Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: Search results for alcohol

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts sorted by date for query alcohol. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query alcohol. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Paper: 'Lost for words: anxiety, well-being, and the costs of conceptual deprivation'

Dr Munch-Jurisic's paper provides many points that can help demonstrate the holistic bandwidth of Hodges' model. When I read 'conceptual deprivation' in the title, it reminded me of a question. Can Hodges' model inoculate the user against conceptual deprivation, to a degree (at least)? Student nurses have a conceptual framework which highlights the political realm. The model is taught with the point that student's need a metaphoric sword and shield. The sword because they will encounter power, and the politics in health, and health in politics. 

A lack of holistic bandwidth may also result in a lack of integrated, holistic care? 

Aged 17, on my first mental health ward, a mixed-sex admission ward. I was 'lost for words' when as a nursing assistant, a patient, who was very quiet asked: how on earth I thought I could understand her problems? A woman in her 80s at least, I was stopped in my tracks. We agreed finally I could try. 

There are other points for all users of Hodges' model about the literacies in Hodges' model. Once again that means all of them. The student unfamiliar with being away from family, let alone from a remote, rural to an urban environment, exposes them to all sorts of experiences. Substance and alcohol misuse, are never confined to cities (county-lines UK). The first-use of cannabis might reveal a psychotic-like reaction. Working in Manchester I had a few students on my caseload, working through this difficult - with family, friends and early intervention in support. I'm still reading ...

Abstract 

A range of contemporary voices argue that negative affective states like distress and anxiety can be morally productive, broaden our epistemic horizons and, under certain conditions, even contribute to social progress. But the potential benefits of stress depend on an agent’s capacity to constructively interpret their affective states. An inability to do so may be detrimental to an agent’s wellbeing and mental health. The broader political, cultural, and socio-economic context shapes the kinds of stressors agents are exposed to, but it also delineates the hermeneutic equipment they have available to interpret their stress. To explain this specific problem of conceptual deprivation, philosophical theories on wellbeing and anxiety need to move beyond individualist perspectives. 

Keywords: Stress · Distress · Discomfort · Affect · Anxiety · Well-being

Munch-Jurisic, D. M. (2021). Lost for words: anxiety, well-being, and the costs of conceptual deprivation. Synthese, 199(5/6), 13583–13600. https://www.jstor.org/stable/48691612

Sunday, July 12, 2026

Level Headed Questions about Identity

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group

Individual - Person
IDENTITY
 Personality
Character
Traits
 
Spiritual identity
 
Religious identity


brain in a vat 
thought experiment
  
SPIRIT level
 
 
'LEVEL HEAD'

Social identity (cohesion)

Collective & Cultural identity
 
Role & Family identity
 
Relational identity
Languages

media(-ted) identities

Local / Regional identity

National identity:
North-South :: West-East divide

Organisational / Inst. identity
Political
 
GLOBAL
NORTH:SOUTH 

 

The Legend of St Edmund and the Wolf

Source: 'The Bay Horse' local pub and Coffee House.

Previously: 'identity' : 'philosophy' : 'alcohol' : 'South' : 'language'

Thursday, May 21, 2026

RCN Congress: The Systems Table and the Missing Cog

Across two maillists: SDOH Social Determinants of Health and POHG Politics of Health Group a discussion and debate regards public health, longevity and policy, was provoked by a study:

'At least 80% responsibility for ill health in old age down to individual'

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/may/20/responsibility-ill-health-old-age-oxford-longevity-project-study

'... Individuals bear at least 80% of the responsibility for their ill health in old age, according to a report aimed at challenging the belief that physical decline is either inevitable or primarily the responsibility of the state.

The report, launched at the Smart Ageing Summit in Oxford last week, argues that individuals have far greater control over their longevity than is commonly understood. The authors call on the government to take legislative action on alcohol comparable to restrictions on smoking.

Living Longer, Better – the Oxford Longevity Project’s first Age-less report – was co-authored by an interdisciplinary panel of UK-based experts in medicine, physiology, ageing and education policy. It was sponsored by Oxford Healthspan.

The report’s authors, Sir Christopher Ball, Sir Muir Gray, Dr Paul Ch’en, Leslie Kenny and Prof Denis Noble, present the figure of 80% as a conservative estimate.

Ball, a 91-year-old former Parachute regiment officer who intends to reach 100, said: “Some have gone higher and said it’s approaching 90%. But I think 80% seems about fair.”The claim, however, has been described as simplistic and said to neglect wider arguments about whether people are genuinely in control of individual choices when it comes to issues including poverty, pollution and healthcare access.

Nancy Krieger, professor of social epidemiology at Harvard TH Chan school of public health, said: “The report is to be commended for rejecting genetic determinism but it problematically avoids engaging with the societal determination of health and health inequities; the role of work, economic deprivation and government policies that give corporations free rein to sell unhealthy products.”

Steven Woolf, professor of family medicine and population health and director of the Virginia Commonwealth University Center on Society and Health, agreed, saying the paper “ignores and oversimplifies the actual, multilayered root causes of the conditions that foster poor health in a population”.

Woolf added: “There are factors affecting health that are beyond personal choice. So while it’s good to give people clear guidance on how their choices affect their health, it’s taking policymakers and others off the hook.” ...'


This provides me with evidence (well it would - wouldn't it^) on the need for, the purposes, and applications of Hodges' model.

More philosophically (perhaps), I'm reminded of the work of several academics - thinkers, Michel Serres stands out for me. Serres felt that positional adverbs were important, e.g. between, above, and under.

He also wrote of life (as per many philosophers), and the universe e.g. his writings on Physics and Lucretius - as flow - a river.

For new life, the options are seemingly infinite, far, far upstream: at source - not recognisable even as a trickle... but soon a rivulet, a stream, a river of so many tributaries.

As we grow older we get closer to the sea (of the 'eternal'), the options open to us shrink gradually, but ultimately radically - inevitably.

But looking back the turbulence, uncertainty, unpredictability (trauma and joy), all contribute, not just to where we end (up) but how this came about.

Life's signature at death.

In "Hodges' Health Career Model" 'health career' refers specifically to the idea of life chances (of course) and how other careers, education, work, retirement, caring (self - others - planet) .. are impacted through life and death's course.

This morning at RCN Congress, Liverpool (the home of District Nursing) there was discussion re. nurses being engaged in preparation for the next pandemic.

So often 'Nursing' is absent from the POLITICAL / POLICY table:

Speaking for myself, nursing is not interested in the four-course meal, but being involved and engaged in the after dinner discourse can be critical.

Politicians, policy makers, business, management consultants and lobbyists are so quick to point to and extol the 'SYSTEMS' perspective, and the need for 'systems thinking'.

Guilty of systemic neglect, they clearly have no idea of what a system is, an inability to appreciate and apprehend scope, scale and the 'whole'.

In mitigation (or not), for all groups: voice matters. Especially the voices of foresight, balance, advocacy, Their ability to ascend always proves an issue. 

Related papers listed in the sidebar:

Jones, P. (2008) Exploring Serres’ Atlas, Hodges’ Knowledge Domains and the Fusion of Informatics and Cultural Horizons, IN Kidd, T., Chen, I. (Eds.) Social Information Technology Connecting Society and Cultural Issues, Idea Group Publishing, Inc. Chap. 7, pp. 96-109.

Jones, P. (2009) Socio-Technical Structures, the Scope of Informatics and Hodges’ model, IN, Staudinger, R., Ostermann, H., Bettina Staudinger, B. (Eds.), Handbook of Research in Nursing Informatics and Socio-Technical Structures, Idea Group Publishing, Inc. Chap. 11, pp. 160-174.

Jones, P. (2012). Exploring several dimensions of local, global and glocal using the generic conceptual framework Hodges's model. The Journal Of Community Informatics. 8(3). Retrieved from https://www.academia.edu/3794699/Reflecting_on_the_glocal_through_the_conceptual_framework_of_Hodges_s_model

^Because these days you need to make every kernel - found or created on the continuum of evidence - count.

Previously: 'life chances' : 'health career' : 'Serres' : 'APPGs'

Liverpool, UK. RCN Congress 2026 - 
n.b. See you in Liverpool 2027?

Saturday, January 10, 2026

Book: Bill Ross - 'Order and the Virtual' ii

'The Philosophy and Science of Deleuzian Cosmology'

Now I can say: "This year, Hodges' model will be presented at WCCS 6th World Conference on Complex Systems", so current reading needs to match this project. And, it does. In spades, in fact c/o and with thanks to Edinburgh University Press. Look at chapter 1! 'Chaos' with Mandelbrot fractals, smooth space drawing from Deleuze and Guattari's A Thousand Plateaus. For readers unfamiliar with the Deleuzian oeuvre, abbreviations of texts that feature in Bill Ross's book Order and the Virtual are listed (xii) and includes key sources by Michel Serres, Henri Bergson and Alfred North Whitehead. This works as you mentally take a note, of work to lookup. Almost twenty years ago, I related some ideas of Michel Serres to Hodges' model:

Jones, P. (2008) Exploring Serres’ Atlas, Hodges’ Knowledge Domains and the Fusion of Informatics and Cultural Horizons, IN Kidd, T., Chen, I. (Eds.) Social Information Technology Connecting Society and Cultural Issues, Idea Group Publishing, Inc. Chap. 7, pp. 96-109. 

Ross discusses the extent and proximity of Deleuze's thought to chaos, complexity theory and science more generally as identified by commentators. Now up to chapter 4, it would have helped to have a look at the bibliography at the book's end. Deleuze saw how his work resonated with chaos theory. Steve Strogatz's book (now in a 3rd edition):

Strogatz, S.H. (2015) Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos: With Application to Physics, Biology, Chemistry and Engineering. 2nd edition. Perseus Books Publishing, Cambridge. 

- explains in the introduction how 'home computing' contributed to the aesthetic appeal of fractals, which could display incredible patterns derived from seemingly simple mathematics. Even though, the programs often required many hours of running to deliver their results.

In the late 1980s I was fascinated with a subscription to Fractal Report:

https://stephen.shawweb.co.uk/Fractalreportindex.html

The relevance for me of Order and the Virtual is apparent on page 1, Deleuze and Guattari's thought having an immediate transdisciplinary application, crossing boundaries, and the creation of regions of bifurcation. Ross connects Deleuze's thought and Ilya Prigogine & Isabelle Stengers' text:

Order Out of Chaos: Man's New Dialogue with Nature. London: Heinemann, 1984 

Ross is encouraging (to me and for Hodges' model), as he notes how the notions may be inexact, but they are nonetheless rigorous. Spanning as they do, philosophy, science - what is scientific(? - itself a boundary - demarcation) and artistic. I've often thought of Hodges' model as filled with folds, and multiple bifurcations. It looks like Bill Ross is going help me to isolate several, and possibly make my search more efficient (the latter really would assist). The memorial event held in Manchester last September was revalatory. Since the early 2000s I'd grown to  really appreciate the availability of books by Michel Serres. I was not aware of the force behind the Clinamen Press, which Bill Ross established in 1999. 'Clinamen' is a useful concept too, which I have encountered previously, through Serres and Lucretius. 

Readers new to philosophy, sociology and the development of ideas must often grapple with a new and specific vocabulary. This is a primary purpose of such texts. On page 2 the springboard is sprung, the Event is key in Deleuzian scholarship. The Event is a force for creative and disruptive force for thought,  idea generation and creativity. The Event is experienced in our current 'realities' of: time and space (Kronos) where things are actualised, and the virtual (Aion) - the pure Event. This lack of hesitation is welcome. Our 'virtual' world quickly provides access to reading:

parrhesia 27 · 2017 · 1-12
extract from the birth of physics
michel serres, translated by david webb, with an introduction by bill ross
https://parrhesiajournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/parrhesia27_serres.pdf

Where you have bifurcations, you have convergences and divergences, stasis, state - stasis or not, paths, a series and metrics. We are reminded that science is not just about theory - metaphysics, it is, sleeves rolled-up about doing too; as I've noted in subsequent reading. As 'chaos' predicts, there is no let up,  the Choasmos, quickly follows. I'm thinking of a 'situation' clinically as a rollercoaster - 'constant displacement' seeking a difference, and repetition, the ravages of alcohol, dementia, low mood, psychosis, obsession and compulsive 'states'. The chaosmos is central in Hodges' model, although as both continua and oppositions. Ross explains how Deleuze's chaosmos is not necessarily scientific, but belongs to the ancient cosmologies of the Greeks (p.3). I thought of flux here. 'Parity' is not just a physical metric, but a quality that acts, seeks resolution - equilibrium(?) - between the mental chaos and physical chaos.*

Thinkers like Deleuze 'trap' words, concepts, in boxes, drawing from other other sources (for chaosmos - with Guattari again); then they can be examined and tested for their scope, application, meaning and association. Hodges' model provides a trap, for any situation. Not as specific as a physicist's ion (or Penning) trap, but the model can act as a series of holistic traps. To provide a metric of holistic bandwidth.

*Of course, equilibrium is never found - until the 'End'; such is the nature of flux. 

More to follow...

Bill Ross (2024) Order and the Virtual: The Philosophy and Science of Deleuzian Cosmology. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. https://edinburghuniversitypress.com/book-order-and-the-virtual.html

Monday, August 04, 2025

Book: v 'Health and Health Care Inequities'

This final post for HHCI takes in -

Chapter 7: Searching for Socialism
Chapter 8: Mobilizing for Health Equity.

These themes are preceded at the close of chapter 6 with Arnel sharing some personal background, as an immigrant to Canada from a racialized background, who has worked in the health care industry (p.96). COVID also features again, its effects still resonate socio-politically.

It is an unfortunate conjunction - relationship as far as socialism, social justice, the green movement and social cohesion are concerned but Borras provides an invaluable service in linking the Capital-State alliance, which I have capitalised. It seems to be appropriate?

There is 'something' here (I think) in the 'identity' of governments, administrations - I will work through elsewhere.

Having added a note in post iv on expropriation, I see that 'precarity' is also included (p.98).

Chapter 7 gets to grips with 'Welfare Systems in Capitalism'. As before the details are Canadian, but with global reference to other welfare systems - liberal, conservative, and social democratic. If Marxism - Socialism was once feared for its seismic potential, I wondered if chapter 7 points to socialism being in a dormant state? Borras explains welfare state evolution and influences and employs metrics of trade union density, low-wage rates, poverty rates, and infant-mortality rates. On low-wages reference to the US as a capitalist powerhouse that does not provide a favourable environment for most workers, added to my thoughts about nursing globally and the US specifically: despite my parochial vantage point. Five tables aid international comparisons, with inconsistencies in data also highlighted. I couldn't help but feel the need to consider the impact of the wider-determinants of health. Now  undoubtedly, an emerging field. The discussion on infant mortality prompts thoughts of my daughter a mum-to-be amid health news in the UK. Plus, Labour's previous and renewed efforts in Sure Start; and the need stressed through Hodges' model to focus on ALL the literacies, including health.  

It sounds a contradiction but HHCI frequently had me thinking 'BIG picture' and detail. Reading 'US Empire' (p.110) made me wonder what descriptor might have been applied if written in June 2025? Social democracies are called to account. As a community nurse I am ready to support someone in making a change. But they must want and be the agent of that change. I can't support the individual in their drinking to excess - in the case of alcohol misuse/dependency. Social democracies and capitalism can operate as a conspiratorial dyad, limiting social and welfare progression. The lessons here are invaluable (pp.110-113). 

More could be made of the specific political impacts of technology. But clearly that would be another book. For example, no excuse, but BIG-TECH were clearly determined to start[-up] as they intended to go. They had a 'cleanroom' - clean-slate as far as unionisation was concerned. Governments permitted the same - paving the way, enabling and across continents. Ironic, the touchy-feely "We Care" with 'amazing offices', work cafés, dog areas, cycle paths, gardens, breakout spaces, and views. "Now, it is almost a religion: 'Give me a company until it is seven ...'. 

As socialism tries to overcome the past, and its associations; a political movement is needed. Somehow 'new socialism' sounds dated. There a call for openness in new ideas and ways to realise socialism. Over the past two decades work has changed, zero-hour contracts, part-time contracts, the rise of employment agencies and self-employed workers. It appears 'complex adaptive systems' can explain and help solve many problems, extending to human organisation and government. Yes. 'It is crucial to understand people's situations and value their experiences.' But how? And, how to 'encourage open conversations and learn from each other.' (p.114)? Neither 'citizen', or 'assemblies' are in the index, as with gambling and advertising. I may have missed one, or more in the text. You have a sense of a need for international organisation. Especially, with AI - artificial intelligence also in the wings.

The results of Erik Olin Wright's analysis of anti-capitalist movements does not sound convincing to me (pp.114-116), but then I'm a nurse. Perhaps economics itself needs to be looked at (again)? Is it an ongoing project - radical economics - that is? How does a new socio-political order 'account' for the existing distribution wealth? The paths toward health equity 1-6, make more sense. The political realism demonstrated, gives me reason to continue here. 

A brief section on electoral politics, brought me to short-termism. I have reached out to SIMPOL about this book and will share with the author.


[ Update 20/08/25: I've put the author Arnel in touch John Bunzl at SIMPOL. Short-termism remains an acute problems in our politics and policy. I've always worked clinically, so despite union and professional body membership, policy is something that has been done to my colleagues and I. There did seem some coherence with the National Service Frameworks. That may be illusory as they focussed on long-term conditions, but there was more:

Boardman J, Parsonage M. Government policy and the National Service Framework for Mental Health: modelling and costing services in England. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment. 2009;15(3):230-240. doi:10.1192/apt.bp.106.003095

They also had the attention of 'service user / carer specific organisations' -
https://mstrust.org.uk/a-z/national-service-frameworks-nsf

Last week, outside a large bookshop in Hay-on-Wye there were cabinets with books for sale at £1. With £5 worth under my arm, I was ready to go in to pay, and spotted 'Walk Don't Run' an absolute gem which I will post about soon. It links to the first post about Arnel's text and evidence. ].
Chapter 8: Mobilizing for Health Equity. Social justice: It seems the more it is spoken of (shouted even); the further it is to being delivered. We used to talk about minority and disenfranchised groups needing a 'voice'. Now social media amplifies the voice, that gets lost in the cacophony and chaos of information disorder. The 'essence of socialism' needs to quickly get to grips with capitalism as the need for 'labour' changes - is changing. We must listen to literature too: 'Some animals are more equal than others'. Class awareness and the role of unions is discussed. Education is critical. Perhaps we need more Philosophy in Pubs? People learn more effectively when they discover things, and arrive at conclusions for themselves. Use of guided discovery and Socratic dialogue have proved their worth repeatedly. This is why formative education is so important. Young people should be able to reflect and think critically. Within the education system the development of character and values too. That way: 'Workers must become political activists.' (p.126).

As a former health care worker there's a page (+) on engaging nurses in the fight for health equity. It is good to see I am probably right to assume the majority of nurses not 'politically active'. Hopefully, nurses and other formal carers reflect the local community and demographics. Although COVID revealed blatent structural realities. 

Individual
|
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
Group

LIFE CHANCES
MY POTENTIAL
MENTAL HEALTH

PHYSICAL RESOURCES
PHYSICAL HEALTH

SOCIETY
SOCIAL RESOURCES
COMMUNITY

HEALTH ACTIVISM
ADVOCACY
POLICY CHANGE


On page 108 is '2SLGBTQIA+' below is a video that helps:


There are 'minimum demands' - Canada-centric of course. A look beyond policy change limitations and a short review of the need to establish a genuine socialist political party. This begs the question of how 'genuine' would be recognised. There may be a case study emerging in UK politics over the next four years? The bones are here in HHCI- no doubt about that.  More is needed, so it's encouraging there is no 'manifesto' in the index either.

Many thanks to Fernwood Publishing for my pb copy.

Arnel M. Borras. (2025) Health and Health Care Inequities - A Critical Political Economy Perspective. Fernwood Publishing.

See also - reference to Hodges' model:
Iris Lohja, Yves Demazeau, Christine Verdier. A multi-agent system approach to dynamic ridesharing for older people: State-of-the-art work and preliminary design. 18èmes Rencontres des Jeunes Chercheurs en Intelligence Artificielle, RJCIA’20, Jun 2020, Angers, France. pp.52-59. ⟨hal-02897446⟩

Sunday, May 04, 2025

NHS & Politics: You don't have to do 'The Hokey Cokey'

c/o Lunch with the FT - Amanda Pritchard
Life&Arts :: FTWeekend


individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group
'Another question that she says will become increasingly pressing is what "the core business" of the health service should be at a time when parts of the state and voluntary sectors have been squeezed, leaving the NHS to pick up the slack. GPs tell her that between one in four and one in five of their patients come to them for help with non-health problems.

A colleague in a mental health service recently told her it employs a housing team to support patients who couldn't otherwise be discharged from hospital. "You wouldn't say the core business of the health service is as a housing provider, but that's where we've ended up."'

She adds: "Think about how long it takes to train a doctor - you can't change your mind every five minutes. . . Think about what it requires to put new [digital] systems in place. It's not buying the tech - that's the easy bit. It's the implementation . . . and some consistency of leadership is really helpful."

'The NHS contributes between 10 and 
20 per cent to people's health, she says - a figure I find startlingly low. "The rest is what we would recognise as the wider [social] determinants, including housing, and meaningful employment, but also smoking, diet, alcohol and lack of exercise. "I know there's an anxiety sometimes about being too nanny stateish about this . . But it is going to take really bold action to set the conditions for people to then live healthier lives."'


'The abolition of NHS England marks the end of an attempt to take the politics out of the health service by placing its day-to-day running in the hands of an arm's-length body. But Pritchard suggests that if this was the intent, it was probably never realistic. "It's too important to the country [and] we spend too much public money for ... the politics not to be part of it."'



My source:
Sarah Neville, Lunch with the FT Amanda Pritchard, Life&Arts, FTWeekend, 26-27 April, 2025, p.3.

Previously: 'Nye' : 'SOCIO-technical' : 'housing'

Monday, March 11, 2024

HIFA Discussion: Alcohol Use Disorders - Drink Aware and Change

Dear HIFA colleagues,

I would like to invite you to retweet the following that I have just sent on our X/Twitter account:

"Pls RT: I just took the DrinkAware test as if I drank 3 pints a day (well over the recommended limit). The result was "Great news! You are at lower risk of alcohol-related problems". We invite others to check. Thx NPW https://www.drinkaware.co.uk/tools/drinking-check#/ "

You can see the tweet and retweet here: https://twitter.com/hifa_org/status/1762399130154885617

We are unsure why the test - which is taken by 900 people every day - is providing such misinformation.

DrinkAware is funded by the alcohol industry.

Thank you for your help to publicise this issue.

Best wishes, Neil

HIFA profile: Neil Pakenham-Walsh is coordinator of HIFA (Healthcare Information For All), a global health community that brings all stakeholders together around the shared goal of universal access to reliable healthcare information. HIFA has 20,000 members in 180 countries, interacting in four languages and representing all parts of the global evidence ecosystem. HIFA is administered by Global Healthcare Information Network, a UK-based nonprofit in official relations with the World Health Organization. Email: neil AT hifa.org


To which I replied:

RT'd as requested.. 

Reply from twitter ... 


McCambridge J, Kypri K, Miller P, Hawkins B, Hastings G. Be aware of Drinkaware. Addiction. 2014 Apr;109(4):519-24. doi: 10.1111/add.12356. Epub 2013 Oct 28. PMID: 24164565; PMCID: PMC3992896.

UPDATE 10th March

Dear HIFA colleagues,

Further to our discussions on HIFA, in the past week DrinkAware HAS CHANGED THEIR ADVICE to people who drink 42 units per week (3X the recommended maximum). Questions remain about how many people were misled by previous advice, whether that advice was deliberate, and whether WHO's AUDIT test (currently used as the basis for the DrinkAware test) should continue to be used by anyone as an unsupervised self-evaluation tool.

BACKGROUND On 22 February 2024 I reported on HIFA an apparent problem with DrinkAware, the UK's largest alcohol charity, funded by the alcohol industry. https://www.hifa.org/dgroups-rss/alcohol-use-disorders-79-role-alcohol-industry-10-alcohol-industry-and-misinformation

I took their Drinking Check. I posed as a man who drinks 42 units per week (3X the recommended maximum) and DrinkAware told me: "Great news! You are at lower risk of alcohol-related problems. This means you are at lower risk of serious diseases such as stroke, heart and liver disease, and seven types of cancer and may already be noticing the benefits of lower risk drinking such as deeper sleep, more energy and brighter moods."

There was no advice to reduce my consumption.

This test was repeated by other HIFA members in subsequent days, with the same results.

On 4 March 2024 we reported our findings to the World Health Organization.

CHANGE IN ADVICE Today, 10 March 2024, I took the test again. As before I posed as a man who drinks 42 units per week. This time I got a different result:

"You are on the right track. You are at lower risk of alcohol-related problems... To keep your health risks low, the UK Chief Medical Officers advice is to drink no more than 14 units a week. If you are regularly drinking above 14 units per week there are tips and advice below about how to cut down."

INTERPRETATION Prior to 4 March 2024, DrinkAware was encouraging many heavy drinkers (up to 42 units per week) to continue drinking as they are.

DrinkAware claims that its Drinking Check tool was used by 250,991 people in 2021, so it appears that potentially tens or even hundreds of thousands of people drinking 14-42 units per week may have been misinformed.

At some point between 4 March and 9 March, Drinkaware changed their Drinking Check tool so that heavy drinkers (up to 42 units per week) are now advised to cut down.

SHOULD WHO's AUDIT TEST BE USED AS AN UNSUPERVISED SELF-EVALUATION TOOL?

Previous messages on HIFA have suggested that AUDIT should only be used as a clinical tool by health professionals, and not as an unsupervised self-evaluation tool. WHO's AUDIT manual notes: 'Care must be taken to tell patients why questions about alcohol use are being asked and to provide information they need to make appropriate responses. A decision must be made whether to administer the AUDIT orally or as a written, self-report questionnaire.' https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/67205/WHO_MSD_MSB_01.6a-eng.pdf

NEXT STEPS

How many people were misled by previous advice, was that advice deliberate, and should WHO's AUDIT test (currently used as the basis for the DrinkAware test) continue to be made available as an unsupervised self-evaluation tool?

I invite HIFA members to suggest next steps. Are you a health journalist (or do you know a health journalist) who might be interested to look into this in more depth? Please pass this on and/or contact me: neil@hifa.org

Meanwhile I shall report this new finding to WHO.

I look forward to your comments and suggestions: hifa AT hifaforums.org

Best wishes, Neil

Finally ...

Dear HIFA colleagues,

We now enter our 6th and final week of the deep-dive into Alcohol Use Disorders, where I invite you to reflect on what has been discussed so far (and what has not been discussed). In your view, what is the key learning in relation to the 5 questions we have explored:

1. Do people understand the health, socio-economic and environmental harms of alcohol? What matters to them? How can they be better informed? How to reduce stigma? 2. Do health workers have adequate knowledge to prevent and manage alcohol use disorders among their patients? What matters to them? How can they be better informed? 3. What is the role of the alcohol industry? What can be done to address misinformation from the alcohol industry? 4. Do public health professionals and policymakers have adequate knowledge to prevent and treat alcohol use disorders in their country? What are current national policies and what more can be done to fully implement those policies? 5. How can we define and measure alcohol use disorders?

To help with this, I have prepared a full compilation of our discussion so far (205 pages):

https://www.hifa.org/sites/default/files/publications_pdf/Alcohol_Use_Disorders_Compilation2.pdf

I shall now work on an edited version (selected text organised under subheadings for each of the 5 questions and for other topics) and will get this to you asap.

Many thanks, Neil

Wednesday, February 28, 2024

HIFA Discussion: Alcohol Use Disorders - Do people understand the harms of alcohol?

Dear All (with further editing since posting)

The discussion, points, angles, questions ... are coming thick and fast it is difficult to keep up.

Many thanks for the summaries; and of course the discussion which archived also acts as a resource - repository:

https://www.hifa.org/news/hifa-announces-deep-dive-discussion-alcohol-use-disorders-starts-5-february-2024

I wonder whether the question: 
"Do people understand the harms of alcohol?" must always be placed in context?
It is radically different when asked of the tee-total, dry, safe drinker; and someone (still) actually in their alcohol drinking?

It occurs to me that alcohol, even more so than 'other' substance misuse (heroin...) represents what must be *the* contradiction, paradox in healthcare - except the tragic loss that is suicide.

Contrast substance misuse inc. alcohol, with 'help-seeking' and 'The Sick role'

https://www.england.nhs.uk/blog/ed-mitchell-2/

Plus, the (medical) sociology of the decision to consult/refer, and how in mental health (UK), the mental capacity act is apparently being misapplied ('policy-drift'?**):

https://www.lawsociety.org.uk/topics/blogs/are-mental-health-and-capacity-laws-at-risk-of-being-toxic

https://www.communitycare.co.uk/2017/08/23/flawed-use-mental-capacity-act-key-theme-safeguarding-adults-reviews-report-finds/

Individual

   |
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
Group

continental drift

policy drift?


Previously, I highlighted how as a Community Psychiatric Nurse 1985-1995 (adult) .. if a patient/client was not working to control/reduce their alcohol consumption they may be 'counselled' re a pending discharge and referral back to their GP - family physician. In supervision with the team's manager they would want to know what is 'happening'. It being important not to create (social) dependency, or worse support someone in their alcohol misuse.

There was a sense, still is(?) that in substance misuse (across forms) - the individual has to reach 'rock-bottom', literally the 'gutter' that is the point they decide (really?)** to live, or carry on to suffer irreversible brain damage, or premature death. Regards the 'brain damage' it was a struggle for 45-60 minutes given the impact upon short-term memory, what time, .... is it indeed? When the patient was not living alone, how did the relative, family cope?

Is having to reach the gutter, the bottom, a trope/myth? In psychosis rather than assume the patient is beyond being reached prior to being medicated there are psycho-social interventions that can be commenced: being available / with. Here though this is usually 'first episode'. There is no analogue here, unless first admission to an in-patient unit is taken as a golden opportunity? But this also depends on its nature (funding, staffing - expertise), a general adult mental health ward, or specialist unit.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0048347/

What is the current strategy?

In terms of 'HIFA' - and the person that counts**, not only do they not have the 'information'; they do not have the EXISTENTIAL INFORMATION as it relates to them: 'Health Information for YOU'!

Again in Hodges' model we can contrast the dichotomy/polarisation of INDIVIDUAL :: GROUP.

The model's being situated; and able to encompass data, information, knowledge (facts, for example, and their delivery) - wisdom (Multi-contextual / transdisciplinary..).

I admire people who work in these services (learning disability and palliative care); as they must be severely tested as they retain an ability - the humanity - to 'see' the person whatever the patient's situation with their lack of awareness (capacity..?) and its critical salience.

Peter Jones
Community Mental Health Nurse and Researcher
Blogging at "Welcome to the QUAD"
http://hodges-model.blogspot.com/
http://twitter.com/h2cm
h2cmng at yahoo.co.uk

Location: It was just a cappuccino.

**Which points to the relevance of the POLITICAL care/knowledge domain in Hodges' model.

Monday, February 26, 2024

HIFA Discussion: Alcohol Use Disorders - Language 'being drunk'

----- Forwarded message -----
From: Peter Jones, UK <hifa AT hifaforums.org>
To: HIFA - Healthcare Information For All <hifa AT hifaforums.org>
Sent: Sunday, 25 February 2024 at 06:35:47 GMT
Subject: [hifa] Alcohol Use Disorders (86)

This morning on Times Radio UK, Hugo Rifkind 1000-1300 from 10.58:30 UTC:

- there was mention of research in Germany on language, finding that there are over 540 words for 'drunkenness' being drunk. Apparently, the key is adding -ed to many words.

https://www.research-in-germany.org/idw-news/en_US/2024/2/2024-02-19__I_m_gonna_get_totally_and_utterly_X-ed.__OR__Can_you_really_use_any_English_word_to_mean__drunk__

This stood out for me as Hodges' model can potentially encompass the full corpus of a language, with the various contexts in which language is applied/used.

Significant of course informationally, in evidence-based practice, and research, were 'definition of terms' are (usually?) essential.

Also reminded of national variation in clinical/medical terminology. Scottish slang for injection includes 'jag'.

For health communication and HIFA, clearly language is fundamental and presents a real 'can of worms' (sorry!) in sense-making, creating 'noise' in the communication channels.

Should health services/systems effect a (gradual) change (shift) of emphasis to education and prevention - with the requisite policy support (utopic?) then this will need to be addressed.

In checking this news, it appears Germany has a more acute problem with alcohol. Can anyone 'local' - please shed any light on this?

I will post again about the HIFA discussion with a week ... left and highlight the above.

Many thanks

Peter Jones
Community Mental Health Nurse and Researcher
CMHT, Prescott House, Salford NW England, UK (Mon-Tues)
Blogging at "Welcome to the QUAD"

h2cmuk AT yahoo.co.uk

Saturday, February 10, 2024

HIFA Discussion: Alcohol Use Disorders (37) Do people understand the harms of alcohol? (9) How can they be better informed? (5)

Further to the post on 1st February 2024:

HIFA discussion on Alcohol Use Disorders, 5 Feb - 17 Mar 2024

- I have f/w some reflections (edited here). You may have your own experiences, skills, knowledge to contribute?

<>

As a teenager you were very aware of peer pressure (as a social expectation) to drink. Is it an acquired taste?

The media played a key role - advertising "Tetley Bitter-men", "Double Diamond - works wonders", Babycham, Advocaat, Martini Rosso .. and many of the popular TV series we consumed (pardon the pun).

Getting in the pub AND served was a right of passage - and a rather 'tame' one for a white, male.

In the family the harms and risks of alcohol were explained. 

Sometimes they were demonstrated at parties, weddings, the aunt, uncle - relative who was notorious for having too much.

Studying literature at school did have a role to play - although less directly.

Although on reflection when there were school assemblies I wonder if 'drink' (Church of England) was mentioned?
Interesting perhaps - the change in daily school routine.

I remember at a birthday party for a fellow class pupil at a social club, the birthday boy was sick all over the table - yes - had been drinking.

Tempered my attitude early on - c.15.

As a nursing asst. and student nurse you realised the other - dark - side. The key being the contradiction that alcohol represents:
  • Drink to relax, socialise, be friendly, enjoy yourself;
  • Impact of your health, risk of addiction, violence, (brewer's droop was an early lesson - tho not practically);
  • IF YOU develop a drink problem then you're on your own and so is your family (there are of course agencies in developed nations - but the funding disparity - as in, gambling, tobacco?).
In a 'local' - public house - pub it was known in 1970s for some regulars (invariably men) to down c.12 (more?) pints in a night - even after drinking hours: they were heavy goods vehicle drivers.

---------
I may have posted before - how in 1987-88 I completed a study of alcohol (intervention) teams, Preston, Salford, Blackburn here in NW England. The consultant psychiatrist made a key point about the (much debated even then) use of economic levers to help reduce alcohol consumption.

Scotland have just updated their intervention:

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/feb/08/scotland-raises-minimum-alcohol-prices-by-almost-one-third

As a student nurse - I was already aware of some of the inorganic molecules that have been found in space: the original primordial soup!

The chemical names still remind me of a chemical plant, such as the former ICI plant at Widnes / Runcorn, Cheshire, England, e.g.:

https://thumbs.dreamstime.com/b/heavy-industry-panorama-night-panoramic-view-chemical-plant-refinery-blue-sky-illumination-some-freight-85481422.jpg

This in-turn takes me to the miracle that is the liver - the biological chemical plant - with a potential powerful message in how 'alcohol' is broken down:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6527027/

Sometimes insight into this can work wonders in terms of motivation for change - the facts - not trying to scare (waste of time)...?

Which brings me to the obvious 'contradiction' in caring for people with a primary / secondary problem with alcohol.

Having a liver function test.

If it's OK that *means* I can carry on!!

I have over the years developed what imho I consider to be potentially therapeutic relationships with patients affected by alcohol.

I say potentially as I, with supervision, have had to withdraw input and discharge them. Even if the client can't 'draw the line', you cannot support the patient in their damaging alcohol consumption and related behaviours. The offer of further support was offered, with signposts should there be a change of  mind.

Alcohol, tobacco - vapes, the 'mental pollution' that can be passed as legitimate 'advertising', fake news ... still calls for a generic model, a universal conceptual framework for personal and global health - across literacies and forms of informatics:

'alcohol'
https://hodges-model.blogspot.com/search?q=alcohol

Just to close I saw an item (I will try to find...) on the preponderance of 'smoking' in films 1940s - present day.

Still a problem now.

Of course: advocacy for health requires constant vigilance.

Thursday, February 01, 2024

HIFA discussion on Alcohol Use Disorders, 5 Feb - 17 Mar 2024

Dear all on HIFA,

It's just 4 days to go before the official launch of our deep-dive discussion on Alcohol Use Disorders, 5 February to 17 March 2024.

Please forward this message to your contacts and networks and invite them to join! www.hifa.org/joinhifa

More information here:
https://www.hifa.org/news/hifa-announces-deep-dive-discussion-alcohol-use-disorders-starts-5-february-2024

HIFA is grateful for sponsorship from the Ulrich and Ruth Frank Foundation for International Health known online as NextGenU.org.

Note: We have opportunities for further sponsored discussions in 2024. We have 20 working groups on standby to plan and implement a discussion [ https://www.hifa.org/projects ]. Or we can start a new group to address a topic that is important to you. Also new in 2024 there is the option to have live webinars to complement our forum discussions.
To discuss possibilities, please contact: neil AT hifa.org

With thanks, Neil

HIFA Partnerships and Projects working group: https://www.hifa.org/projects/partnerships-and-projects

HIFA profile: Neil Pakenham-Walsh is coordinator of HIFA (Healthcare Information For All), a global health community that brings all stakeholders together around the shared goal of universal access to reliable healthcare information. HIFA has 20,000 members in 180 countries, interacting in four languages and representing all parts of the global evidence ecosystem. HIFA is administered by Global Healthcare Information Network, a UK-based nonprofit in official relations with the World Health Organization.

Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Health information & 7th Global Alcohol Policy Conference

Politicians -
GIVE HEALTH LITERACY A CHANCE!

INDIVIDUAL
|
     INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP
cognitive access, basic literacy
'legibility', digital access
PUBLIC - MENTAL - HEALTH

Society
Communities
Most vulnerable groups
Digital divide

"Why are alcohol companies pushing for QR codes on labels? Well, which of these two labelling methods actually shows the risk of alcohol consumption, 1 or 2? QR codes are a way for producers to say they are informing consumers, without doing so." @InstAlcStud

economic access
Health Information For All
POLICY
7th Global Alcohol Policy Conf.
Alcohol Taxes - False economy?


My source: https://x.com/InstAlcStud/status/1703658612109742578?s=20

Thursday, May 25, 2023

c/o HSE.ie - Model of Care for People with Mental Disorder and Co-existing Substance Use Disorder (Dual Diagnosis)

"The definition of Dual Diagnosis for this Model of Care is: ‘the co-morbid disorders due to substance use and/or addictive behaviours along with the presence of mental disorder(s)’. The disorders of substance use include disorders of alcohol use." p.10.

Model of Care for People with Mental Disorder and
Co-existing Substance Use Disorder (Dual Diagnosis)

INDIVIDUAL
|
INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES              
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC
SOCIOLOGY :   POLITICAL
|
GROUP


mental disorder

addictive behaviour -
inc. gambling and gaming disorder

lived experience
recovery (here?)
[cognitive access: orientation, insight, literacy, communication ..]
training

patient and
Demographics:
Adult Dual Diagnosis team
cover population of 300,000

Adolescent Dual Diagnosis teams
10 to 17 years


lived experience
data gathering

p a th w  a ys
[ physical access: place, time]
e-health, therapeutic modules

reablement, recovery (here?)
public involvement


Carers

Social Inclusion
Social capital

lived experience

Vulnerable women, communities, homeless, ethnic minorities, refugees,
recovery (here?)

rehabilitation



Dual Diagnosis Service
funding
[ planned - in-patient beds ]

TRAINING

Service users
lived experience
interdepartmental discussion re. service provision for
prison population
probation services

asylum seekers,
immigrants
Key Performance Indicators

recovery (here?)



FOR: Economic, Educational, Environmental, Social, Political DETERMINANTS . .

READ: Cognitive, Physical, Social and Political ACCESS

My source: https://twitter.com/h2cm/status/1661299925391384576?s=20

Tuesday, August 30, 2022

August 2022 - Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved

 
The August 2022 issue of the Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved (JHCPU) has been released:

https://muse.jhu.edu/issue/48370

The Note from the Editor appears below. Following the link will bring you to the full table of contents.

With best wishes for the new academic year,

Ginny Brennan

 Note from the Editor


Public Health and Politics

Positioned at the nexus of social science and health, the Journal's work is necessarily political. One of the many concerns in the U.S. as we approach the Fall of 2022 is the U.S. Supreme Court's June decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organisation to overturn Roe v. Wade and with it the Constitutional guarantee of the right to abortion, abrogating women's moral autonomy over their reproductive health. In this issue, Frohwirth and colleagues consider another contested site in the reproductive health care landscape—contraception affected by abortion policy—as they assess the impact on women in Iowa of a 2017 reduction in Medicaid coverage of contraceptive care. Due to the new law, patients enrolled in the state family planning program could no longer access subsidised care at publicly funded clinics affiliated with abortion provision, and over 15,000 patients had to find to find a new family planning provider. The researchers learned in their qualitative study that high fees for visits and contraceptive methods, restrictive or inadequate insurance coverage, and access barriers such as long appointment wait times were the most common barriers to preferred contraceptive care, and these barriers compounded one another. Furthermore, barriers grew once the more restrictive Iowa Medicaid policy was in place. The authors conclude that policy changes supportive of contraceptive care would decrease vulnerability and increase reproductive autonomy.

Several papers in this issue bear on the construction of datasets or use datasets in new and sophisticated ways. We publish them aware of the fact that database construction is central to many highly political debates. Qato and colleagues introduce an intermediate-level variable—the nursing home—into an analysis of the distribution of COVID19 vaccination among nursing home residents. Looking at over 12,000 nursing homes in terms of the racial heterogeneity of the residents, the authors find that residents of the quantile of homes that were more predominantly non-Hispanic White were significantly more likely to be vaccinated (mean vaccinated 85.65%) than residents of the quantile that was least predominantly non-Hispanic White (mean vaccinated 72.74%). The authors of this short article conclude, "A higher proportion of White residents per facility was associated with higher resident COVID-19 vaccination rates reflecting continued disparities in quality of care during the pandemic."

While it is not construed formally as a variable, the construct of neighborhood in the paper by DiFiore and colleagues reveals significant patterns in the distribution of food insecurity. They assess food insecurity in relationship to perceived neighborhood safety, social cohesion, informal social control, and crime, adjusted for demographics, socioeconomic status, and neighborhood characteristics. The participants in the study were 300 mothers and female caregivers of Medicaid-enrolled two- to four-year old children in Philadelphia. Greater food security was associated with higher perceived neighborhood safety and social cohesion, and lower police-recorded violent crime rates. The evidence of this research suggests that the structural condition of living in a supportive neighborhood social environment may protect against food insecurity.

Kong and colleagues conducted COVID19/food security research, using longitudinal data to assess the interrelationships among food insecurity, mental health, and the COVID19 pandemic. They found that food insecurity was associated with stress, depression, and anxiety. They also found that these conditions improved over time during the pandemic among food-secure participants but worsened among food-insecure participants. The pandemic appears to worsen the already vicious cycle connecting food insecurity and mental health.

Two papers based on the Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) argue for enriched variables for coding race and ethnicity. Jones and Satter analyze mental health outcomes based on race and ethnicity and, in doing so, they observe that over 80% of respondents to the YRBS who self-identified as American Indian/Alaska Native also self-identified as Hispanic. American Indians/Alaska Natives are often multi-racial and of Hispanic/Latino ethnicity, and therefore outcomes differ widely depending on whether one examines American Indian/Alaska Native alone or in combination with other racial/ethnic variables. Also using the YRBSS, Braun and colleagues assessed tobacco and alcohol use and adolescent sexual practices among Black, bi/multi-racial, and White adolescents. They find that results differed across all three groups, leading them to conclude that nuanced racial categories are called for.

It is our hope that these and the many other papers in this quarter's issue—through their attention to social, scientific, and political decisions affecting health and health care—will serve to advance health justice, either through or in spite of the political process.

Virginia M. Brennan, PhD, MA
Editor, JHCPU
Associate Professor, Meharry Medical College

My source:
Spiritof1848 Listserv

See also: 'poverty' :  'politics' : 'risk' : 'covid'

Monday, July 25, 2022

World Drowning Prevention Day

INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP

I can learn to swim?

Yes, you can -
it's fun too!
 Even if you can swim:
Respect the water!

Be aware -
of water depth,
the water's temperature and
your body's reaction to cold,
what lies beneath,
and the effect
of alcohol and substances, and that recent meal...

Be safe -
while having fun!

Local Community
Knowledge of local risk


Policy
Facilities
Development aid/funding

Sunday, March 06, 2022

Hubris syndrome: Daedalus Project [Psycho-Political]

INDIVIDUAL
|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC -----------------------------------  MECHANISTIC    
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP
Hubris
Syndrome


"Democratic politicians as diverse as Woodrow Wilson, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Churchill, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, Pompidou, Mitterrand, Blair, George W. Bush, Chirac, and Sharon all lied about their health. ...


... Between 1906 and 2008 seven Presidents are judged to have been mentally ill while in office: Theodore Roosevelt (bipolar disorder), Taft (breathing-related sleep disorder), Wilson (major depressive disorder), Coolidge (major depressive disorder), Hoover (major depressive disorder), Johnson (bipolar disorder), and Nixon (alcohol abuse). Many despots-such as Hitler, Stalin, Saddam Hussein, Pol Pot, Idi Amin, and Robert Mugabe-have been branded by the press and public opinion as suffering mental illnesses. Lord Owen argues neither Hitler nor Stalin were mad in any sense the medical profession recognizes (whereas Mussolini and Mao had depression, possibly bipolar disorder)."

'Faith' in leadership?

'Choice'?

by Owen David


I remember Lord Owen's book being published, over a decade ago and heard radio interviews at the time (BBC Radio 4, Start the Week?). Not sure why I didn't pick this up as the disciplinary bridges are stark and clear (now!): PSYCHO-POLITICAL and GEO-PSYCHIATRIC. The importance of the issues the Daedalus Project addresses, now within Maudsley Philosophy Group is not just suddenly 'self' evident*, but is of importance for the world's population- impacting upon global safety and security.

Even since Lord Owen's book the rise of AI adds complexity (as ever).

 *irony intended.

Text: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3205306-in-sickness-and-in-power

Owen, D. (2009) In Sickness and in Power: Illnesses in Heads of Government during the Last 100 Years, London: Methuen Ltd.  ISBN: 978-0-413-77689-1

Plus via twitter: 


Saturday, May 09, 2020

The meaning of "Care Package"

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ----------------------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group - population

"I return to my hotel room in central Wuhan to find a package from the local government waiting for me. They have sent foreign journalists two large bottles of hand sanitiser, 20 masks and a 55-page comic book dedicated to sanitation. In one cartoon, a grinning bottle of ethyl alcohol reminds readers to wipe down their phones up to four times a day.

But the main item in the care package is a hastily bound white booklet with a cover that reads simply: The Chinese Way. ...

But the omissions in the document are often more telling than the official timeline itself. The Chinese Way makes no mention of Dr Li Wenliang, the national hero of the epidemic. On December 30, Li raised an early alarm when his hospital in Wuhan began seeing patients with a Sars-like strain of pneumonia."






Art in Wuhan depicting Dr Li Wenliang, who raised an early alarm about the coronavirus outbreak and later died of the disease © Don Weinland



https://www.ft.com/content/61ec68d8-8432-11ea-b872-8db45d5f6714

Image source: ft.com