Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: Search results for troubled families

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query troubled families. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query troubled families. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, June 27, 2026

‘Prevention Demonstrator’ - GM Live Well

England’s First Prevention Demonstrator: Opportunities for Greater Manchester and its VCFSE sector

Greater Manchester has been chosen as England’s first Prevention Demonstrator, an initiative announced in the Government’s 10-Year Health Plan earlier this year. It marks a step toward transforming public services with a more ‘preventative’ approach.

The Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) was named as the first prevention demonstrator in the UK Government’s 10 Year Plan for Health in July. It will take a community-led preventative approach to the provision of public services which means fixing the foundations of a person’s life – such as housing, and access to education and employment opportunities – as a means of preventing ill health from social and economic detriment and improving lives, as well as reducing pressure on acute and crisis services.

The Prevention Demonstrator will be building on the Live Well Model of service delivery, which brings together services such as health, employment support and debt advice at a neighbourhood level working with the voluntary, community, faith and social enterprise (VCFSE) sector, providing a blueprint for the rest of the country.

Warren Heppolette has been appointed to lead this work, seconded from NHS Greater Manchester where he was Chief Officer for Strategy, Innovation and Population Health. Warren has been closely involved in the GMVCFSE Leadership Group’s Commissioning and Investment sub-group which aims to improving standards and practices for the benefit of the VCFSE sector.

Continued ...


Lucy North, Communications and Policy Officer. Published: December 5, 2025

⍚


'Sustainability' and 'sufficiency' (as per the previous post) are words of the moment. Policymakers want change to have a permanent quality, which ironically means individuals within a population benefitting from initiatives like this have a mindset that makes them flexible to future changes and challenges.

As Camilla Cavendish notes in 'Andy Burnham will need to play a new card now', Manchester's prevention demonstrator has echoes of David Cameron's Big Society and the Troubled Families project. There are two other words that can work for individuals and populations: impetus and momentum. Within this through Hodges' model we can equip people and communities for lifelong learning. We can also highlight, as Prof. Kevin Fong did at RCN Congress 2026 in his marvellous keynote - that resilience is found between people, not within individuals.
 

See also: Presentation - Prevention, Health and Good Growth: Realising Our Prevention Ambitions

Philip Britteon, Alfariany Fatimah, Stephanie Gillibrand, Yiu-Shing Lau, Laura Anselmi, Paul Wilson, Matt Sutton, Alex J. Turner, (2024) The impact of devolution on local health systems: Evidence from Greater Manchester, England, Social Science & Medicine, Volume 348, 116801,
ISSN 0277-9536, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.116801.

My source: Camilla Cavendish, Opinion: Andy Burnham will need to play a new card now, FTWeekend, 20-21 June, 2024. p.12.

Previously: 'prevention' : 'big society' : 'troubled families' : 'social prescribing'

Tuesday, June 24, 2025

Invited to ARC - Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (Updated May 2026: ARC Livestream £20)

Earlier in the year I read in the Financial Times Weekend, and on @h2cm about

the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship - ARC.

There was a conference and slick website whose aims struck a cord.

Other events (are ongoing as I write) and scheduled, including Olympia, London, UK, from 23rd to 25th June 2026.

Having subscribed for news of future events, I was overjoyed to receive an invite today:



 Register for ARC 


Semi-retired, I knew there would be a cost to attend, but £1500 (plus, travel from NW England and accommodation) is unfortunately beyond my means. Having self-funded many conferences in the past, £500 per day for commercial/IT conference and additional features is not necessarily 'expensive'.

The invitation itself is encouraging, and I am always grateful for that. 

I will 'regretfully decline' so the place can be reallocated. It is a shame as Hodges' model can really contribute to this dialogue, and debate.

The vertical axis of Hodges' model incorporates the individual, however defined, persona, or role attributed; e.g., person, client, carer, patient, mother, father, infant.

There is an obvious overlap and this is where context and situation also come into effect. How roles are ascribed is defined socially, culturally, and politically, which is what is found at the other end of the I-G axis - group.

Citizen, citizenry, citizenship, migrant, refugee, jury member, voter ... all clearly have a socio-political grounding.

Below, I have copied an updated version of the conceptual mapping from my 2nd March blog post. 

Back in March I was clearly hopeful, looking at the post's link text:

https://hodges-model.blogspot.com/2025/03/arc-speaker-2026.html


Individual
|
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
Group
WHO AM I?
identity personality
attitude aptitude
character - integrity - virtues
purpose - motivation
faith - individual beliefs
religious engagement
courage hope
my literacies - education3
threshold concepts
fatalism - my destiny
well-being - self actualisation
trust
personal qualities - empathy - rapport
life stages - life chances
TI:ME
Past NOW Future
physical thresholds 
trust in SCIENCE?
climate change
circular economy - transformation
AI
truth - information disorder
science - technology
PAST - work - FUTURE
Balance - Energy
(what does the clock say?)
ACT NOW for FUTURE GENERATIONS
problems: waste, health, poverty, info disorder
Evidence
grassroots social movement
family - LOVE - social growth
community - dignity & respect
culture - diversity
social - cultural identity
arts
society - support
social change
social capital
social contract
social values
our shared destiny
our children's children
welfare - living wage
employment - leisure
quality of life
power - security - safety
Short - Long-termism
political systems - democracy, theocracy...
transparency - accountability - TRUST
past policy UK: 'Troubled Families'
economics - tax - income $$$ £££
organisations, institutions, corporations
political (manifest! - colonialism ) destiny
policy - political systems
political engagement
health of Leaders
CARE: from SELF to PLANET
international law - justice
control of fraud, corruption, crime
human rights
political thresholds


Visiting London 4th - 7th July (2025) and looking forward.

Update May 2026: 
 

Saturday, July 04, 2009

Relationships matter: Society Guardian & The WSJ

Re. Charles Leadbeater's State of Loneliness, The Guardian, Society, 01.07.09

The cover of this weeks Society Guardian immediately caught my eye with its picture (I wonder which corner of which care domain this lady is sat in?):

The text initially passed me by; then yesterday I caught up, it seems the business model quest in one sector is having a domino effect with new models needed elsewhere including health and social care.

Leadbeater's piece reminded me of Lean thinking the improvement process with its drive to identify value, reduce waste and repetition. ... His text points out that:

More efficient services quickly move in and out of people's lives, but they don't really change how people live. That is one reason why we have not made deep inroads into the most deprived communities, the most troubled families, the most intractable social problems. Services manage and process people and problems, but only rarely allow people to change their lives. Service solutions are ill-suited to the emerging challenges of the rise of long-term health conditions, diseases linked to lifestyle and diet, ageing or climate change. You cannot deliver a solution to an epidemic of diabetes the way that DHL delivers a parcel.
So any model, method that is primarily process centered may find itself compromised - providing just one cylinder's worth of power in a four cylinder engine. In Hodges' model I have identified the 4Ps. PROCESS, PURPOSE, POLICY, and PURPOSE (to which we must now add PROBITY). It will be interesting to see how value is defined across service forms of engagement, intervention (including signposting) and the new set of outcome measures to follow whether local, national, service-reported or patient reported outcome measures. Leadbeater continues:
The key will be to redesign services to enable more mutual self-help, so that people can create and sustain their own solutions. The best way to do more with less is to enable people to do more for themselves and not need an expensive, professionalised public service. Enabling people to come together to find their own, local solutions should become one of the main goals of public services. Services do a better job when they leave behind stronger, supportive relationships for people to draw on and so not need a service.
So Jo(e) Public needs to reflect, compare, evaluate, learn, collaborate and make informed decisions in order to stay well amongst many other things. They need to be engaged holistically.

Where is the model for this...?
I believe I know.

The Wall Street Journal has something to add here The Doctor Will Text You Now and relating to my earlier posts on 'Beware Reflex Moves'. Relationships matter, but if nurses are out there assessing, assessing, assessing who is doing the education, dividend added therapy outcome focused?

If e-health is going to make a real contribution in augmenting and freeing high value care resources then this in turn depends on the value invested in relationships.
Louis Petrillo, 57, a psychologist in Westfield, N.J., says he regularly turns to his family’s doctor, Robert Eidus, for online advice about his frail 90-year-old mother, who finds office visits difficult. His son who is away at college also used an online visit when he had sinus problems. “I can get into his virtual office anytime,” says Dr. Petrillo. He feels the online care works well largely because Dr. Eidus knows his family members’ regular health complaints.
If older adults move home and need new primary care services, what are most probably(?) well established patient - doctor (patient - primary care team!) relationships are not just undermined they are undone! A person's sense of community is fractured. ...

Yes that image speaks volumes.

Image source: Guardian

Mathews, A.W., The Doctor Will Text You Now, JULY 1, 2009, The Wall Street Journal Interactive Edition

Sunday, March 02, 2025

Alliance for Responsible Citizenship

Last month on two occasions, I came across the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship (which is a registered company). 


In the Sunday Times, "Philippa Stroud: ‘Everyone’s moaning — I think humanity can sort things out’":

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/philippa-stroud-alliance-responsible-citizenship-km8z26b8b

and Financial Times "'Part megachurch, part political rally: inside London’s ‘rightwing Davos’".

https://www.ft.com/content/7ff1614c-38a2-4b5c-81d3-80cea1196dad 

Apparently, a right wing, conservative movement with a three-day conference, one commentary suggested it has struggled to define itself, which is understandable given the ongoing (increasing?) prompts for its creation.

You recognise early on in your nursing career and not just as a student (pre-Project 2000 UK), but as a Nursing Assistant that character is a key element in your professional development. By the time you qualify, you more accurately see that without a doubt it is your formative education that is a critical factor. That and your 'home' circumstances - and not necessarily the two-parents good, one bad formulation. This is why with students excluded from school, society is taking a wrong turn. There is obviously a problem but what is the 'correct' approach?

An 'alliance' already suggests a given level of organisation. By definition 'grassroots movements' must struggle to establish and retain their identity.

This is a project Hodges' model can help address - with a balanced but not necessarily a neutral output.


Individual
|
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
Group

identity
personality
attitude aptitude
character
faith
individual beliefs
religious engagement
courage
hope
threshold concepts
my destiny
well-being
trust


future
physical thresholds 
waste
climate change
circular economy
AI
truth - information disorder
science
technology
PAST - work - FUTURE
our future destiny -
(what does the clock say?)
future generations?

grassroots social movement
arts
family
community
culture - diversity
social - cultural identity
society - support
social change
social capital
social contract
social values
our shared destiny
our children's children
welfare - living wage
employment - leisure
quality of life

power
political systems
past policy UK: 'Troubled Families'
economics
organisations, institutions
corporations
political (manifest! - 
colonialism ) destiny
policy
systems
political engagement
health of leaders
trust
international law - justice
control of fraud, corruption, crime
human rights
political thresholds


Sunday, August 07, 2016

Future of Mental Health Nurse Training - Generic Course

It is an old debate: the generalist versus specialist. In nursing it's the divide in the tree of knowledge that gives us the branches of adult - general  and mental health nursing. Never unique this physical-mental, mind-body divide is repeated. A fractal feature of being human.

Without checking these two camps have been mentioned on W2tQ previously. Ever defensive I have probably been responding to the critique so readily aimed at Hodges' model:

Well, it is plain to see and read from the model that it is reinforcing the Cartesian division. The model is putting the patient in a box, not only that but using the medical model's reductionist practice by having four boxes. The model acts as an elaborated checklist.

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ---------------------------------------  mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group

MENTAL HEALTH CARE

PHYSICAL CARE





On the 15th I am 39. Yes, I wish I was. On the 15th it is 39 years since I started as a Nursing Assistant at Winwick Hospital, Warrington, UK. The change in mental health since then has been phenomenal. Winwick is gone as the local, or one of several regional asylums.

There is a proposal for students to specialise in the last year of training, to ensure there is an adequate grounding in physical care. The concern is that mental health skills will be diluted. There is some progress to be gained, ironically, in that suddenly the training will mirror what is experienced by the public and mental health services in terms of parity and spending.



MENTAL HEALTH CARE


PHYSICAL CARE






If we want to demonstrate nursing as a science and art let's mix the blue and green:


MENTAL HEALTH CARE and PHYSICAL CARE


SOCIOLOGY domain

POLITICAL domain

Voila! 50% of the work of the model is done. You wanted integrated care; you got integrated care: everything is all 70s Hunky Dory.

Of course, it is never that simple.

I've picked this issue up after it featured in Nursing Times (Stephenson, 2016) last month. Among the points raised:

  • Mental health risks being sidelined. 
  • Dilution of the mental health specialty could have a "devastating" impact.
  • Some mental health courses have already be revised to incorporate more generic content. This can leave students with the "the worst of both worlds". There is a risk of a bias to adult nursing. 
  • Recruitment and differences in the appeal of courses is also noted, mental health candidates may already have related qualifications and more life experience.
  • There is a need for a responsive and flexible workforce who can work pretty much anywhere (pp.2-3).

It seems as if there is climate for merger and acquisitions activity. In truth it has been there for a long time.

Mental health has changed. From my limited perspective I have not needed a work-issued briefcase for a decade. There was one case for us to use as needed. This one facet of a service-defined stepped care model that reflects change. From institution issue 3-piece suit plus white coats to smart-casual on the community. It is several years since I last needed to give an i.m. injection. I do feel I could tomorrow if needed, but if it is Risperidone - Consta I would once again need to read about the client and digest the info leaflet before doing the visit. Questions about competence are the constant. Believe me I'm not wishing for a return for the old-days: I remember it very well.

As a sign-off mentor there has been a panic to find a student the necessary experience. Now it seems there is less urgency in this respect. This is a positive sign in terms of mental health nursing and social change and yet a loss of a clinical skill being learned and exercised.

The emphasis over the past 1-2 decades is on nursing assessment. The nurse as therapist in the formal - psychological sense is no longer emphasised. A further diminution of mental health nursing. This may be a bias on my part, as a new community psychiatric nurse in the 1980s.

Where I mention merger and acquisitions above, what of interest rates? What difference will the loss of the student bursary make? Workforce planners may benefit from more certainty and an increase in numbers, but what of the quality of the future workforce? This is a crucial factor in retention. I came to mental health nursing first then did two years for the SRN - RGN. Currently, some courses are structured such that in the first 6 months the student is already committed to the pathway. Change is not possible even if desired.

At the very least this suggests the need for a four year course?

The locus of my nursing career has been the community and begs the question: Is the project complete? The media and countless promises on mental health funding (ongoing) show that this is far from the case. Where would this place children's mental health, women's services and forensic? Has the reduction in beds been compensated for by community resources?

But ALL the above misses another agenda; one that is now: 21st century nursing; (this is also represented in the third rendering of Hodges' model above).

Policy makers must address the social and political foundations upon which all nurses, social workers and allied health professions (theorize and) practice.

Where is the workforce that will help the public to self-care? Where is the focus on prevention? How are those 'troubled families' doing?

There is a prospective dividend to follow from big-data, that can extend this debate to the real questions of - society, policy, and life-styles - and provide evidence for real change. Finally:

Where is the generic conceptual framework to help integrate physical - general nursing and mental health?

Stephenson, J. (2016). Rift over move to 'generic' courses. Nursing Times, 20.07.16. 112:29, 2-3.