INTRODUCTION
Several studies have discussed the specific knowledge taught and learned in precalculus, calculus, and analysis courses, from different perspectives: for example,
concept image and concept definition (e.g., O’Shea, 2016), APOS theory (e.g.,
Martínez-Planell, Trigueros Gaisman, & Mcgee, 2016), and the Anthropological
Theory of the Didactic (ATD; e.g., Bergé, 2016). Our starting point is the general
and relatively vague question of when in an undergraduate degree in mathematics
does a student need (need in the sense of to succeed in the course) to engage in
mathematical activities that may substantially, or meaningfully, lead to developing
mathematical practices. We consider and frame this question within the ATD
(Chevallard, 1999), which provides theoretical tools for modelling any human
activity or practice. The semantic distinction between these two words is essential to
us. Our hypothesis is that the kinds of didactic constructs to which professors and
students are exposed are decisive in fostering the emergence of practices out of
collections of local, particular, and relatively short-lived activities. From the
theoretical stance we take, this means the development of mathematical knowledge
out of local, particular, and relatively short-lived mathematical activities.' p.487.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
“Activity and practice”
'As mentioned above, we have come to see the semantic difference between activity
and practice as pertinent to our work. The ATD’s notion of praxeology provides a
fundamental model for defining mathematical practice, which, in the context of the
theory, is equated to mathematical knowledge. According to the model, any practice
(or piece of knowledge) can be represented by a quadruplet [T, τ, θ, Θ] involving
four interconnected components: a type of tasks T, which generates the practice, the
corresponding collection of techniques τ developed to accomplish T, the discourse
used to describe, justify, explain, and produce the techniques (i.e., their technologies
θ), and the underlying theories Θ that serve as a foundation of the technological
discourse. As students progress in their studies of mathematics, they engage in
numerous activities, which progressively determine the practices they develop'. p.489.
Laura Broley and Nadia Hardy. (2018). A study of transitions in an undergraduate mathematics program. In PROCEEDINGS of INDRUM 2018
Second conference of the
International Network for Didactic
Research in University Mathematics. pp.487-496. ERME topic conference.
https://indrum2018.sciencesconf.org/data/Indrum2018Proceedings.pdf
THEORETICAL CONSTRUCTS
'ATD “postulates that any activity related to the production, diffusion or acquisition of
knowledge should be interpreted as an ordinary human activity, and thus proposes a
general model of human activity built on the key notion of praxeology” (Bosch &
Gascon, 2014). The praxeology 𝛱 is represented by a quadruple [𝑇/𝜏 /𝜃/𝛩]: its praxis
part (or know-how) consists of a type of tasks 𝑇 together with a corresponding
technique 𝜏 (useful to carry out the tasks 𝑡 ∈ 𝑇 in the scope of 𝜏). The logos part (or
know-why) includes two levels of description and justification: the technology 𝜃, i.e.
a discourse on the technique, and the theory 𝛩, which often unifies several
technologies.
The elaboration of a reference epistemological model (Florensa, Bosch, & Gascon,
2015) as sequences of praxeologies, for a given body of knowledge, is an important
step in any research carried out in the ATD framework. It is the tool that will be used
by the researcher to describe, analyse, put in question or design the specific contents that are at the core of a teaching and learning process. In order to build such a model,
“mathematical praxeologies are described using data from the different institutions
participating in the didactic transposition process, thus including historical, semiotic
and sociological research, assuming the institutionalized and socially articulated nature
of praxeologies” (loc. cit. p. 2637).' pp.498-499.
Charlotte Derouet, Gaetan Planchon, Thomas Hausberger, and Reinhard
Hochmuth. (2018). Bridging probability and calculus: the case of continuous distributions
and integrals at the secondary-tertiary transition. In PROCEEDINGS of INDRUM 2018
Second conference of the
International Network for Didactic
Research in University Mathematics. pp.497-506. ERME topic conference.
https://indrum2018.sciencesconf.org/data/Indrum2018Proceedings.pdf
I came across this source as I'd read about the way chemistry as a discipline co-opted some mathematical symbols, but adapted them for their own use.
Previously: 'math' : 'threshold concept' : 'liminal' : 'learning'