Here on W2tQ many posts have referred to '
common sense' over the years. Apparently, there is no such thing - which may be another blog post).
https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/too-many-goals/202005/theres-no-such-thing-common-sense
In 'Our Housing Disaster' Julian Richer is simultaneously analytic in identifying problems and potential solutions, logical and to me commonsensical. There is a need for debate and decisions at a political level. Residents, must also be involved, have a say. Chapter 10 lists shorter-term actions and longer-term.
The history of this disaster is tackled in chapter 3. Chapter 4 links very well explaining the rise of renting. If there was ever to be another edition - which the book and issue well-deserve; it would be good to a nod to evidence-based housing policy? This is suggested, as is integrating the many threads of housing; work, transport, infrastructure, shops, water and services. I've posted here about the number of
All-Party Parliamentary Groups and talk of joined-up government. Housing is anything but joined-up. You could argue all MPs and Lords should read this book.
Overall, the book is well produced, the text very readable, large size and well laid out. The 'references' for each chapter are in the form of links. Needless to say, I have only tried a few. The book seems smaller - narrower than a standard paperback, so may have fewer words / line. For posts i & ii, I extracted text from photos, which is a challenge without stressing the book's spine (as I've written before no doubt, I'm squeamish when it comes to books).
In the UK, the Right to Buy and Help to Buy, have long been a feature of housing policy. Of Help To Buy, it has 'cost taxpayers £29 billion in cash terms by 2023' (p.45) and has additional consequences. Milton Keynes is the 'right-to-buy-to-let' capital of England (2017, p.48). Surely, it is time to move on - and quickly. The history of how we got here is fascinating, like a slow car-crash with critical events that accelerated the inevitable. Taxpayers and citizens all: we have missed out. There is mention of preventing corruption (but yes, more effort on money-laundering and tax evasion please!). The need for buildings inspection, standards of construction and materials and responding to the climate crisis and high energy costs are also stressed.
Richer's stance is tempered, and sets an effective tone. He is not preaching, even as he points to land owned by the Church of England. I remember the NHS selling estate, and yet there is more. While the book is not long, an index would help. I like the final summarising and concluding sentences for each chapter. Physically, they are bound to be there obviously, but there's a welcome sensible thread to these imho. With an index, perhaps I could check back to look up 'productivity,
reduced', a problem that has plagued the UK economy. To what extent does housing contribute to this now; since the 1960s?
The King's Fund and many other organisations and commentators advocate daily for social care. While it is acknowledged, social care is not one of the government's 5 key 'missions', and now (5th Dec.) there are
milestones. Richer refers to the problem of bed-blocking in the NHS, and the need for suitable future housing so older adults can continue to 'live' in their homes.
So often in health we are taught, and learn to assess, plan, intervene, and evaluate a person-centred set of needs, a patient's needs, and a carer's needs. It is welcome to see a collective - population-based focus on needs. The book delivers on the title. So there are no details of nations (or cities) that have a much better housing system and controls. Over the years it's been interesting and encouraging to read about
Vienna in the FT. Below I have mapped/associated selected concepts to the care / knowledge domains of Hodges' model:
INDIVIDUAL
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
GROUP
psychological security
mental health
'my' home, my space
identity
peace of mind when costs met
facilitate well-being
memories
LAND - the 'hope' value
sense of continuity / permanence
children being safe making friends
access to 'GREEN' spaces
my life course - personal history
Cognitive assurance: my area -
family & friends / pets /school / work -
attachment |
LAND - UK geography
physical shelter physical health (NO damp, mould, noise...) House building targets/programmes my space/room having an address - identity displacement public/environment health eviction house building - infrastructure land - costs transport links bed-blocking in hospitals Climate Change
|
place to make a home
raise a family
belonging
sense of community
friends & neighbours
anti-social behaviour by tenants
social care - older adults
social care disabled
access to work, schools
resources to service a community
lack of spare capacity to support people & families in need/crisis |
the economy: interest/mortgage rates
indebtedness - poverty
housing POLICY :: COSTS
national housing & land assets
inspection and building standards
forms of tenure: private, rented, housing assoc.
LAW - housing & land legislation
housing rights
migration, refugees
independent advocacy / NGOs
compulsory purchase
|
Thank you Mr Richer for an excellent read and synopsis. I do hope the government listens! My daughter's partner works in estate agency, so I know where my copy is heading: a new home!
orcid.org/0000-0002-0192-8965
