Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: Search results for consent

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query consent. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query consent. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Living and Loving Dangerously

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group

identity - choices
 
Memory - Cognition
DEMENTIA - Early onset

Inability to consent
 
inhibition-disinhibition 

mental capacity
 


My liberty, my choices

"What! I'm married to you? Oh!"

Treatment - medication 

'Secure (safe)' environment

'Holistic assessment'?
 


Marital/Initimate Relationships
Social (our) identity

Existing relational behaviours

Interrelational needs
Interpersonal grief

Social identity/expectations

Yes, but we're married ... had 40 years together ...

Family bias, prejudices..
A 'new' step-parent ...

Access to support: 
relational - mutual vulnerability


Informed consent
Assumed consent

Rape, Sexual abuse, crime

Capacity to give consent

Consistency in decisions

Lasting power of attorney -
finance; health

External safeguards

Human rights

Access to supervision -
clinical & management


Prompts:

Previously post: Living and Caring Dangerously

Danny Leigh. Critic's choice - Films on release: Queen at Sea. Life&Arts, FTWeekend, 19/20 September, 2026, p.18.

https://depijp.rialtofilm.nl/en/films/queen-at-sea

So many difficult conversations. All on their own unique continuum in terms of sense-making for all concerned. 

A 'new' diagnosis at age 60; versus one at 44. Families seeking to control disclosure of the diagnosis from the patient. Clinical and family debate about this.

Finding a person locked-in the house, while their partner 'nips' to the shops. A person having their freedom to go out, on their regular walk  -despite acknowledged risks. (When they are known by people on their route - community care in action. Receiving a call from a neighbour; or the neighbour who knows where you park and can intercept you, on arrival or departure to express concerns. Or, even as you venture out for a walk with their neighbour of many a year. Categorise them as you will: [nosey, caring, concerned, public spirited, neighbourly, or (healthily) curious]?

Other discussions of grief at the loss of a person they have loved - in every way. A grief that presents new dark dimensions to what has gone before. Complicated by a state of early onset of memory loss. An ongoing disintegration of personhood and identity. An inability to consistently express thoughts, wishes, and choices. An inability to give informed consent. A loss taunted by retained physical desirability. What does love, sex, compassion mean now? What is the sum now, of love expressed over 'x' years? Hearts hollowed out, of what can be so important to a couple. Not vital to all. But for others, a source of conjoined affirmation, joy, warmth, companionship, a celebration of life and being human.

How to share that grief even amid close friends and family, who cannot cope themselves and withdraw? What of the preparedness of professions to manage such situations? What structures are in-place for team meetings, clinical supervision and inclusion in training, especially safeguarding?

From the bibliography (lower sidebar):

Hodges, B.E. (1989) The Health Career Model, IN, Hinchcliffe, S.M. (et al.) 1989 Nursing Practice and Health Care, 1st Edition only, London, Edward Arnold.

Adams, T. (1987) Dementia is a family affair. Community Outlook, Feb, 7-8.

Merritt MK, Procter N. Conceptualising the functional role of mental health consultation-liaison nurse in multi-morbidity, using Peplau's nursing theory. Contemp Nurse. 2010 Feb-Mar;34(2):158-66. doi: 10.5172/conu.2010.34.2.158. PMID: 20509800.

Murphy, K., Welford C. (2012) Agenda for the future: enhancing autonomy for older people in residential care.International Journal of Older People Nursing. 7, 75–80.

Kernohan, W. G., & Jones, P. (2023). Hodges’ Health Care Model as a Framework for Quality. Paper presented at Interprofessional work: developing oral care and the health workforce for the future, Brescia, Italy.
https://pure.ulster.ac.uk/en/publications/hodges-health-care-model-as-a-framework-for-quality

Jones, P. (2025). A Conceptual Mapping Exercise of Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards in Residential & Community Care Using Hodges' Model and Threshold Concepts. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70085. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70085

Jones, P. (2025), A Generic Model and Conceptual Framework to Prime Curiosity Across Health and Social Care Disciplines to Facilitate Lifelong Learning. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70252. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70252

Previously: 'capacity' : 'consent' : 'law' : 'safeguarding'


Monday, May 18, 2020

"Care Package" 4 the C.21st ?

"The CARE Package was the original unit
of aid distributed by the humanitarian organization
CARE (Cooperative for Assistance and Relief Everywhere)."
individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ----------------------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group - population

Disaster Conflict Refugee context?
Individual choices - 
facilitating autonomy 
whenever possible - Sign Language?
Mental health Care Plan
includes relapse prevention /
 Staying well / Self care
Mental capacity / Decision making
Physical health check
Patient Reported Outcomes*
Specific management of medication - lithium, psychotropics and safety completed and health literacy demonstrated with support if needed.
Making Every Contact Count -
in every care context
Psychological therapies 
One narrative: told recorded once
Cognitive access:
Health Information
Access to my health record
My Care - Why?
Understanding, Awareness
C[P]-Suite "I Consent" - My data,
Genetic Profile, Reimbursement?

INTEGRATED -
Disaster Conflict Refugee context?
Avoid admission, over-treatment
Quaternary Prevention
Preparation for Admission?
Physical Care Plan
includes relapse prevention /
 Staying well / Self care
If in-patient THEN is medication ordered and ready for discharge? e-Prescription?
Electronic Health Record
Mobility - aids, Transport
Advice / instructions
Wound / 
Dressing management
Making Every Contact Count -
in every care context
Clinic location: urban / rural
 transport 
Virtual - Telemedicine, e-Health
m-Health
Patient Reported Outcome Measures
Patient involvement in Research
Trials
Physical therapies - access
Physical access services/devices?

- CARE ?
Care IN the Community?
Housing :: Homeless?
Pre-discharge home visit -
e.g. Occupational Therapy?
Living alone?
Safety
Carers involved with due 
consent in care planning. 
Engaged in recognition and role of warning signs and actions to follow.
Recovery, Rehabilitation, Reablement
Awareness and shared competency in medication, in event of physical illness.
Patient/Family audit of clinical record: accuracy if/when appropriate BUT check completed.
Plan of care - activities, groups, information, arts, studies, 
volunteering.
Carers assessment
Social care.
Advance (anticipatory) care planning
Progress (this time) PRO*
Introduce respite care, day care, volunteering
Avoidance of admission:
this time :: next time?
[Finance of Health Service Delivery]
Care Package for specific groups / populations / circumstances: 
Forensic, Prison, Homeless, 
Substance Misuse, Veterans
Need for interpreter, advocacy?
Feedback on care experience:
patient and carer(s)
Management of Belongings, Cash
Community care - follow up instigated - introductions made with continuity of care (personnel) were possible.
Communication with (family) GP/Doctor
Out-of-hours services 
and contact details.
Patient & Carer invited to phone
purely as a trial-run.
Law - Policy? 72 hour, 7 Day -
follow-up at home.
Incidents - Complaints? Apologies?
Organisational Learning 
Welfare - Employment
Data capture and reporting of care spell/episode.
De-identified.
Reports submitted stats.
Reporting plans to Public re. Health Services
Public involvement in Services



The above is not comprehensive and in itself begs questions of scope and what is a 'comprehensive' care package?

The mapping above to Hodges' model includes many assumptions - existing health service provision, governance, finance, housing, social infrastructure - social determinants of health and how these are mitigated (if at all).

Tuesday, December 02, 2025

Auction: Twenty-two photographs of psychiatric patients at the Surrey County Lunatic Asylum [1850s]

DIAMOND, Dr Hugh Welch (1808–1886)

Twenty-two photographs of psychiatric patients at the Surrey County Lunatic Asylum [1850s]

Estimate - GBP 100,000 – GBP 200,000

Christie's London - December 10th 2025

https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-6564110?ldp_breadcrumb=back

Asylum patient by Hugh Welch Diamond, c1850-58
Asylum patient by Hugh Welch Diamond, c1850-58
Hugh Welch Diamond (English, 1808-1886)
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

'The women Iook out at us across 170 years of history with a variety of expressions - bold and shy, serene and distressed. Yet all of them were regarded at the time as "lunatics". These faces were the  subjects of a pioneering project by the 19th-century psychiatrist Hugh Welch Diamond, superintendent of the female division of an asylum in London and the world's first photographer to take pictures of patients for the purpose of diagnosis and therapy.

Twenty-two of Diamond's asylum portraits - the largest surviving group - will be put up for auction on December 10 at Christie's in London, as part of a sale of books, manuscripts and photographs from the library of The Royal Society of Medicine. If they achieve their estimated prices, RSM, a membership charity, will raise more than £2mn to invest in physical and digital infrastructure.' ...

'Diamond was working at a time when society's views of people suffering from mental illness were changing. The earlier practice of shutting patients away in secure "madhouses" was giving way to more humane treatment. Diamond seems to have believed that photography would help doctors both to diagnose and to treat patients. His diagnoses were based partly on the idea, popular in Victorian medical circles, that an individual's physiognomy - their physical features, particularly the face - could reveal their mental state.

"He wanted to make people better and put them back into the world," says Sharrona Pearl, a medical historian at Texas Christian University who has studied Diamond's work. "He also enjoyed experimenting and liked the idea of bridging his expertise in medicine and photography.' p.32.
individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic -------------------------------------------  mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group-population

Mental Illness
PERSON - SUBJECT
Patient's names not recorded
Portrait - Consent?

Diagnosis and Treatment
person - DATA - SUBJECT
Photography as records
Eagerness to classify - label
Social history
Change in social attitudes
Stigma and fear of mental illness
Current relatives?

Confidentiality
Institutional change
Power imbalance
Shift from 'custodial' to health care 


My source:
Clive Cookson, Mind Hunter, FT Magazine, November 15, 2025, 1151, pp.30-34.

I have noticed Prof. Brendan Kelly is a regular FT respondent, as with this article:

'These photographs were likely to have been taken without meaningful consent and in the context of power imbalance. Yet publication can reclaim their individuality, address historical injustice and underscore our common humanity. Compassion, respect and humility should guide decisions. 
 Proceeds should support medical, educational, or justice-oriented programmes. Most importantly honouring forgotten patients of the past demands better care for people with mental illness today, who often languish, neglected, in homeless hostels or prisons. We can do better.'

Brendan Kelly Professor of Psychiatry, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland.
Letters, FT Weekend. 22-23 November 2025, p.10.

See also: 'asylum' : 'photos'

Sunday, February 01, 2009

(Confidential) Letter to self - and you, and you, and you... ?

Hi PJ,

I'm wondering if you can help with something that's been troubling me a bit...?

You know that as a nurse (and future patient!) confidentiality (which increasingly relies on the security of ICT systems) is of course vital to your profession and professionalism both in theory and practice. Quite rightly take this for granted and you could be in serious trouble, with your job in jeopardy.

I’ve been wondering about the way that Jo-public views their personal health information and clinical record and how these views have evolved over the past decade and how they will change in the next 5, 10 .... years? A change that will have major implications for definitions and the meanings of record, access, sharing, personalised, and professional. This is also one of those slippery slopes; since it will be very difficult to get that emerging genie back in the bottle. The clinical record even with new consent models will increasingly make it a currency for exchange within a *wider* community given the rise of electronic and personal health records, Health 2.0, 3.0…. By 'community' I mean one not just restricted to health and social care organizations, but one that could be much more extensive.

There are a lot of tools out there in the public domain that enable the creation of new portals, services to which other agencies can add value. This is not a problem: 'value-added services' is one definition of progress.

The problem is the pace of change and the extent.


Health has always been commodified. Recently on the news I heard that a kidney is probably worth 1.5 million dollars (https://www.newkerala.com).

Perhaps for the ‘professions’ given the sanctity of clinical records this is the
ultimate trip?

Any thoughts or directions to references…?

Many thanks and best regards,

'Your other half'
P.S. People had better be careful when they mix personalised and professional - that's quite a potent concoction. I wonder if you can sell it?

Additional links / reading:


Viewpoint Paper

A Research Agenda for Personal Health Records (PHRs)
David C. Kaelber, Ashish K. Jha, Douglas Johnston, Blackford Middleton and David W. Bates
Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, Volume 15, Issue 6, November-December 2008, Pages 729-736.

Abstract:

Patients, policymakers, providers, payers, employers, and others have increasing interest in using personal health records (PHRs) to improve healthcare costs, quality, and efficiency. While organizations now invest millions of dollars in PHRs, the best PHR architectures, value propositions, and descriptions are not universally agreed upon. Despite widespread interest and activity, little PHR research has been done to date, and targeted research investment in PHRs appears inadequate. The authors reviewed the existing PHR specific literature (100 articles) and divided the articles into seven categories, of which four in particular— evaluation of PHR functions, adoption and attitudes of healthcare providers and patients towards PHRs, PHR related privacy and security, and PHR architecture—present important research opportunities. We also briefly discuss other research related to PHRs, PHR research funding sources, and PHR business models. We believe that additional PHR research can increase the likelihood that future PHR system deployments will beneficially impact healthcare costs, quality, and efficiency.


From the above:

Markle Foundation http://www.markle.org

Robert Wood Johnson Foundation http://www.rwjf.org


Considering something ‘ELSE’: Ethical, legal and socio-economic factors in medical imaging and medical informatics
Penny Duquenoy, Carlisle George, Anthony Solomonides
Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, Volume 92, Issue 3, December 2008, Pages 227-237.
Abstract:
The focus on the use of existing and new technologies to facilitate advances in medical imaging and medical informatics (MIMI) is often directed to the technical capabilities and possibilities that these technologies bring. The technologies, though, in acting as a mediating agent alter the dynamics and context of information delivery in subtle ways. While these changes bring benefits in more efficient information transfer and offer the potential of better healthcare, they also disrupt traditional processes and practices which have been formulated for a different setting. The governance processes that underpin core ethical principles, such as patient confidentiality and informed consent, may no longer be appropriate in a new technological context. Therefore, in addition to discussing new methodologies, techniques and applications, there is need for a discussion of ethical, legal and socio-economic (ELSE) issues surrounding the use and application of technologies in MIMI. Consideration of these issues is especially important for the area of medical informatics which after all exists to support patients, healthcare practitioners and inform science. This paper brings to light some important ethical, legal and socio-economic issues related to MIMI with the aim of furthering an interdisciplinary approach to the increasing use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in healthcare.

 
Situation-Based Access Control: Privacy management via modeling of patient data access scenariosMor Peleg, Dizza Beimel, Dov Dori, Yaron Denekamp
Journal of Biomedical Informatics, Volume 41, Issue 6, December 2008, Pages 1028-1040.
Abstract:
Access control is a central problem in privacy management. A common practice in controlling access to sensitive data, such as electronic health records (EHRs), is Role-Based Access Control (RBAC). RBAC is limited as it does not account for the circumstances under which access to sensitive data is requested. Following a qualitative study that elicited access scenarios, we used Object-Process Methodology to structure the scenarios and conceive a Situation-Based Access Control (SitBAC) model. SitBAC is a conceptual model, which defines scenarios where patient’s data access is permitted or denied. The main concept underlying this model is the Situation Schema, which is a pattern consisting of the entities Data-Requestor, Patient, EHR, Access Task, Legal-Authorization, and Response, along with their properties and relations. The various data access scenarios are expressed via Situation Instances. While we focus on the medical domain, the model is generic and can be adapted to other domains.


Picker Inst. http://www.pickereurope.org/


Saturday, November 07, 2026

Government: policymakers & APPGs need Hodges' model

Press release Nov. 3

Child Trust Fund injustice to end under Government plans

Young people lacking the mental capacity to make financial decisions will finally have easier access to their Child Trust Funds. 

Young people lacking the mental capacity to make financial decisions will finally have easier access to their savings, ending a long-standing injustice that has created unnecessary barriers for families. 

Following years of campaigning and legal difficulties faced by families, new legislation will be introduced by the Government to allow simpler access to Child Trust Funds, replacing the complex and often costly Court of Protection process.  

The reforms are expected to allow parents and carers to go directly to Child Trust Fund providers to access savings, solving years of unnecessary anguish for an estimated 63,000 to 126,000 young adults. 

Child Trust Funds were introduced in 2005 to provide children a financial boost as they start adulthood, but the scheme made no provision for 18-year-olds who lacked the mental capacity to manage their finances without a straightforward way to access their savings.  

Campaigners, disability charities, and the financial services sector will help shape the new process, protecting young people while pulling down barriers that have frustrated families for years. 

Justice Minister, Jake Richards said: 

Young people who lack the mental capacity to make financial decisions should be able to access their savings as easily as possible – especially when this money was put aside by loved ones to help them take their first steps into adulthood. 

This is simply an injustice that we’re finally putting right and as campaigners have argued for years, change is long overdue. This legislation will ensure this group of young adults no longer face difficulty from accessing money that is rightfully theirs.

Continued ...
individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
HUMANISTIC ------------------------------------------------ MECHANISTIC
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group

Mental capacity

Consent

Disability - Learning Disability

Accessibility

Childhood - Adulthood

Processes - Systems

Families

Social (in-)justice

Activism

Child Trust Funds

Policy making

Policy


My source: BBC Radio 4 Today 0700-0900 7th Nov 2026

Previously: 'consent' : 'mental capacity' : 'APPG'

Saturday, May 31, 2025

Globally - seeking the ink of scholars

The Ink of the Scholars:
Reflections on Philosophy in Africa


Since the late 1980s, in trying to understand Hodges' model, especially its political dimensions beyond nurses as advocates, the mental health act, choice and self-determination. To be followed by consent, then informed consent, mental capacity, human rights, equality, protected characteristics, safeguarding, equity, social in-justice; I've then questioned my assumed neutrality of the model. 

Allied to this is the fact that Hodges' model is one of many models and frameworks, largely created in the developed world. What alternative viewpointsof nursing, care and philosophies are there? Do these challenge Hodges' model? Or, can Hodges' model also encompass them, in a complementary manner?

Serendipity, or ADHD, seems to follow me around. In addition determined to extract value from my purchase and reading of the weekend FT, I learned of potential key read:


Prempeh, C. THE AESTHETE. Koyo Kouoh, The curator of 2026 Venice Biennale talks whisky sours, working from bed and being the "high priestess of the okra church". HTSI, FTWeekend, 3 May 2025,pp.21-22.

'THE BEST BOOK I'VE READ IN THE PAST YEAR is a book on African philosophers, The Ink of the Scholars: Reflections on Philosophy in Africa, by Souleymane Bachir Diagne, one of our most brilliant thinkers. He challenges the idea that there isn't a philosophical framework to African societies. There are ideas around Africans being the great architects of hospitality and Diagne reflects on what the African approach to humanity is. What does it mean to be careful, mindful and caring? It's not just about welcoming people to your home or feeding them. Hospitality is carrying people, making people feel comfortable in your environment - it's intellectual and emotional. Everyone should read Diagne, full stop.' p.21. 
 

Shocked: I have just read of Koyo Kouoh's passing - RIP. 

Souleymane Bachir Diagne, & Jonathan Adjemian. (2016, May 23). The Ink of the Scholars: Reflections on Philosophy in Africa. CODESRIA Books Publication System. CODESRIA
https://publication.codesria.org/index.php/pub/catalog/book/40

See also: 'hospitality'

Thursday, October 06, 2022

PROCESS 0 : 4 DOMAINS

No, 0 - 4 is not a sports score.   

Quite a while ago and over several years I associated 4P's with each of the domains of the model:

SCIENCES: process
SOCIOLOGY: practice
POLITICAL: policy
INTRA- INTERPERSONAL: purpose

 
Although, this brings home the model's being an idealisation - there remains much to learn and discover. In addition to physical processes there are political, psychological, social processes too. If you were to prioritise the concept of PROCESS across the model how would you do this?
 
My take - which could (will) differ tomorrow - and could well do so if the context was specific. 
 
I've tended to think of triage, physical and psychiatric emergencies the focus being on the SCIENCE domain (ABC medical emergency...!) and that is the starting point. If triage is excluded, then #MyNameIs follows crucially in obtaining a comprehensive assessment and addressing 1-1 parity of esteem. There is a need to (really) attend to the INTERPERSONAL domain.
 
In a way the 'individual' domains INTERPERSONAL - SCIENCES should (must) collapse into one. This is to help assure, strive to achieve person-centred and integrated care; and not to reduce, rationalise, and generalise the nurse curriculum. We need mental health nurses equipped for the 21st century.
 
Reflecting on this though I'm jumping ahead.
 
We actually start with the POLITICAL domain 0 - below. With nurses in the UK being balloted on strike action this is difficult medicine to swallow, but there we are. Globally, we saw the literal power of the POLITICAL domain in health during the (ongoing) pandemic. We will do so again in future security, health, and climate challenges to follow. We don't want future generations to face ours, they will have their own.

 INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP
3
1
2
0

Spiritual - 4

So, in 0 is there an advanced directive? Even before this, can I as a nurse, or other practitioner - nurse, treat, care ... for this person? Do we have consent - can they give consent? Is there a Dr 'in the house', a responsible medic? Have they been admitted, their referral accepted and acknowledged? Are there cultural or religious reasons not to proceed as we might otherwise? POLICY, safety, protocol also dictates that if we are a first responder then we do not become a casualty - that is obviously undesirable. So we are checking the environment (SCIENCES domain 1*) - the specific context.

THEN - I'm selecting 2 the SOCIOLOGY domain. The information obtained from the person (if any) is crucial to what follows. The 'if any' is non-trivial too were the INTERPERSONAL domain 3 is concerned (and the aforementioned collapse [3-1]. Even if the person declines, or is unable to communicate with us, we can still glean essential details about physical AND mental status. So, yes, the specialist skills of the practitioner and lived experienced colleagues really do matter.

With the SPIRITUAL domain (which can encompass the model) we close a circle, back to the religious, cultural, human rights and values dimensions acknowledged above. This conjunction of political and spiritual is a little surprising in global terms, and so maybe encouraging too.

*Yes, the SOCIOLOGY domain 2 also. You may think you are only going to visit a 79 year old man/women; not realising that their grandchild also arrives with a forensic history. This could be a very positive rewarding encounter, or otherwise.


Monday, November 28, 2022

Medical sociology ... "food for thought" c/o POHG

I replied to the message copied below by Alex Scott-Samuel on the Politics of Health Group Mail List. Following up with respondents, I have copied Alex's reply and others:

----- Forwarded message -----
From: Alex Scott-Samuel <alexscottsamuel AT gmail.com>
To: "pohg AT jiscmail.ac.uk" <pohg AT jiscmail.ac.uk>
Sent: Saturday, 26 November 2022 at 13:05:25 GMT
Subject: [POHG] Illich

Just came across this from 19 years ago: still offers food for thought
 
[The graphic file downloaded should be legible. PJ]
 

*************************************
Politics of Health Group Mail List Messages
*************************************

Visit the PoHG website for lots of interesting links and publications: http://www.pohg.org.uk/
PoHG on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/282761111845400
Follow us on Twitter: @pohguk
You can subscribe to / unsubscribe from the PoHG mail list here: http://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/POHG

====================

On 26 Nov 2022, at 17:46, peter jones <h2cmng AT yahoo.co.uk> wrote:

Thanks Alex,

This is very useful - short but very sweet and as you say food for thought - especially in our (ongoing) consumptogenic age.

You've prompted a draft blog-post I will add an acknowledgement and link to POHG.

I've no evidence, that is reading, so what follows are thoughts ... musings ... but I keep wondering: what has happened to 'medical sociology'?

Is medical (health) sociology - history as a discipline?
Is there ongoing development - has the discipline morphed into others?
Is there a case to stress not only public health, but public MENTAL health? As I often do. Am I over-reacting?
In information technology there is talk of functionality being placed in wrappers. Has sociology been subsumed - it's there - but underneath - policy rhetoric (integrated, person-centred, holistic care)?

Who are the leading current figures - and recent equivalents of -

"Aaron Antonovsky (19 December 1923 – 7 July 1994) was an Israeli American sociologist and academic whose work concerned the relationship between stress, health and well-being (salutogenesis)."

Canguilhem
Virchow ...?


Should I take heart by the arrival of the SDGs, and the recognition of not only the social determinants of health, but political and commercial too and others..?

I keep writing regarding the potential and utility of Hodges' model:


Thanks again,

Peter
====

----- Forwarded message -----
From: Alex Scott-Samuel <alexscottsamuel AT gmail.com>
Cc: "pohg AT jiscmail.ac.uk" <pohg AT jiscmail.ac.uk>
Sent: Saturday, 26 November 2022 at 18:41:10 GMT
Subject: Re: [POHG] Illich - wither et al. ?

Interesting questions Peter. I sense that the answers are out there but not necessarily concentrated in this list. Although I retired from academic public health almost 7 years ago, I have no reason to think that what is now called the sociology of health and illness is not as strong as ever. The kind of places I would look are on the one hand journals such as Sociology of Health and Illness, Social Science & Medicine and Critical Public Health and on the other, popular outlets such as Laurie Taylor's Radio 4 programme Thinking Allowed. 

As far as I know the Medical Sociology Group of the British Sociological Association still exists and holds regular conferences. There has for many years been a Journal of Public Mental Health though it's a while since I've looked at it

Antonovsky's ideas were popular in the health promotion field as well as in academic social science. I remember that a number of people in the WHO Healthy Cities movement were interested in salutogenesis. I've not thought about it for many years but I was on a research group with Antonovsky in the mid 80s when he was developing his Sense of Coherence construct. I  I have to say that despite the attractiveness of problematising health rather than sickness, I never thought the sense of coherence was adequately or well theorised. I do recall seeing quite a few papers from people who rushed out to measure the coherence of people in various situations using the tool which Antonovsky produced. I don't know whether this kind of work continues nor whether it developed

All the best, Alex
=============

----- Forwarded message -----
From: Alderson, Priscilla <p.alderson AT ucl.ac.uk>
Sent: Saturday, 26 November 2022 at 18:55:08 GMT
Subject: Re: [POHG] Illich - wither et al. ?

Dear Peter,

My book Critical Realism for Health and Illness Research: A Practical Introduction (Policy Press 2021) reviews the main traditions in medical sociology and critically updates sociology research that is relevant to the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond. The medical sociologists are the largest subgroup among all UK sociologists.

best wishes
Priscilla

Priscilla Alderson PhD,  Professor Emerita,  

Social Research Institute, University College London,
18 Woburn Square, London WC1H ONR p.alderson AT ucl.ac.uk     

http://iris.ucl.ac.uk/iris/browse/profile?upi=DPALD60  

   

Alderson P. 2021 Critical Realism for Health and Illness Research. Policy Press. 

Winner of the IACR Cheryl Frank award 2022.

Children’s consent to heart surgery research website:  

https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/departments-and-centres/centres/social-science-research-unit/consent-and-shared-decision-making-healthcare/heart-surgery

Alderson, P. and Morgan, J. 2022 Realist by inclination, childhood studies, dialectic and bodily concerns: an interview. Journal of Critical Realism, 10.1080/14767430.2022.2068261
Alderson P, Morrow V. 2020 The Ethics of Research with Children and Young People: A Practical Handbook. SAGE.

=============
 
----- Forwarded message -----
From: Eileen O'Keefe <e.okeefe57 AT gmail.com>
To: Alex Scott-samuel <alexscottsamuel AT gmail.com>;
Cc: Professor Lesley Doyal <l.doyal AT bristol.ac.uk>
Sent: Sunday, 27 November 2022 at 19:52:16 GMT
Subject: Lesley Doyal

Dear Peter and Alex
 
Lesley Doyal set the agenda simultaneously with Illich with her Political Economy of Health. She continues to lead the pack re socially produced global inequities in health, eg her Living with HIV and Dying with AID: diversity, inequality and human rights in the global pandemic. Routledge Global Health Series. 2013.

Cheers
Eileen O’Keefe
===========

<->

By way of background:

I've always been impressed (in awe of) and reassured by 'medical sociology', the pioneers (as above), as a discipline, and in terms of sociology's explanatory potential.

Another - not so much an 'explanation' but an avenue to explore, has long been the continuum of care (yes, just one initially?). This spans the need for compassion, empathy, rapport, allied with the importance of hands - in nursing, medicine, surgery ... their being steady, vision true with rapid, safe, reliable, effective judgement and decision-making. In short, the need for humanistic and mechanistic synergy. Finding, and taking up Hodges' model perhaps this can account for the idea of holistic bandwidth(?).

It is an exaggeration surely, but it feels like I made two simultaneous connections in first reading psychology and philosophy. These are mind - body, and the way that many in society are 'remote' from science (knowledge), for a variety of reasons. Sociology can help account for those reasons.

Seeing (literally) the potential of visualization (as posted on W2tQ and in papers) in the 1970s, in 1990s research programs were dedicated to facilitate the development and application of visualization in the humanities. Visualization should not just be the preserve of high energy physics, bio-science and proteomics ... (although the attraction to what is 'quantifiable' is understandable). This is the question that drives this effort (I think!).

So the 'humanities' still have a requirement in information systems, informatics and literacy terms, and Hodges' model can, I believe, offer a way forward.

The replies above are much appreciated and I will follow them up.


Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Oh dear! I forgot to ask the nurse (doctor)....

Hodges' model introduction II:

The view from the other side of the fence


Have you ever been to see the doctor or nurse and shortly after leaving the surgery, or clinic you've remembered something? These days - very sadly - many people go to the doctor to seek help for their memory, but for others this is a fact of that frustrating mix of vital questions and issues to raise amid recognition that the time of nurses and doctors is very precious.

This post introduces a framework that can help people to prepare for a consultation and maintain a record of just where their care situation is up to. The framework in question is called Hodges' model. It is named after a retired Senior Lecturer - Mr Brian E. Hodges who lives in Sheffield, England. Brian Hodges created the model to help nurses and community staff ensure the care they deliver is holistic. Holistic in this sense means covering all the essential aspects that contribute to health and well-being, so that includes physical, emotional and mental and even spiritual health.

If you need to go into hospital you do not want to be treated like a faulty machine. Of course, in an emergency those machine-like things we do like heart beat, respiration, temperature regulation are of central importance. Should you ever need emotional care for a severe mental health problem then you would also expect that your physical needs are taken fully into account. Amidst these aspects of care the health care team must also pay attention to culture, equality, diversity and access to services.

Although the model was developed in the 1980s its relevance and potential increases in all the time. This is because of the following:

* health care and medicine is increasingly complex;
* people may have long term and multiple chronic problems;
* education is essential to 21st century care management - as people are expected to 'self-care';
- people may also be managing their own care budget and so need information and 360 vision;
* policy makers stress the need for 'patient choice';
* high quality health and social care is very expensive;
* as people live longer and may have several relationships spanning cultures and belief systems the notion of a health career is the career.

Hodges' model builds on two basic facts of life (and death):

From your point of view and that of any health or social care professional your health is about you - an INDIVIDUAL.

Your health affects other people - most significantly your family. Rather than you being ill, you may of course be a carer having to look after a relative. Also affected are work colleagues, the wider community through to whole GROUPS of people.

We now talk about medicine, well-being, and health in terms of global health since the population of Earth is so tightly linked and interdependent.

In order to maintain health there is a need to diagnose and intervene - or assess, plan, intervene and evaluate. Here the model can also take into account ethnic and transcultural aspects of health. Diagnosis and intervention in Western medicine is frequently MECHANISTIC and this is balanced (remember that HOLISTIC part of the model) by the need for HUMANISTIC interventions. This is what we mean by 'bedside manner' and people being 'caring'. The ability to empathise with others and develop a therapeutic rapport after physical and emotional trauma is a great gift - that while often innate can also be learned and honed.

Once Brian Hodges had identified the following dimensions of care:

INDIVIDUAL - GROUP and HUMANISTIC - MECHANISTIC

he considered the types of knowledge that health and social care workers need to not only do their job safely, effeciently and effectively, but also help people to help themselves. This led to the FOUR CARE or KNOWLEDGE DOMAINS, each covers a key aspect of care:

SCIENCES: e.g. anatomy, physiology,healing process, drugs, risk, diagnosis...

INTRAPERSONAL: e.g. mood, thinking, beliefs, communication, education, learning, coping...

SOCIOLOGY: e.g. relationships, roles, meaning, groups, resources

POLITICAL: e.g. choice, consent, autonomy, policy, legislation, finances

Students - young and mature - who decide to study health and social care can use the model to help them reflect on critical events in their training and learning. The model can help them gain some insights in completing essays and case studies integrating knowledge and experience. When you think about it: if it essential that care professionals are able to have an effective dialogue with patients and the public then they should also be capable of having an effective 'dialogue' with themselves.

Members of the public can also be taught the model to help them appreciate the factors involved in their care programs, solutions and ongoing management if required. Hopefully this brief explanation sheds some light on the model's mantra:

Hodges' Health Career (Care Domains) Model: h2cm
h2cm: help 2C more - help 2 listen - help 2 care

Hodges' model is no universal panacea it is just a tool; but while services stress the need for person-centered, integrated, value-for-money, high quality services ... built on respect, dignity, trust and choice - YOUR health career matters.

h2cm can help pull the many threads together....

<>

On the website's homepage there are four introductions based upon the care domains. Each one addresses a particular audience: learners (SCIENCES); patient (INTRAPERSONAL); carer (SOCIOLOGY) and policy maker / manager (POLITICAL). They all need updating (re-writing?!).

If you would like to contribute to this exercise please contact me through twitter or at h2cmng at yahoo.co.uk

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Call for Papers: Bioethics and Philosophical Health - JECP

Submission Deadline: Thursday, 31 December 2026

Contemporary bioethics has developed sophisticated tools for ethical decision-making. Yet it often operates within assumptions that reduce life to physiological viability. Ethical questions are frequently treated as matters of procedure and consent. Meanwhile, patients and clinicians face questions that exceed these frameworks. What makes a life worth living? How does illness disrupt or reveal meaning? What forms of care support not just survival but existential coherence? These questions call for a deeper engagement between bioethics and the philosophy of existence.

Despite growing interest in person-centred care, conceptual tools for clinical evaluation remain limited. Frameworks for assessing philosophical sense-making and existential orientation are underdeveloped. The Philosophical Health perspective addresses this gap by going beyond physical and psychological health. It asks how we cultivate meaningful lives through bodily experience, self-understanding, relational belonging, engagement with possibility, purposeful action, and philosophical reflection. The concept draws on the ancient tradition of bios philosophikos. It proposes that healthcare should attend not only to pathology but to the philosophical dimensions of human existence.

This special issue creates space for exploring how philosophical health can deepen bioethical inquiry as an embodied ethics of the good life. It challenges reductive assumptions and fosters practices that support purpose and meaning in lives, even when disrupted by health challenges. We welcome transdisciplinary contributions from philosophers, bioethicists, clinicians, medical humanists, and social scientists. Topics include how philosophical frameworks enrich clinical practice, how healthcare shapes existential experience, how the 4E cognitive approach may inform bioethical theory, and how dialogical methodologies can be integrated into institutional contexts. The issue aims to rediscover bioethics as a genuinely philosophical and existential enterprise, that is as bios ethikos.

Topics of interest for this call for papers include but are not restricted to:

  • Philosophical frameworks for enriching or transforming bioethical practice and clinical evaluation;
  • Philosophical dimensions of clinical encounters: embodiment, selfhood, temporality, and meaning-making;
  • Critiques of the reduction of ethical deliberation to procedure, regulation, or risk management;
  • How healthcare practices shape or constrain the philosophical dimensions of human existence;
  • The 4E cognitive approach (embodied, extended, enactive, embedded) applied to bioethical theory and practice;
  • Integration of philosophical inquiry and dialogical methods into clinical or institutional contexts;
  • Empirical and conceptual engagement with the Philosophical Health methodology, including SMILE_PH;
  • Cross-cultural and planetary perspectives on philosophical health and the good life;
  • Methodological innovations in clinical philosophy, philosophical counselling, and reflective practice.
More details here: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/page/journal/13652753/call-for-papers/si-2026-000772


_______

Dr Luis de Miranda
Associate Professor (Docent) in Bioethics, Uppsala University
Marie Skłodowska-Curie Fellow, Turku Institute for Advanced Studies
Associated Researcher, Centre for Research Ethics and Bioethics,
Department of Public Health and Caring Sciences, Uppsala University
https://www.luisdemiranda.com/

My source: Philos-L "The Liverpool List" is run by the Department of Philosophy, University of Liverpool https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/philosophy/philos-l/ Messages to the list are archived at http://listserv.liv.ac.uk/archives/philos-l.html. Follow the list on Twitter @PhilosL. Follow the Department of Philosophy @LiverpoolPhilos

Monday, October 10, 2022

World Mental Health Day: Forms of Esteem ...

Tua Tagovailoa
Miami Dolphins, Quarterback


 INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP

psychological trauma
(or^, personal trauma)


personal choice

Identity

Memory


Motivation

My.. 'Skill-set'

SELF-ESTEEM


Expectations:
*on the field
*off the field


physical trauma


"Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy"

motor impairment

"He lost consciousness as he instinctively assumed the "fencing position" position and his fingers curled and tightened."

"Bennet Omalu, the neuropathologist who discovered CTE in American football players, watched the Dolphins v Bengals game in horror. He messaged Tagovailoa, saying: .."



social (family) trauma

my children's names


"[ Bennet Omalu ]... If you love your life, if you love your family, your kids - if you have kids, it's time to gallantly walk away. Go find something else to do. Tua, my brother. I love you. I love you as much as I love my son. Stop playing. Stop. Hang your helmet and gallantly walk away."

'pluralistic ignorance'

'Plausible ignorance'

Informed consent
MENTAL CAPACITY
High risk - High reward

"Think of what is still happening in the NFL, of what is happening in rugby, and soon you reach the conclusion that players need to be protected from themselves. Something their sports are absolutely not doing." p.24.

PARITY OF ESTEEM


David Walsh, Latest NFL concussion scandal is a sickening indictment of ... Sport, The Sunday Times, October 9th, 2022, p.24. (Paper copy.)

Mr Walsh also refers to - Head On: Rugby, Dementia and Me (BBC 2 TV)

^ Person-centred?