Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Wednesday, August 03, 2022

The Phillips Ives Review

Call to action:  please share widely across your networks.  If you would like our comms pack to promote the review in your organisations in health and social care, please let me know.  

The Phillips Ives Review has launched and will provide evidence and inform strategy; ensuring that nurses and midwives are given access to the knowledge, skills and education required for safe, effective digitally-enabled practice.

We’d like to invite anyone working in nursing or midwifery practice, or interested in this area to share your ideas, case studies and experiences on our engagement platform until 21 August. 

"The Phillips Ives Review was launched virtually on 26 May 2022 by its Chair, Dr Natasha Phillips, Chief Nursing Information Officer (CNIO), NHS England and International Vice-Chair Dr Jeanette Ives Erickson (USA).

This year long in-depth study will identify what is required to enable the meeting of the CNIO NHS England's aims for Nurses & Midwives:

  • To ensure nurses and midwives are empowered to practice and lead in a digitally-enabled health and social care system, now and in the future.

  • To ensure nursing and midwifery practice is fully supported by the use of digital technology and data science.

The Review will bring together national and international experts with expertise in nursing and midwifery and beyond, to investigate, critically appraise and make recommendations to ensure the breadth of ambition and scope of future practice of the pre and post registration nursing and midwifery workforce is captured."


My source: FutureNHS - https://future.nhs.uk//home/grouphome

Call for Papers - Basic Needs: Normative Perspectives

for a special issue on
Basic Needs: Normative Perspectives
(Editors: Lukas Meyer – Daniel Petz – Alessandro Pinzani)

Lessico di Etica Pubblica
http://www.eticapubblica.it/
 
In recent years the debate on basic needs and their place in normative theories of ethics and politics has been rekindled. This controversial concept has finally been openly adopted by authors who adopt different approaches to discuss issues of social justice. There are good reasons for this.

As a currency of justice, needs have several advantages. First, in contrast to preferences, desires, and some other currencies, basic needs are fully objective, i.e., whether a person has a basic need for a certain thing is independent of her own or anybody else’s mental attitudes towards that thing. A second important reason for preferring basic needs as the currency of justice is that they are also universal, although their definition might be culturally influenced. Thirdly, basic needs are intrinsically morally demanding: that P has a basic need for O by itself entails that P ought to be able to have, be, realize, etc. O. Finally, basic needs also have an important advantage in the particular context of sufficientarianism. One of the main objections against sufficientarianism is that it is unable to provide a plausible substantive specification of its threshold of sufficiency. The concept of basic needs, in contrast, essentially entails the idea of a qualitative difference. Being able to fulfill such needs takes precedence over being able to fulfill non-basic needs and desires. Moreover, it distinguishes a life that has a certain minimum quality from a life that lacks this quality.

We invite authors to explore these and other aspects of the concept of basic needs and its use for normative theories of social justice, including intergenerational justice.

Contributions can be in English, Italian, German, and French. The deadline is September 30, 2022

For inquiries please contact: Alessandro Pinzani <alepinzani AT gmail.com>
 
*currently.

Tuesday, August 02, 2022

ii from Learning Health Systems journal - to case studies

Returning to this journal, reference #47 -

MacQuarrie C. Holistic designs. Encyclopedia of Case Study Research.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; 2010:442-443.

In -

From “Invented here” to “Use it everywhere!”: A Learning health system from bottom and/or top?

Christian Colldén, Andreas Hellström

- led me to (with my emphasis) 

Encyclopedia of case study research/edited by Albert J. Mills, Gabrielle Durepos, and Elden Wiebe. London: SAGE Publications Ltd. 2010.

"Case study methodology can be a rich source for understanding the multiple structures that support and sustain organizational life and business units. Its strengths are in its ability to gain an insider’s viewpoint during the research process, the more in-depth and nuanced findings based on that, and in its flexibility in using different methods. Its challenges are in the theoretical framework and in the development of concepts based on empirical findings. When these are taken into account, fruitful and nuanced research results are possible, and through the study it is possible to gain an overall and holistic picture of the research object." p.76.
"To reach the intended effect for the learners, these teaching cases must fulfill certain conditions and prerequisites. For this, Bernd Weitz proposes three essential criteria: exemplarity, clearness, and practical orientation.

Exemplarity means that the study must exemplify not just an arbitrary and subjective case, but also one that is objective, unique, or representative. Clearness requires that cases are not trivial; on the contrary, they have to make use of all possible and appropriate alternatives of illustration for a comprehensive understanding. This demands holism, traceability, visualization, and supplementation with additional information. The last point, practical orientation, aims for the highest integration of theory and practice for an integrated learning process." p.77.
    (And many other sources.)

Hodges' model provides a portal. As a frame, not just one type of portal but several including information (portal). A portal that can function as a learning health system. Could this in combination with health literacy* even be extended to represent a definition of self-care? Long identified as a research approach for Hodges' model, case studies are the logical fit. If they were not, then the whole clinical, nursing, healthcare rationale for the model would be lost. A clinical, medical, health care episode begins as a result of case-ness being achieved. In the case that follows in practice, we are looking to assure person-centered care in the midst of criteria, processes, (gate-keeping) thresholds that are inherently service-centred and possibly also influenced by targets and a series of constraints.
"Case studies of the elderly tend to embrace normativism. If health, as in naturalism, amounts to preserving the organic functional ability to make species-typical contributions to survival and reproduction, then health can be objectively and statistically determined—that is, subjects’ perceptions or awareness are not relevant. But if a normative evaluation of the person’s body and mind is a necessary element in the care of the elderly, then case studies are necessary." p.127.

Demographics, and intergenerational factors, plus the (probable) rise of appeals to transdisciplinarity^ means that for policy, governance and assurance case studies and mixed-methods will increase in research.

The orientation of Hodges' model is also inevitably practical and hence pragmatic.

I have only scratched the surface here, and probably not in the most itchy of spots (Encyclopedia and not the only one).

More to follow ... and if you have observations, advice I'd be pleased to hear from you.

*All the literacies and schools of informatics.
^Such are the problems we face.

See also: Contents: Learning Health Systems,6,3, July 2022

Monday, August 01, 2022

Contents: Learning Health Systems,6,3,July 2022

 

This issue includes:

What is unique about learning health systems? 

Charles P. Friedman


From “Invented here” to “Use it everywhere!”: A Learning health system from bottom and/or top?


Christian Colldén, Andreas Hellström


Toward an ontology of collaborative learning healthcare systems  

Alexandra H. Vinson, et al.

Email request by -
Kathleen Young, Editorial Assistant
kayoung AT umich.edu
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA

 

Friday, July 29, 2022

The Cass Review Interim Report ... reflections ...

 ... that may stand for themselves?

[ with my emphasis ]


Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: 

Interim report

February 2022

Introduction from the Chair

"... the aim of the Review is to ensure that children and young people who are experiencing gender incongruence or gender-related distress receive a high standard of NHS care that meets their needs and is safe, holistic and effective." p.11.

 

"As with autism, the framework for assessment needs to become formalised so there are clearer criteria for diagnosis and treatment pathways which are shared more widely. These should incorporate not just whether the child or young person meets DSM-5 criteria for gender dysphoria, but how a broader psychosocial assessment should be conducted and evaluated, and what other factors need to be considered to gain a holistic understanding of the child or young person’s experience. Professional judgement and experience will still be important, but if the frameworks and criteria for assessment and diagnosis were more consistent and reproducible, there would be a greater likelihood that two different people seeing the same child or young person would come to the same conclusion." p.60.

"Assessment and management: All children and young people who are referred to specialist services should have a competent local multi-disciplinary assessment and should remain under active holistic local management until they are seen at a specialist centre." p.92.

[ and from: https://www.england.nhs.uk/commissioning/spec-services/npc-crg/gender-dysphoria-clinical-programme/implementing-advice-from-the-cass-review/ ]

"Dr Cass has now sent further advice on the core components of this model. You can read the advice in full here.

In summary, she has said:

  ...

  • ‘The services should have an appropriate multi-professional workforce to enable them to provide an integrated model of care that manages the holistic needs of this population’.
  • ‘Staff should maintain a broad clinical perspective to embed the care of children and young people with gender uncertainty within a broader child and adolescent health context’."

 

Thursday, July 28, 2022

Seeds in 'architecture' iii

Prof. Younés describes 'three essential dualities': 

  • IMAGE and WORD 
  • TYPE and MODEL
  • IMITATION and INVENTION

IMAGE and WORD 

Nursing has its historical images, that are continually presented, the lamp, hands imbued with care and support and others. The attraction to Hodges' model was through its similarity to mind-mapping, but with offering an foundational structure for reflection and critique (learning). So image has been there from the start.

Younés writes: "Within the dialectic of the visible (objects apprehended by the senses) and the invisible (ideas or forms apprehended by the mind), the image acts as a symbol when it supports the visibility of an idea." ... "Forms can be seen as structural potentials ..." p.238.

Younés classifies images (p.241), or the artistically factual through three divisions:

  1. visual images (that would include icons and interface features)
  2. mental images
  3. verbal images (including metaphors and descriptions).

 "... the mind constructs a world within a world, and then reflects upon its own activity, as well as its own aesthetic appreciation of such activity."
I must stress the Younés context is architecture (and philosophy), but here extending to meaning I'm reminded of the way Hodges' model can span the arts and sciences, and original influences on why this model stood out for me through its facility for mind-mapping.

TYPE and MODEL 

 Here (p.242) Younés returns, not just to the origin, but the concept of origin through Form, the word and the type. Searching for universally shared purposes, within the permanences of human experience  this is health and social care too.

Taking in data, information, knowledge from assessment and other activities, this is usually contextualised - associated with a care domain. A return to the origin (nexus) of Hodges' model, the center is vital to retain balance and provide assurance in what we are doing, or not, and why.

"The architect imitates things as they have essential significance, but he or she does not copy any particular thing. This enables the layered transformation of natural models, without which the column would have always remained a tree. The form of the imitation is always different from that of the model. The roof is different from the forest's canopy. It is here that the pleasure of invention and the evaluation of the new enter, for it is within the recognized distance between the forest's canopy and the roof, that much of art occurs." p.244.
How times change in two decades. So many seek a roof, with architects having a recognized role in providing solutions post-natural disaster and political displacement of people. Not just homelessness, but homes that can cope, adjust to climate change. COVID has reminded us of the rejuvenating properties of nature, of the forest canopy, even that afforded by city centre gardens. 

We now see a roof not merely in physical terms, but social. As the night skies brighten we try to secure the canopy of the stars.

IMITATION and INVENTION 

Have we forgotten the contribution of positive role-models in learning? Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and this throws up the constant educational dilemma of the theory - practice gap. Should we be exposed to practice without the guiding mentor represented in theory - that is also evidence-based?

There is an interesting exploration of SCOPE, DISCOURSE and NATURE: On Scope

"Thus a theory that is systemic aims at a certain level of completeness for it establishes the internal organization of architecture as a discipline, and it explains its external relations to other arts, to techniques, to social factors. Put differently, the interior individual realm concerns the intellectual freedom, the inner reflection of the architect-maker. The exterior individual pertains to the thoughts resulting from one architect reflecting upon another architect's work, as well as the individual architect's reflections on the suitability of her or his building to a context. The interior collective bears upon the conscious or unconscious content of culture which thrive within the images of of operative myths that inform architectural production. The exterior collective designates that commonly built sense regarding the suitability of architecture (decorum) within its milieu par excellence: the city. The above concerns the scope of an architectural theoretical system, on the urban, architectural, aesthetic, social, and practical levels." p.245-246.

INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP
interior individualexterior individual
interior collective
exterior collective

 

I started these three posts noting the addition of 'architecture' to titles, concepts, and 'stretching' disciplines. Also guilty here; in mitigation, I'm aware of how in the mid-late 1970s technical drawing as taught was to change radically in the digital wave.

Hodges' model provides a drawing board, with analogue and digital potential.

I will continue to draw upon the (inspirational) discipline of architecture, it informs and sustains thought, construction, meanings, language use, and effort here.

There is much more to glean from this paper, so I hope to revisit it in the future - with further annotations on my copy.

Over the years I have noted related items in the press (yes, I saved the following):

Designs for life: architecture in the disaster zone, FT Weekend.

and read - A Bed for the Night: Humanitarianism in Crisis

See also: 

Seeds in 'architecture' i 

Seeds in 'architecture' ii

Younés, Samir. “Constructing Architectural Theory.” Philosophy 78, no. 304 (2003): 233–53. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3752046.


Monday, July 25, 2022

World Drowning Prevention Day

INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP

I can learn to swim?

Yes, you can -
it's fun too!
 Even if you can swim:
Respect the water!

Be aware -
of water depth,
the water's temperature and
your body's reaction to cold,
what lies beneath,
and the effect
of alcohol and substances, and that recent meal...

Be safe -
while having fun!

Local Community
Knowledge of local risk


Policy
Facilities
Development aid/funding

Sunday, July 24, 2022

I'm a critical thinker and no I don't carry a card ;-)

"One of us (PD) had a conversation recently with a new Director of Nursing (DoN) of a large hospital trust. They started to talk about “these new graduates today” and “what was wrong with them.” For shame, PD was just waiting for the usual tired diatribe about “university nurses” and what they “could not do” and why they were all “too academic” and so on ad nauseum. I could not have been more wrong. The DoN talked about “these new nurses” and how they did not seem to be critical thinkers who could question and challenge existing systems and practices. What I need, they said, are nurses who can advocate, challenge, step in to prevent incidents or patient deterioration, who can see better ways of doing things and make that happen. The last thing they need, they said, were nurses who could only tick boxes or follow algorithms and orders. To say this conversation was an eye-opening highlight in the oft-reported “decay” of critical thinking in nursing (Morrall & Goodman, 2013) was an understatement, especially since every university School of Nursing will swear blind that it produces nurses who are card-carrying “critical thinkers” and every hospital will testify that it encourages this, rather than erects barriers to prevent it (Cornell, Riordan, Townsend-Gervis, & Mobley, 2011). It is a real concern that so few Schools or health services even know how to ask the question, “How do we know?”, let alone answer it." p.2.

Darbyshire, P., Thompson, D. R., & Watson, R. (2019). Nursing schools: Dumbing down or reaching up? Journal of Nursing Management, 27(1), 1-3. https://doi.org/10.1111/jonm.12730

Still ready to help teach, share, collaborate - while still learning here ...


Saturday, July 23, 2022

The mechanics of Continental and Policy Drift


INDIVIDUAL

|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP


continental drift








... slow movement ...


Thanks to Prof Linda Gask who Retweeted LiLong.