(90)23/LASSL(90)11

Rachel Perkins, Sharon Gibbard, Yasmin Blackwood, Simon Barnitt, Lowri Smith, Anna Cheetham, Poppy Repper, Anne Rackham, Ben Dorey, Jo Luck, Julie Repper. Recovering Adult Acute Psychiatric Inpatient Wards: Creating Recovery-Focused, Trauma-Informed and Neuro-Inclusive Culture, Relationships and Practice. ImROC. Briefing Paper 24. 2024.


See also:

ImROC (2023) Thinking about Recovery Together

ImROC (2023a) Team Recovery Implementation Plan for Acute Inpatient Wards

Wand, T. (2024), We have to cancel psychiatric nursing and forge a new way forward. Int J Mental Health Nurs. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.13301

Warrender, D., Connell, C., Jones, E., Monteux, S., Colwell, L., Laker, C. et al. (2024) Mental health deserves better: Resisting the dilution of specialist pre-registration mental health nurse education in the United Kingdom. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 33, 202–212. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.13236

Plus:
Jones P. (2014) Using a conceptual framework to explore the dimensions of recovery and their relationship to service user choice and self-determination. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine. Vol 3, No 4, (2013) pp.305-311.

Dynamism - Stasis : Demand - Supply :Bed-blocking

individual

|

INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES

humanistic ---------------------------------------  mechanistic

SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL

|

group-population

Gibbons, K. (2016). NHS crisis deepens as bed blocking costs £6bn. The Times, August 12, p.1.

Image source:

Hospital Bed By Wojciech Zasina, PL, Noun Project

"Community Care means whatever you want it to mean. Discuss?" Essay question c.1987

individual

|

INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES

humanistic ---------------------------------------  mechanistic

SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL

|

group

Blue/Orange	Blue/Orange
OUT!	IN!

HCA training: Knock, knock, knocking on the political domain's door

INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ------------------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL

individual

emotional care	physical care
social care	FRANCIS - a year on:  How much training do healthcare assistants have before their first shift on a ward? 25% = none

group - population

Although that 25% sits nicely in the POLITICAL domain, what is the impact of this finding across the domains overall? Whether or not the impact is equally shared across the interpersonal, sciences and social domain, upon which domain will it end up knocking?

Calkin, S. (2014) Francis impacts on culture and patient safety, HSJ, 7 February. 124, 6376, 4-5.