Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: unique

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts with label unique. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unique. Show all posts

Thursday, July 31, 2025

'Nurse as Engineer' by Josefson

'Engineering' and 'architecture' have both been co-opted by cross-disciplinary explorers to help traverse what are usually cravasses between disparate fields. Or, if not a serious journey - more a day-trip than an expedition, it's an effort to create the impression of progress being (rapidly) made. Fields of knowledge being pulled - fused-together. These are transdisciplinary times:

'Individualization is best achieved in the engineering model, in which cach patient is seen as a unique case. The nurse collects and analyses the patients' data to arriye at a diagnosis, which includes, but is not limited to, issues that concern medical diagnosis and treatment. "The nurse sets obiectives based on knowledge and experience of what is desirable and achievable and designs an individualized care plan by selecting from a known repertoire of nursing interventions those most likely to lead to achievement of the objectives. After implementing the interventions, the nurse evaluates their effectiveness by comparing the client's subsequent condition with previous diagnoses and objectives."

In the last model - the non-routine model, which is a research model - the patient is still seen as unique. The problem is that the search procedures cannot be analysed because more judgement and intuition is required in making decisions.' p.25.

n.b. Two other models are described: the nurse acting as a craftsman; and the routine.

Josefson asks in a section (pp.28-29):

Who draws the boundary between Man and Machine?

Who - indeed!

Ingela Josefson. The nurse as engineer—the theory of knowledge in research in the care sector. In.  Knowledge, Skill and Artificial Intelligence. Bo Göranzon & Ingela Josefson (Eds). (1988), ISBN038719519X. pp.19–30. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.

In the above paper/chapter Josefson draws upon the work of Katie Eriksson and Judy Ozbolt.

Previously: 'engineer' : 'architecture'

Friday, April 26, 2024

Buses, Eddie Stobart, Lego and Laughing Boy

Individual
|
   INTERPERSONAL   :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
Group

person - personality
personal duty of care
emotional care
experience

buses - Eddie Stobart - Lego
space - time
1-day Physical care  Another day
the sound of laughter


Source: Twi/X + image:

Friday, April 07, 2023

Is Hodges' Model anathema to 'Extant Nursing Theories' ?

 INDIVIDUAL
|

 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|


"Are the extant nursing theories endangered species? Some nurse leaders think so. A cursory review of major nursing journals reveals the conspicuous absence of articles using nursing theories as guides to research and practice. These articles are often written by seasoned scholars and doctoral students in nursing, yet nursing science is absent. How can this be when PhD students are being prepared to be knowledge builders for the discipline and their teachers are the seasoned scholars?

This question took center stage in a recent international gathering of nurse researchers and theoreticians."

Parse RR. Are the Extant Nursing Theories Endangered Species? Nursing Science Quarterly. 2023;36(2):109-109. doi:10.1177/08943184221150254
 
 
Hodges' Model is a stranger in a strange land; and as usual I am writing from Wigan Pier - so vastly differing contexts and experiences acknowledged.
 
Whatever its status as a model of nursing, model of care, conceptual framework, nursing theory (level 'x'); as the editorial indicates, if the model were to have a 'home' it might be the USA with its nursing science PhD programmes. 
 
Clearly, this is not the case.
 
Unsuccessful in trying to learn of the international event mentioned, I can take encouragement from Hodges' model being 'stateless' and as such, being global, local and glocal in scope. There is succour in having an origin the model can call home here in the NW England (literal - person-centredness).

The medicalisation of nursing science may be an issue for PhD programmes in the USA, but the inter- multi- transdisciplinary potential of Hodges' model can encompass this - preserving and even assuring disciplinary identity as needed. An original purpose of the model was also curriculum design, and development.
"In all university systems it is the faculty and administrators of nursing programs who make curriculum decisions. These same faculty and administrators promulgate the use of theories from other disciplines to guide nursing research for PhD dissertations. What is wrong with this picture?"
I would suggest it is not 'big' - rich enough.

"What is the uniqueness of nursing as a discipline when medical science content has replaced the nursing theories and frameworks in PhD programs? The extant theories and frameworks concretized nursing as a unique discipline different from medicine in the 20th century. Can nursing now be distinguished from medicine when the content of PhD programs is bereft of extant nursing theories and frameworks?"

Yes, nursing can and is being distinguished from medicine and all other disciplines: abstraction and scope of practice are key. 

So many 'literature searches' are incomplete (but I would say that).

It is actually a sad state of affairs should PhD programmes of study be the primary motivation for the development of nursing science. This is the 21st Century.

Nursing should be defined by the needs of national and global populations and associated national and global policy - especially ongoing gaps in those needs.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Holistic care striking a balance: Dance halls and the steps we take

I was reminded recently of these research related terms:

NOMOTHETIC -

Of or relating to the study or discovery of general scientific laws.

IDIOGRAPHIC -

Concerned with establishing the uniqueness of a phenomenon:
an individual, a place, or a region, for example.

These words struck me due to the way that Hodges' model can encompass them courtesy of the INDIVIDUAL-GROUP and HUMANISTIC-MECHANISTIC axes.

You know those arcade and now home based interactive dance games where the player dances on a pad?: well if Hodges' model is a dance hall and the concepts we use (the semantic web) comprise the dance steps; then if we focus on one side only (self?) we would essentially be standing on one foot - dancing with one half of our body or may be even a quarter.

Come on.
Yes of course - "at your own risk".
Stand up, move the chair out of the way and do your groove thing!

Try it!

Do you feel a bit silly?

OK, OK, it's no use,

Alright!

I confess!

While I try to be holistic, that's how I dance...

Image source adapted from:
http://www.uniqlo.jp


Answers.com - definitions