Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: Search results for brian hodges

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query brian hodges. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query brian hodges. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, September 01, 2023

Brian E. Hodges (1942-2022) RIP Creator of Hodges' Health Career Model

The end of 2022 and start of 2023 brought loss, reflection and change in terms of family, friends and educational ties. My children said goodbye to their grandmothers in the space of two months. 

Brian E. Hodges c/o Family.
Then I was contacted by Brian Hodges’s daughter Sarah, with the news her father had died. November through to January saw me attend three consecutive funerals. I’m grateful I was able to visit Sheffield and say goodbye to Brian and meet his extended family.

Yes, it has taken a while to post this. For six months I have been sorting, clearing, rationalising books, papers with a house-sale now imminent, liaising with Brian's family too. 

It is fitting to share this sad news now and celebrate lives well-lived, cast in the promise of a new academic year. I think Brian would have liked this - the potential, and prospects for students in the semesters to follow, lecturers wrestling with how best to communicate and engage their students.

I first met Brian in 1987 when he was a Senior Lecturer at Manchester Polytechnic - which is now Manchester Metropolitan University. Brian taught on the ENB 911 Care of the Mentally Ill in the Community Certificate course. On the course Brian explained his eponymous model. This was more than a decade before Project 2000 made nursing an undergraduate programme. Brian created the model as a response to this. Brian’s qualification in Learning Disability Nursing is key to the inclusion of individual, group (carers) and the POLITICAL domain.

The model contributed to our assessment on the course, which required we complete a case study applying the model to a client/patient on a placement which was conducted with another service. Seconded from Chorley my placement experience was at Bolton. I still have my case study and a set of Brian’s original lecture notes.

Straight away I knew there was something special about Brian’s model. I suspect I’d been primed after watching Tony Buzan’s TV programmes in the 1970s, ‘Use Your Head’ and related books on mind-mapping. By the time I joined the Internet-age it was 1997. I’d written some microcomputer programs on the ZX81 and BBC Micro ‘B’: Nursing Process, Computer Aided Patient Assessment; HAEM; and Shades of Grey. Several were published by Open Software Library (no longer operating).

An ongoing interest developed in nursing theory and models of care, from reading about the nursing process. An early thought about creating a computer program about Hodges’ model crystallised in March 1997 when I came across the Nursing Development Site. This was hosted by the University of Alberta, Canada. Seeing that Hodges’ model was not listed, I contacted the site’s administrator. The response was: “Why don’t you create something and let us know.” Brian was very patient and offered his thoughts via email exchanges (saved, but in Turnpike format). In 1998 I finally got in touch with Alberta and they added a link.

The notes below are from the resulting website (1998-2015 now archived). The product of an interview with Brian at Manchester Polytechnic and my interpretation of model:
“Brian thought up HCM on the then British Rail train service, commuting between Sheffield and Manchester in 1983. He was stimulated by the need to impose structure on a curriculum for a BSc Nursing Studies course. Having defined the model in 1983 a scheduled teacher was unable to take a class, providing an opportunity for Brian to share the model and his thoughts with students. Despite this impromptu start, within a short time academic colleagues recognized the value of HCM in curriculum design and development, in addition to clinical practice.
 
A problem for practitioners has always been ensuring a comprehensive assessment has been made. The HCM facilitates that process, as an aide-mémoire, especially critical when faced with child care / abuse assessment and care evaluations. HCM was adopted as a tool for use by students on courses. Not surprisingly a key area of application is Health Visiting. Other nursing fields includes the use of case studies in post-basic education - Community Psychiatry Nursing Certificate; community and mental handicap - now learning disabilities.
 
Key phases in development
 
The main development work following initial conception, was up to 1987. Due to illness in 1990 Brian has been unable to engage in in-depth development work with the HCM. Hence Brian's bemused surprise at my contacting him. Despite this there are many educators, clinicians and no doubt health care managers who having been exposed to HCM carry it, like myself, as part of their mental toolkit. So if you have taught or used HCM in the past, or (even better) use it currently Brian and I would be delighted to hear from you. Given the duration of courses at Manchester then of course many colleagues in other parts of the north west of England have heard of HCM, used the HCM, or possess a college set of notes on HCM. Do you?” . . .

<> 

Sarah and family have kindly forwarded the eulogy which includes:
“Dad was born on 30th January 1942 to Vera and Gilbert Hodges, he was the eldest of three with a sister, Rita and younger brother Philip. He grew up in Kingswood, a suburb of Bristol and attended the local Grammar school. He loved being a Scout and was a member of the YMCA.

When he left school, he went to work for Boots the Chemist, telling us often about his’ behind the counter’ days. However, a conversation with a colleague led him to rethink his career and he applied to train as a nurse at a hospital for patients with learning difficulties. Being a male nurse in the 1960’s was quite ground-breaking, and so typical of Dad who was always pushing boundaries and taking the ‘road less travelled’.

Dad realised that he enjoyed teaching the students and became determined to raise the profile of nursing those with learning difficulties. This led to him to taking a year’s teacher training at Bolton College and with his new qualification he was determined to make an impact on nursing. In 1972 this lead to the move to Sheffield to set up a nurse training course at Sheffield Polytechnic and Middlewood hospital. He loved this job and the impact he could have on training nurses, alongside this he embarked on an Open University Degree and also developed the Hodges Health career model for nursing, which facilitated integrated care, person centredness, reflective practice and helped to bridge the theory and practice gap. He was very proud of this work, and it remains in use.
 
Alongside his work interests Dad decided that he would learn to sail, and not only how to sail, but also how to build a boat. The boat started life in the hallway of the house in Meadow Grove Road, and whilst it amused me and Sarah, there must have been a moment where Mum asked him to move it somewhere more suitable. He successfully built the boat and taught us all how to sail.
Back to his work life he was offered a job as a lecturer at Manchester University and later became Head of Nursing Studies there. He loved his job and invested a lot of time in encouraging his students with his indomitable wit and zest for life. Always wanting to learn more, he also studied for an MSc in Health Education, which meant he travelled to London and loved to tell us about his walks around Chelsea.

Life changed dramatically in 1990 when aged only 48 Dad had a severe stroke which led to a left side paralysis; and a medical assessment that he would not walk again. His sheer determination meant that he did in fact walk, although never regained use of his left arm, which made a lot of day to day tasks very difficult. He had no hesitation about asking strangers to help on his trips to London in his electric wheelchair.

Although Dad returned to work a year after the stroke, he found he could no longer do the job the way he wanted to and took early retirement. Being Dad, he did not stop working and continued to do some teaching, and travelled to other education centres as an external examiner. He also took up a number of volunteering activities which could make use of his skills. He became really involved in health care improvement through service user input and ultimately Chair of Shop Mobility in Sheffield.

One volunteering opportunity led to many and he took up a number of positions in both Sheffield and London. He loved to travel to London on his own on the train, where after his meetings, he would meet Sarah for dinner. He always said ‘focus on what you can do’ so that is what he did. After the stroke he learned to swim again and joined his grandchildren in the pool at Centre-parcs, and played badminton on one of his much loved family holidays.

He did not let the stroke stop him travelling at all and visited France, Florida, Barbados and even St Petersburg in his wheelchair. He also loved trips to Chatsworth for ice cream.

He loved listening to jazz music and rock, had learned to paint and draw. He loved the theatre and bird watching and was an avid reader. In fact, he was interested in everything, knew so much on any topic you could choose, and always more up to date than those around him, often much younger, on all the latest thinking or technology.

His philosophy of life meant that even after the catastrophic event of the stroke, it did not mean an end to living and he found other opportunities which he grasped enthusiastically.

So many people were amazed and inspired by Dad for what he achieved. He was one of life’s cheerleaders always encouraging and supporting others to fulfil their ambitions and this is what we will take with us. When we are not sure in our lives going forward we know we will think ‘What would Brian / Dad / Grandad say’. He had many sayings which we will remember and whenever anyone was facing difficulties or challenges, he would say ‘You will be alright’, and we will be alright because he has have taught us to be so.

Above all he will be remembered for his sense of humour, his huge sense of purpose and service to others and for the determination to live life to the full and never be stopped by anything or anyone. He was so proud of his family and all they have achieved. He was an inspiration and encouragement to everyone he met.

This is the final page of Dad’s life, but it is not the end. Everyone who’s life Dad touched, and all the people present here today carries a little bit of him with them, his humour, his smile, his sayings, his tenacity. So, he will live on with all of us, it is a fond farewell and not a goodbye.”
<> 

Train ticket 28/05/97 (also from 1st website)
Since the Community Psychiatric Nursing (Cert.) course in the 1980s and our initial interview 28th May 1997, Brian and I met on about ten occasions. As noted above, Brian enjoyed rail travel and in the interview I had this image of a train with thought bubbles - Brian's reflections with the model taking shape.

Image from 1st archived site
Brian’s passing and his family's observations prompted recollection of a trip to London in 1996; to an IEE Colloquium on Thinking with Diagrams (Digest No: 1996/010).

https://digital-library.theiet.org/doi/book/10.1049/conferences-1996_010

I’m sure Brian met me there, demonstrating his independence, motivation and enthusiasm. I need to check but I’m fairly sure, even imagining he said he was meeting Sarah afterwards? My father accompanied me, we stayed with an aunt who lived near London Bridge back then. Happy memories for me too.

Brian knew of several sites across the UK, that used or took an interest in Hodges’ model. When the website went live in 1998, I’d hoped people with notes, insights, examples of application, pros and cons would come forward. Sadly this did not happen except for a few instances.

I’m so pleased to have met Brian and being able to carry his model forward. Even semi-retired, I rejoice in the freedom I have as a practitioner. As I believe Brian came up against many academic barriers in trying to validate, publicise and disseminate the model. There was no expressed cynicism in this however, but political realism about how the world – academia works. A lesson I know very well in trying to publish work.

I keep fretting about not completing the ‘new’ website, but perhaps I’m following Brian’s advice after all: “focus on what you can do”. Despite its limitations the blog is helping to spread awareness of Hodges’ model; learning each year of new publications citing the model. Hodges’ model isn’t just another 2x2 matrix—business/management consultancy style thinking tool.

The key is the model’s full title:

Hodges' Health Career - Care Domains - Model

‘Health career’ refers to ‘life chances’ and this was central to Brian’s values of person-centredness, advocacy, and ‘seeing’ the political in health, social care and his own educational development and health career. 

The work remains to take Hodges’ model forward, to pass on this ‘+’ shaped baton. I will reflect further, especially as I was initially determined to ensure that Hodges' model was not just left on the shelf. For me, Brian’s legacy is the increasing relevance of his eponymous model since its creation. Consider since the late 1980s developments in human rights, consent, mental capacity, safeguarding, protection of liberty, mental health act, prison health. Brian's model readily encompasses the person and the State - nationally and globally, access and provision to health services, primary care, sustainable development goals, the determinants of health. How do we switch from illness-directed to preventive, health educational services?

In addition, Hodges' model can conceptually represent all these - across time as a series of frames. Brian's model remains a gift to his students and today's learners; including, patients, carers, mental health and general nurses, district nurses, learning disability and health visitors. As suggested here - Brian's effort and work has proved a great gift to me (as friends, family and many student nurses on placement, mentored, signed-off will attest). Brian's model is not a be all and end all, he knew this. It is one of many tools, models and theories, but it can and must also help future generations: from self care, health care, to global health and planetary care.

Thank you Brian. RIP.

Thursday, January 02, 2025

"Hi! I'm new to Hodges' model - and this blog - what's it about?"

INDIVIDUAL
|
   INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES              
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
 SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
GROUP

The model was created in the early - mid 1980's with four purposes in mind - to facilitate:

1. reflection & develop reflective practitioners;
2. person-centred, integrated (holistic) care;
3. help bridge the theory-practice gap;
4. curriculum design, planning and development.

This was prompted by the change in the UK to university-based nurse education, which was to commence in (Project) 2000.

Learning and applying Hodges' model in 1987-88, and creating a website 1998-2015, I am clearly invested in Hodges' model and biased, questions and debate are welcome.

Created by Brian E.

Hodges' model is a generic framework - 
a conceptual framework.

This model is situated, as 'generic' suggests
which means of course it is universal.

If you've a problem, scenario forthcoming project, or one that is nearing completion Hodges' model can assist in reflection and critical thinking to plan, scope, or evaluate as per your purpose.

This blog has posts about papers, events that interest me (PJ), plus many posts using this two-by-two table approach that suggests how the model can be applied in a variety of contexts.

This blog also has a bibliography
and template in the sidebar.

Hodges^

As noted previously (and last month!), it is marvellous to hear news of a paper citing Hodges' model. If you are planning a piece of writing, research and believe that Hodges' model may be of help please get in touch.

If you don't and can see merit in Hodges' model asit is presented, that is fine also. In fact, although I mention collaboration unique - untainted perspectives are probably much needed. Learning of a citation after publication is great news and encouragement.

This could and should be an amazing community:
Welcome to the QUAD

Thank you for your visit and interest.
Any questions pleased to try to help:
h2cmng AT yahoo.co.uk

As a nurse who trained in learning disability, Brian Hodges was acutely aware of the political in health care, the role of the institutions and the aspiration of community-based and person-centred care.

Yes, you can use the model. It is open source. 
All we* ask is that you cite and credit the source.

With the 'politics of health' much in mind there are many papers to write on the model that includes: reflection; person-centredness; integration of care; self care TO planetary health FROM ?; Inter- multi- transdisciplinary in Hodges' model; A model of healthcare viewed mathematically: Surely you're joking Mr Hodges?

This blog started in 2006, the template is dated, comments are disabled. A new site - repository is needed.

*In Brian's memory too : Brian E. Hodges (1942-2022) RIP^

Thursday, September 19, 2013

H2CM new website - A short-form project brief



In Dani Nordin’s Drupal for Designers, chapter 4 is includes a short-form project brief.

As I pack for Prague and another Drupalcon (my 6th!) and with PHPNW conference fast approaching it's time I re-visited my project brief:

1 Identify the Project Goals


According to Nordin a good list of project goals should be no more than about three bullet points.
  1. To provide a new archive for Brian Hodges’ lecture notes and make these accessible and multilingual
  2. To share / signpost papers to date and invite others to collaborate and share work
  3. To highlight why Hodges’ model matters
Then Dani moved to personas and here I'll extend the above goals.

2 Identify the Audience

I am looking for student nurses, that is under graduates and post grad, indeed life-long learners within the field of health and social care. In seeking students the natural progression of this is to connect if possible with lecturers and faculty. Nordin lists several ways to characterise the personas through common aspects:
  • Who they are
  • What will win them
  • What I need them to know
  • Content focus
So immediately I can broadly identify and develop two personas:

Learners

Who they are: Student nurses, social work students including medicine and other health and social care disciplines. They will be seeking evidence in theory and practice, with sources and resources to apply to assigned work. They will also be open to ideas and techniques that can help them to structure and recall their learning.
What will win them: Make it easy for them to see what is offered, find what they seek, Brian Hodges' lecture notes, provide feedback on learning if students are willing to register and invest their time. Provide a responsive contact form to answer questions promptly. Link the content to evidence if, or as soon as possible. Make content relevant by allowing users to contribute to website's development and direction.
What I need them to know: I want to convey to them an understanding of Hodges’ model its purposes, structure, content and how the model might be applied in theory and practice.
Content focus: Lecture notes text and video; Quiz; Test; Certificate; h2cm grid; Case study template; Presentations; FAQ; Registration; Contact form; Polls; Bibliography; Biographies; Timeline; Photos.

Lecturers

Who are they: Health and social care related faculty, teaching on nursing, social work, learning disability and other programmes. A diverse range of subjects and disciplines could be included from mental health, acute care, community and across the life course.
What will win them: Illustrate the ways h2cm can facilitate learning the aspects of (for example) nursing, not only reinforcing the key concepts of nursing (care) but why they care.
What I need them to know: Understanding how h2cm fits within their respective curriculum. Gaining awareness of how can the model can potentially stimulate and challenge their students and complement assignments. Why Hodges' model is relevant at this particular time.
Content focus: Brian Hodges' lecture notes; Outstanding questions; Research directions; Blog; Contact form; Registration; h2cm examples.

On the old website I possibly over-egged the pudding in terms of 'audiences'. There is an introductory page for -
  • students and lecturer; 
  • patients and carers;
  • the public (citizens);
  • and managers with policy makers.
Nordin has a persona for The Sharer. There are people for whom this is their forte. Here though I would try to include sharing tools that might be utilised by specific audiences. So for lecturers ways sharing might be Academia.edu, ResearchGate and LinkedIn. Likewise there are student (social media oriented) communities.The content of the old was fixed - by me. This needs to change, so polls and discussion may help define what the students / lecturers would like to see, hear ...

3 Focus on Information Architecture and Content Strategy

Nordin is describing a website re-design and so am I with some simplifications. Taking step 3 literally and from reading having an information architecture is very important to me. Its importance is not just in earning a scout badge, but it may need to vary slightly across the site. Nordin's step three seems to emphasize content. I'm wondering about headings, subtitles and other structural and aesthetic points. How might these work and hopefully cohere across the archive and rest of the site? It is also the case of separating (in my head) information architecture and styling.

As to content strategy I've played and doodled with this on several occasions. There's even an A, B, C, ... about it if you check above.

4 Identify New Features or Technologies You Want to Include

Responsive design is as Nordin also indicates a must have for me. In successive Drupalcon keynotes Dries Buytaert has stressed the rise of mobile devices. It would be a major gain to have the archive readable by mobile and tablet users.

Thus far I've not made full use of video, Skype and even audio for delivering content. At Drupalcon Prague there's a session media management and the Scald module. I'm hardly a radio or TV station but as people say DO consider those things that you are not skilled at, or naturally drawn to. Slides and presentations both existing and contributions (or links) would also be a key content feature.

If a community can emerge this might also be that as Nordin suggests users can share internally within the site using (unconsciously) specific structures within Drupal. The latest means of classifying and searching a site will also be essential. Seeking to share h2cm with the world I've scheduled some sessions on leveraging the multilingual capabilities of Drupal 8.

Accessibility is another essential feature.

5 Upgrade, or Start from Scratch

This, thankfully, is not an upgrade. To the list in #4 I could have added database - a dynamic website because this is the primary need, the enabler. With that though comes complexity and responsibility. Website management then demands data be protected, secure, backed up, and this involves migration and upgrades. So, starting from scratch - yes, but with an eye to upgrading.

The NW Drupal meetings in Manchester and Drupalcon Prague program bring the news of the many new tools and changes in Drupal 8:
  • Views in core;
  • New configurable fields e.g. entity reference, date, e-mail and others;
  • Multilingual changes;
  • Blocks & Layouts;
  • Responsive images and breakpoints.

    From Drupalcon Prague "Drupal 8 for Site Builders" session
In addition there is Symfony, the loss of some hooks, Twig a templating engine.

6 Figure Out Theming and CSS Issues

If .Net and Web Designer magazines inform us of two things it's the pace of change in tools and the range of tools. It's helpful then when those choices are reduced. This may be the case with CSS within Drupal and adopting a grid system, a point made by Todd Nienkerk (p.79).

There are some excellent themes and sub-themes within Drupal 7. Drupal 8 extends this potential. I posted previously about Omega.

To conclude:
I think there is an interesting project here, but thinking alone isn't going to get this done!

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Oh dear! I forgot to ask the nurse (doctor)....

Hodges' model introduction II:

The view from the other side of the fence


Have you ever been to see the doctor or nurse and shortly after leaving the surgery, or clinic you've remembered something? These days - very sadly - many people go to the doctor to seek help for their memory, but for others this is a fact of that frustrating mix of vital questions and issues to raise amid recognition that the time of nurses and doctors is very precious.

This post introduces a framework that can help people to prepare for a consultation and maintain a record of just where their care situation is up to. The framework in question is called Hodges' model. It is named after a retired Senior Lecturer - Mr Brian E. Hodges who lives in Sheffield, England. Brian Hodges created the model to help nurses and community staff ensure the care they deliver is holistic. Holistic in this sense means covering all the essential aspects that contribute to health and well-being, so that includes physical, emotional and mental and even spiritual health.

If you need to go into hospital you do not want to be treated like a faulty machine. Of course, in an emergency those machine-like things we do like heart beat, respiration, temperature regulation are of central importance. Should you ever need emotional care for a severe mental health problem then you would also expect that your physical needs are taken fully into account. Amidst these aspects of care the health care team must also pay attention to culture, equality, diversity and access to services.

Although the model was developed in the 1980s its relevance and potential increases in all the time. This is because of the following:

* health care and medicine is increasingly complex;
* people may have long term and multiple chronic problems;
* education is essential to 21st century care management - as people are expected to 'self-care';
- people may also be managing their own care budget and so need information and 360 vision;
* policy makers stress the need for 'patient choice';
* high quality health and social care is very expensive;
* as people live longer and may have several relationships spanning cultures and belief systems the notion of a health career is the career.

Hodges' model builds on two basic facts of life (and death):

From your point of view and that of any health or social care professional your health is about you - an INDIVIDUAL.

Your health affects other people - most significantly your family. Rather than you being ill, you may of course be a carer having to look after a relative. Also affected are work colleagues, the wider community through to whole GROUPS of people.

We now talk about medicine, well-being, and health in terms of global health since the population of Earth is so tightly linked and interdependent.

In order to maintain health there is a need to diagnose and intervene - or assess, plan, intervene and evaluate. Here the model can also take into account ethnic and transcultural aspects of health. Diagnosis and intervention in Western medicine is frequently MECHANISTIC and this is balanced (remember that HOLISTIC part of the model) by the need for HUMANISTIC interventions. This is what we mean by 'bedside manner' and people being 'caring'. The ability to empathise with others and develop a therapeutic rapport after physical and emotional trauma is a great gift - that while often innate can also be learned and honed.

Once Brian Hodges had identified the following dimensions of care:

INDIVIDUAL - GROUP and HUMANISTIC - MECHANISTIC

he considered the types of knowledge that health and social care workers need to not only do their job safely, effeciently and effectively, but also help people to help themselves. This led to the FOUR CARE or KNOWLEDGE DOMAINS, each covers a key aspect of care:

SCIENCES: e.g. anatomy, physiology,healing process, drugs, risk, diagnosis...

INTRAPERSONAL: e.g. mood, thinking, beliefs, communication, education, learning, coping...

SOCIOLOGY: e.g. relationships, roles, meaning, groups, resources

POLITICAL: e.g. choice, consent, autonomy, policy, legislation, finances

Students - young and mature - who decide to study health and social care can use the model to help them reflect on critical events in their training and learning. The model can help them gain some insights in completing essays and case studies integrating knowledge and experience. When you think about it: if it essential that care professionals are able to have an effective dialogue with patients and the public then they should also be capable of having an effective 'dialogue' with themselves.

Members of the public can also be taught the model to help them appreciate the factors involved in their care programs, solutions and ongoing management if required. Hopefully this brief explanation sheds some light on the model's mantra:

Hodges' Health Career (Care Domains) Model: h2cm
h2cm: help 2C more - help 2 listen - help 2 care

Hodges' model is no universal panacea it is just a tool; but while services stress the need for person-centered, integrated, value-for-money, high quality services ... built on respect, dignity, trust and choice - YOUR health career matters.

h2cm can help pull the many threads together....

<>

On the website's homepage there are four introductions based upon the care domains. Each one addresses a particular audience: learners (SCIENCES); patient (INTRAPERSONAL); carer (SOCIOLOGY) and policy maker / manager (POLITICAL). They all need updating (re-writing?!).

If you would like to contribute to this exercise please contact me through twitter or at h2cmng at yahoo.co.uk

Friday, February 20, 2009

Reprise: Hodges' model introduction

Developed in the UK during the early 1980s, Hodges’ model (h2cm) is a conceptual framework that is person-centered and situation based. In structure it combines two axes to create four care (knowledge) domains (as illustrated on the website). Academics and practitioners in many fields create models that help support theory and practice (Wilber, 2000). Models act as a memory jogger and guide. In health care generic models can encourage holistic practice directing the user to consider the patient as a whole person and not merely as a diagnosis derived from physical investigations? Exposure of h2cm is limited to a small (yet growing) cadre of practitioners; several published articles (Hinchcliffe, 1989; Adams, 1987; please see the bibliography on this blog). In addition to a website (Jones, 1998) there is a blog and an audio presentation both first published in 2006.

The best way to explain h2cm is to review the questions Hodges originally posed....

To begin, who are the recipients of care?

Well, first and foremost individuals of all ages, races and creed, but also groups of people, families, communities and populations. In this way the potential scope of Hodges' model is personal and global.

Then Brian Hodges asked: what types of activities - tasks, duties, and treatments - do nurses carry out?

They must always act professionally, but frequently according to strict rules and policies, their actions often dictated by specific treatments including drugs, investigations, and minor surgery. Users who adopt Hodges' model find that the model transcends the purely task-based perspectives of care and intervention. Hodges' model also encompasses beliefs, attitudes, motivation, self-awareness, and values. Nurses do many things by routine according to precise procedures, the stereotypical matron - machine-like efficiency? If these are classed as mechanistic, they contrast with times when healthcare workers give of themselves to reassure, comfort, develop rapport and engage therapeutically. This is opposite to mechanistic tasks and is described as humanistic; what the public usually think of as the caring nurse. In use this framework prompts the user to consider four major subject headings or care domains of knowledge. Namely, what knowledge is needed to care for individuals - groups and undertake humanistic - mechanistic activities?

Through these questions Hodges’ derived the model depicted on the website.

Initial study of h2cm on the website has related Hodges’ model to the multicontextual nature of health, informatics, consilience (Wilson, 1998), interdisciplinarity, and visualization. H2cm says nothing about the study of knowledge, but a great deal about the nature of knowledge is implied in the models structure and knowledge domains. This prompted two web pages devoted to the structural and theoretical assumptions of h2cm. Although the axes of h2cm are dichotomous, they also represent continua. This duality is important as for example an individual’s mental health status is situated on a continuum spanning excellent to extremely unwell. There are various states in-between affected by an individual’s beliefs, response to stress, coping strategies, epigenetic and other influences. H2cm was created to meet four educational objectives:

1. To produce a curriculum development tool.
2. Help ensure holistic assessment and evaluation.
3. To support reflective practice.
4. To reduce the theory-practice gap.

Since h2cm’s formulation these objectives have grown in relevance. The 1980s may seem remote, but these problems are far from archaic as expansion of points 1-4 reveals. Education is now preparation for life-long learning. Curricula are under constant pressure. Despite decades of policy declarations, truly holistic care (combining physical, mental and pastoral care) remains elusive. The concept and practice of reflection swings like a metronome, one second seemingly de rigour, the next moment the subject of web based polls. H2cm can be used in interviews, outlining discussion and actions to pursue, an agenda - agreed and shared at the end of a session. The model is equally at home on paper, blackboard, flipchart and interactive whiteboard. Finally, technology is often seen as a way to make knowledge available to all; the means to bridge theory-practice gap through activities such as e-learning, governance and knowledge management. The digital divide cannot be bridged by idealism alone.

The axes within h2cm create a cognitive space; a third axis projecting through the page can represent history; be that an educational, health or other ‘career’. It is ironic, that an act of partition can simultaneously represent reductionism and holism. Reductionism has a pivotal role to play, which h2cm acknowledges in the sciences domain. What h2cm can do is prompt the user that there are three other pages to reflect and write upon.

Should you be interested I can f/w two papers on Hodges' model published 2008 and 2009: please contact me at h2cmng at yahoo.co.uk. Much of the material on the website is in need of update, or removal - if you would like to help please let me know. The time for partnership in spreading Hodges' model is now....

REFERENCES:

Adams, T. (1987). Dementia is a Family Affair. Community Outlook, Feb, pp. 7-8.
Hodges E. Brian (1989). Hodges health Career Model, IN, Hinchcliffe, S.M. (Ed.). Nursing Practice and Health Care, [1st Edition only], London, Edward Arnold.
Wilber, K. (2000). Integral Psychology: Consciousness, Spirit, Psychology, Therapy. Shambhala Publications.
Wilson, E.O. (1998). Consilience: The Unity of Knowledge, Abacus.

See this blog's bibliography for references and the blog labels (tags) for additional resources.

Monday, October 22, 2007

"Perceptions of Nursing and of a Midwestern Associate Degree Nursing Program" study by Shannon Frodge

In August I posted the news and success of Shannon Frodge's Master's study in which Hodges' model was used as a theoretical framework.

I've copied the abstract, Shannon's reference to Hodges' model and her research questions below. There are some 55 pages, 9,700 words in total, if you want to the read the discussion and conclusion well according to Shannon the text is available on ProQuest.

Every so often I'll bring up the matter of nurse, health and social care recruitment on W2TQ: it really is going to be critical. I do not work in HR - recruitment, but being interested in public (mental) health I am very conscious of demographic trends and be(d)sides standards of care matter too...

Thanks Shannon for the copy, your specific focus on this issue and for recognising and using Hodges' model. I know evidence is important in terms of the tools we use, but you've demonstrated that tools can have a legitimate entry point in their adoption and application. You've posed many questions and presented new angles with recommendations too.

Abstract

The current nursing shortage is complicated by the fact not enough students choose nursing to offset the number of nurses who are nearing retirement. This is distressing to the profession, and is of particular interest to nursing schools. This quantitative, descriptive correlational study examined the perceptions of 99 students in grades sixth through twelfth in a public Midwestern school system regarding nursing as a career choice, 41 current students in the local community college’s nursing program, and recruiting methods that would or did most influence them. The framework for the study is Brian Hodge's Health Career Model. Students were surveyed using a Likert scale tool with demographics and comments. Descriptive statistics included frequency tables, cross tabulations, chi squared, and confidence intervals. Comments were grouped for qualitative phenomenological purposes. Findings indicated statistically significant differences in perceptions of students based on sex and grade which could be used to enhance recruitment efforts.

Research Questions

Specific research questions pertaining to this study are:

1. Are middle and high school students in a Midwestern community considering nursing as a career choice?
a. If so, what are the reasons?
b. If not, what are the reasons?
c. What recruitment strategies would most influence these students to decide on nursing as a career choice?
d. What recruitment strategies would most influence these students to seek their education at the Midwestern community college ADN program?

2. Of currently enrolled students in a Midwestern community college ADN program:
a. What recruitment strategies most influenced these students to decide on nursing as a career choice?
b. What recruitment strategies most influenced these students to seek their education at the Midwestern community college ADN program?

Theoretical Framework

The framework for this study is Brian Hodges’ Health Career Model (Hodges, 1997). This model looks at the nurse as an individual whose practice depends on his/her education and past experiences (Hodges, 1997). The model is composed of two intersecting lines that look at the nurse’s attributes both individually and in group settings, and his/her ability to perform job duties both interpersonal and mechanical (Hodges, 1997). Within the four quadrants then, Hodges identifies four major areas of knowledge necessary to practice nursing (Hodges, 1997).

This particular framework lends itself to this study as it looks at traits of individuals who are nurses and helps to explain how their background and knowledge influence the care they give. Hodges writes “the health career is influenced by personal factors of the individual of physical or psychological origin and factors relating to the social world and the policies that govern daily life” (Hodges, pp 1, 1997). Because some of these attributes or interest in these knowledge areas must be present in order for an individual to choose nursing, the model is appropriate to the study.

Thursday, November 23, 2023

Hodges' model - as 'a' philosophy c/o TPM

As much as I might like, or aspire to write, this is not a treatise on Hodges' model as a philosophy. Anyway: why limit ourselves to one 'philosophy', when several might apply, or at least be found?

Other TPM articles within the 50 new ideas issue point to Hodges' model (of course 😉).

Philosophy itself may benefit. Philosophy is "the love of wisdom". While there are dangers in siloed kowledge and the thought that put it there, what is classed as wise across the domains of Hodges' model in a given context? Contexts change, but how can philosophical reasoning help us 'keep our options open'? Or is the situation and context 'closed'? 

Again much as I might like, in response to Benatar's Forsaking wisdom (pp.23-24) I'm not trying to clever - even my sense of humour does not extend that far. We do want to apply Hodges' model  practically. Maybe disciplines exist in a perennial state of self-doubt? Peter Boghossian discusses Philosophy that matters (pp.29-30). Nursing is no exception being challenged still regards its professional and academic identity. In mental health nursing there are concerns about the field as a specialty being genericised. The nursing discipline for which identity and meaning is key finds its own identity challenged. Helen De Cruz writes of The Philosopher's rut (pp.41-42). A contributing factor is the tendency in philosophical debates to be dominated by two-well-outlined opposing positions. This framing can stifle exploration, and yet in Hodges' model with oppositions built-in the model as a whole provides conceptual escape; a series of conceptual spaces to explore. 

Hodges' model can help postpone what De Cruz refers to as cognitive closure, another reason for the philosopher's rut. We tend, psychologically to draw quick conclusions such that we are averse to ambiguity. This may be innate to a degree, as seen in 'black and white' thinking. Ironically, for me with Hodges' model is the counterposition of reflection as navel-gazing, resulting in too many options, and no decision at all.  

With the self, I, individual appearing to take a prime position in Hodges' model, Michael Cholbi reminds us of the philosophical significance and history of self-knowledge (pp.35-36). Student nurses need to acquire sufficient substantial self-knowledge to be safe, effective, competent, satisfied and lifelong learning practitioners. In another issue 98 4th Quarter 2022, Jonathan Matheson asks Why Think for Yourself (pp. 26-32), is there a rationale in intellectual autonomy and love of truth? You can exercise your intellectual autonomy and make it collaborative, by deciding on the port of entry to Hodges' model. This is a determinant in terms of the context, the situation that prompts you reach for the model in the first place. 

me - you INDIVIDUAL - the few
  |
     INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
others - GROUP - many
inherent philosophy in Hodges' model

the mind - my mind
Personal identity
epistemology
ontology - being - identity
my - beliefs - (yours)

abstraction
logic - mathematics

concept of opposition^
opposition of concepts^

representation of -isms

ethics - moral reasoning

values - value

unconditional positive regard


physicality - materialism

the brain - my brain - body
Organic identity
implicit binary structure

superimposed relations
vectors

coding and classification

language corpora

reality as orientation:
(e.g., what three things do we need to know?)

personalised medicine ('up here')

professional scope - curricula
silos of knowledge

scientific method/methodologies

language - semantics - meaning
dialectics
'other minds'
practical reasoning

applied philosophy

individual-collective debate:
utilitarian principles

social philosophy

socialisation of learners (professions)

conformance - group think


health in politics
politics in health
human rights

the unborn - future humans

protected human characteristics

diametrical oppositions in Hodges' model
(e.g., 1. my mental state - mental health law; 2. public understanding - of science; 3. my freedom - the law. 4. culture - (techno-culture!) - science...)

power - freedom

political philosophy



In John Corvino's Applied philosophy out of the closet (pp.39-40), I'm not sure if it was Martha Nussbaum who stressed the need for philosophy to be practical. Is this the same as applied? I note her work on capabilities. Hodges' model seeks to reduce the gap between the learning involved in (between - hence bridging) theory and practice - to achieve competencies. For the future of (Brian) Hodges' model this matters, as I understand that efforts are ongoing to apply category theory to the social sciences. It is a pragmatic conceptual structure. To return to identity, A M Ferner tackles (literally?) Organic identity (pp.49-50); while Kerrie Grain takes on what is next-door in Hodges' model - Personal identity (pp. 51-52). As I continue to sort papers, journals and books there is more to follow. 


The Philosopher's Magazine, "50 New Ideas", 1st Quarter 2016. Issue 72. pp.20-120.

TPM #72 cover image: https://ericthomasweber.org/correcting-political-correctness/

^Ack.
Needham, R. (1987). Counterpoints. Berkeley: University of California Press.
(Looking f/w - I think - to chapters 7-8. With specific post(s) to follow.)

Sunday, January 20, 2008

The symbol '+'

Apart from a multitude of symbolic meanings the figure below also provides the structural foundation for Hodges' model and as symbols.com notes:
Cross from symbols.com

The cross with arms of equal length is an extremely old ideogram used in most cultures. It is also one of the basic gestalts in Western ideography (as opposed to the basic elements, which are derived entities). The cross is found in every part of the world, in prehistoric caves and engraved on rocks.
In my interview with Brian Hodges' over 10 years ago in May 1997, Brian provided an account for how he arrived at this structure (summarised below). As mentioned elsewhere on this blog, the website, symbols.com and other sources - the cross, or 2x2 matrix is a common device to explain and structure. The four elements, the four humours (or humors) yellow bile, black bile, phlegm and blood, the seasons; there are so many things that can be characterised in this way.

With '+' as a starting point for me to reflect on Hodges' model I see each line as an individual. This agent or subject could include patient (person) and health care worker; lecturer and student and many other examples.

The act of cros-sing, the intersection of the axes represents two human beings being in a situation.

Space and time brings people together:

and also forces us apart - physically and temporally.

Adding an arrow to one end of these axes creates the dynamic of communication.

The angular distance in the alignment of those arrows offers hope -
  • in our common humanity we are never in 180 degree opposition;
and yet acknowledges:
  • the isolation of the individual -
  • and the challenge.
The work that must done. Hence the primacy of communication skills and values; in order to bridge individual being, ti:me and space.

Perspective is helpful here as an extension:

While we may get close to another person, through relationships that entwine the lines - be they spun by professional obligations, friendship, family ties, or intimate sexual relationships - the two lines are always distinct: part of an elaborated knot.

Is it just the special ties that must forever seek to be one+



The best way to explain h2cm is to review the questions Brian Hodges originally posed.

To begin, who are the recipients of care? Well, first and foremost individuals of all ages, races and creed, but also groups of people, families, communities and populations. Then Hodges asked: what types of activities - tasks, duties, and treatments - do nurses carry out? They must always act professionally, but frequently according to strict rules and policies, their actions often dictated by specific treatments including drugs, investigations, and minor surgery. Nurses do many things by routine according to precise procedures, rather like the stereotypical matron with machine-like efficiency? If these actions are classed as mechanistic, they contrast with times when healthcare workers give of themselves to reassure, comfort, develop rapport and engage therapeutically.

This is opposite to mechanistic tasks and is described as humanistic; what the public usually think of as the caring nurse. In use this framework prompts the user to consider four major subject headings or care domains of knowledge. Namely, what knowledge is needed to care for individuals - groups and undertake humanistic - mechanistic activities? Through these questions Hodges’ derived the model axial structure.

Sunday, October 15, 2006

Hodges Model References Bundle

I've finally put the primary references in a bundle [Oct 2006] and used ccPublisher to publish the document on the Internet Archive. I missed a few details off the JAN reference (Volume, Issue) which are included below. It would be great to see this list grow through your contributions....

As the first podcast script is also complete I've no excuse to delay much longer. I am leaving for Bath this evening a workshop, so will tackle this next weekend... Bye for now. PJ

Primary references as of October 2006 (if you know of others please get in touch):

Adams, T. (1987) Dementia is a family affair. Community Outlook, Feb, 7-8.

Hinchcliffe, S.M. (et al.) (1989) Nursing Practice and Health Care, 1st Edition only, London, Edward Arnold.

Jones, P. (2004) Viewpoint: Can informatics and holistic multidisciplinary care be harmonised? British Journal of Healthcare Computing & Information Management, 21, 6, 17-18.

Jones, P. (2004) The Four Care Domains: Situations Worthy of Research, Conference: Building & Bridging Community Networks: Knowledge, Innovation & Diversity through Communication, Brighton, UK. March 2004.
[http://www.comminit.com/healthecomm/planning.php?showdetails=318] Accessed: Oct 07 2006.
(If you visit the above link you can download this position paper - look at the bottom of the page.)

All the above are about the model – Hinchliffe is one chapter by Brian Hodges.

---------------------------------------------------
Hughes, E. (1958) Men and their work. New York: Free Press.

Hughes is used by Brian Hodges to define health career the idea of life chances.
---------------------------------------------------
You can also of course reference webpages:
[ no longer available:
web archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20121230101851/http://www.p-jones.demon.co.uk/ ]

Jones, P. (1998-2006). Hodges' Health Career Care Domains Model, [http://www.p-jones.demon.co.uk] Accessed: Oct 07 2006.
Jones, P. (2000) Hodges' Health Career Care Domains Model, Structural Assumptions;
[http://www.p-jones.demon.co.uk/theory.html] Accessed: Oct 07 2006.
Jones, P. (2000) Hodges' Health Career Care Domains Model, Theoretical Assumptions;
[http://www.p-jones.demon.co.uk/struct.html] Accessed: Oct 07 2006.

The Journal of Advanced Nursing paper below is prior to the website, but hints at the way I have since stressed the role of information within Hodges model as the unifying concept.

Jones, P. (1996) Humans, Information, and Science, Journal of Advanced Nursing, Vol. 24,3, September, 591-598.

Friday, January 02, 2026

Nothing new under the Sun ...

 ... unless you're a 'health' service, or gathering dust on a shelf

January. Is the time of Janus: we look forward and back.

In April, this blog 'Hodges' model: Welcome to the QUAD - W2tQ' will be twenty years young. A blog post will follow with some metrics and statistics, although the 'analytics' that accompany many websites is not the main objective here. Preceding W2tQ and that first post, was the now archived website:

https://web.archive.org/web/20150316193042/http://www.p-jones.demon.co.uk/index.htm

Running from 1998-2015, the site's emergence ran as per:

Taught and applied Hodges' model on
 Community Psychiatric Nursing Certificate course 1987-1988.
Using the model in my practice and sharing with colleagues.
Gaining online access 1997.

Finding the Nursing Theory Development Site - NTDS 
(no longer available)
which was at https://www.ualberta.ca/en/index.html 
Meeting Brian Hodges at Manchester Met. University in May 1997.
Publishing the website in 1998.

Listed at the NTDS was a broad range of models of nursing and nursing theories. Brian's model, as anticipated was missing. I asked about Brian Hodges's model being added as a resource. Back then I thought, and still do, that Brian's work deserves recognition and more importantly, actually being used by practitioners and learners. It was a shame I thought, that such a person-centered and integrative model should be sat on a shelf (like other great ideas) gathering dust?

Still limping along in theme, functionality and accessibility, at least W2tQ has outlived the original website.

Academia and professional bodies across healthcare disciplines stress the need for research in practice. As a consequence, I've wondered about the pool of research questions that a healthcare, nursing, community nurse might have in mind? Ready and waiting, for those instances when specific funding materialises for a project. How many of these questions might feature as recurring characters? Once articulated, there for a new team member, are several starter-questions, a primer, to encourage exploration and critical thought. (Of course, a researcher needs to frame the question themselves; even if they do not 'own' them - public, patient engagement in research?).

With sustainability still on the political agenda (whatever the media suggests), is there a plan gathering dust, for the redesign, no less, of the National Health Service? Having squandered the demographic dividend of the 1950-1980s, how do we create concurrent health caring and preventive/educational services and systems?

Now, there is a project that Hodges' model could assist with! Better check the shelves (floppy disks!) and blow the dust-off real quick!

Saturday, November 02, 2013

Papers, possible post-grad studies, conferences and a visit to Brian Hodges

This coming Monday and Wednesday I'm investigating post graduate study options with visits to Sheffield and Lancaster Universities.

Heading to Sheffield on Monday I'm also looking forward to catching up with Brian Hodges the creator of Hodges' model in the 1980s. It has been a long time since Brian and I met. I'll see if there is anything I can feedback here.

There is one conference abstract submitted for a presentation next year and another abstract almost completed. This for a workshop which I'm structuring such that it might also inform possible future studies. With these two abstracts for UK based events, I'm also looking at conferences abroad in the latter half of 2014 and 2015. So if anyone has any suggestions please let me know.

The paper on recovery in mental health and Hodges' model is not too far from a complete first draft. It runs to 5,000 words now. I had a great start with the help of two people. Twitter can be a great help in garnering assistance and with a quick response.

There is some feedback and contacts to follow up on the service-user research side (see references below). One research project to cite is True Colours an online self-management system. The advice over the past few weeks is also quite illuminating in evidencing Hodges' model. Another draft paper on case formulation, diagrams and h2cm is well advanced, but on hold at present.

Rose, D., Sweeney, A., Leese, M., Clement, S, Burns, T, Catty, J & Wykes, T. (2009) Developing a user-generated measure of continuity of care: Brief report. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica.: 119: 320–324.

Rose, D. Fleischmann, P and Wykes, P. (2008) What are mental health service users’ priorities for research in the UK? Journal of Mental Health, 17 (3): 520-530.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Papers, *actual* post-grad studies and a visit to Brian Hodges

Early last month I posted about planned trips to Sheffield and Lancaster Universities.

On the 4th I visited Paula Procter at Sheffield Hallam University, spending two hours there. Paula and I have known each other through informatics conferences since the late 1980s or early 90s and the British Computer Society Nursing Specialist Group. (Sadly this group and its publications are not as active as they used to be.) I really appreciate Paula's time and her key conclusion that rather than thinking about Hodges' model I need to apply my knowledge and experience with the model and DO something with it. In doing something with the model in a certain community - most likely residential care and nursing homes - I would also have a potential community of users for the new website. This was quite something to hear as I'm at that stage of my career when, shall we say - other possibilities beckon.

In the afternoon I travelled the short distance to meet Brian Hodges at his home. It was great to meet with Brian again and his wife. It was a lovely sunny afternoon as per the welcome and some cake! We reflected on the respective changes over the past five years and current events. Hot-off-the-press of course was my sharing the discussion with Paula and the planned visit to Lancaster University.

We agreed to meet again and not leave it so long next time. Brian has a desire to write again and and a prospective topic in dependence - independence. I hope this is something Brian can do and forward a photo for the (still) promised site. Brian now has copies of the most recent papers and the latest draft on recovery in mental health and the model.

On the Wednesday, after work I drove to Lancaster to discuss their PhD E-Research and Technology Enhanced Learning (thesis and coursework) distance learning.

At the start of last week a reserve place - for January 2015 became an offer of a place next month.

So, as of next month I will make a start. There is a residential week to look forward to at the end of March. Three second hand books from the reading list are ordered. There is a recommended video link too that invites repeat viewing, Etienne Wenger on Communities of Practice:

http://www.239productions.co.uk/wenger/

- and in the Nursing Informatics book I'm reading for review, on page 189 box 11.1 is on the same topic and referenced source Wenger, E..

I predicted quite some time ago about the post count decreasing here ... now I have an excuse and I plan on this including Drupal.

Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Book: "The Empty Space"

The Empty Space, Peter Brook

 In July I caught up with Mr Brian Hodges who created Hodges' model. Having met previously in November 2013 we agreed not to leave it as long next time and so I returned on 7th October.

One question I had was whether in addition to Hughes there were any other influences that led Brian to the model overall?

Brian could not recall a specific reference, but mentioned the theatre being an influence. I, in turn had picked up a second-hand book on one of several recent trips to London, but the title evaded me. Once home I checked and the book is "The Empty Space" by Peter Brook. A Gower Street bargain at £4.99. Brian also checked and emailed to confirm this is the book on his shelf too.

While in London (and elsewhere) I try to visit the theatre and  now look for performances of Ibsen's plays. Whatever I do see, A Doll's House this month, before the performance starts the set design is always intriguing. I've posted on this before, Hodges' model providing a 'stage set', one that should the play require can include the operating theatre.

As a mental health nurse the themes of Ibsen's plays still resonate today. From the performances I have attended the public finds ongoing relevance in: The Master Builder, Ghosts, The Lady from the Sea, Rosmersholm, Hedda Gabler and An Enemy of the People. This is true of the work by others. The drama of life and death that Hodges' model can also stage.

Brian emailed me about a situation that stood out for him in the book, so I will revisit this. What caught my eye is the cover of Brook's book (and yes, the graphic first). Without even opening the book, the 'scene' is (possibly?) set on the book's cover "A Book About the Theatre: Deadly, Holy, Rough, Immediate" ...


 individual
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ----------------------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group - population

Holy


Immediate

Rough

Deadly




Hughes, E. (1958) Men and their work. New York: Free Press. (Hughes was used by Brian to define ‘health career’ the idea of life chances.)

Sunday, May 05, 2019

Innovations: From Myths To Reality (Revisiting - Berkun, 2007)



Even though Brexit may have normalised hoarding, temporarily(?) at an economic level, I've been sorting some books to 'go' because of  'new' arrivals. Here then are some further reflections on Hodges' model as an innovation in response to Scott Berkun's 2007 title. As you can see there are many overlaps between Berkun's myths of innovation, which in the book are each given a chapter:

Myth #1: The Myth of the Epiphany

The creation of Hodges' model by Brian Hodges in the mid-1980s might be likened to an epiphany of sorts. I didn't ask that particular question when we met in 1998. It was however, more accurately a solution to the forthcoming challenge of Project 2000 and the revolution in the nurse education from schools of nursing to university based, undergraduate courses of study.



This educational, theory and practice-based focus is evident in the four purposes for the model's creation:
  1. Person-centred - holistic care;
  2. To bridge the theory - practice gap;
  3. To facilitate reflection and reflective practice;
  4. To support curriculum development.
If we are talking 'myths' too, how many of these issues were at the model's creation in the mid-1980s what we would term legacy issues now?

Myth #2: We Understand the History of Innovation

If the rise of ideas and the existence of 'fads' suggests that innovations wax and wane - falling out of fashion then - yes. There is a history. I'm assuming that the emphasis on models and theory development in nursing is past its 'golden age'? Whether we understand innovation in the healthcare, medicine, nursing, other disciplines is another question; especially socio-technically. I will return to this at #4.

Myth #3: There is a Method For Innovation

In healthcare there is a method: it is, the method (and methodology of) research that provides evidence for practice and hopefully policy.

(There's brainstorming too of course - for which h2cm is the gift.)

Myth #4: People Love New Ideas

New starters and students in many lines of work are usually made aware of their potential and status (wanted or not) as 'change agents'. Student nurses should be torch-bearers of new ideas that are evidence-based. Whatever our age as lifelong learners we should always be open to new ideas, especially with the advantages that experience brings to the work and testbench of ideas. Constructive criticism should help - by definition - to construct.

So often though, there is marked resistance to ideas whatever 'age' they are. The ongoing mantras are "We've always done it this way!"; or "This is quicker! Tried and tested!" ...

For the past decade (at least) the UK economy has been plagued by a productivity crunch. This is also affecting health care. Myths 1-4 can also be considered under the heading of 'progress'. How much do we understand 'progress'? An examination must reveal productivity and innovation as fundamental elements.

Myth #5: The Lone Inventor

As I may have mentioned before when we were taught Hodges' model (1987-1988 Manchester Polytechnical College - MMU) as students and informed that we must apply h2cm in a marked case study/assignment there were some mutterings. Students often contribute to the development and testing of countless theories and models.

Brian did not publish much on the model beyond a book chapter. In this sense there is a lone inventor and a lone champion drawing an immense number of additional sources (here since 2006 for example).

Myth #6: Good Ideas Are Hard to Find

Ideas are not hard to find. For Hodges' model this is quite ironic. Ironic because, of course, the model provides a net to help 'capture' not just good ideas - but a brainstorm full of them.

There's something even more important though:

Hodges' model can help us find ideas not as 'good' or 'bad' in the first instance, but to test the ideas across contexts to see how an idea might perform. Only then is an idea 'good' and suitable for purpose (see #9).

Myth #7: Your Boss Knows More About Innovation Than You

The defences of ritualised practice and accepted (ideas) practice are well established ...
  • Not invented here!
  • Not created - owned by me!
  • Who is Hodges?
Social media constantly espouses on 'true' leadership and how power is exercised and distributed (if at all), but for many leaders power is a factor and the pedigree of the ideas and strategies that are deployed is a political football.

Myth #8: The Best Ideas Win

The videotape recording standards is a regular lesson here. The best ideas often do not win.

Sometimes building something is not enough ... or is it?

Whatever the 'truth' here - I still believe there is a great resource in this model.

Is h2cm a compound instrument?
Is h2cm an implicit holistic theory?
Is h2cm a series of conceptual spaces?
Is h2cm all of these ... ?

I also believe the challenge of individual and population health has a long-tail as a legacy problem.

Whether h2cm 'wins' or not - its relevance for the problems and solutions of the 21st and 22nd centuries grows each day ...

Myth #9: Problems and Solutions

Management and organisational gurus often extol the virtue of 360 degree vision. Hodges' model can encourage this as there are several dimensions and dichotomies 'embedded' within. Of particular note in myth 9 is objective versus subjective qualities - and what counts as good or bad (to follow).

A key in healthcare is that 'the' problem is not ours.

It is 'ours' - if factors impose upon clinical decision making are a distraction 
- such as economics.

Identifying what the problem is - requires that we validate and integrate several sources of information: the referrer, the person - patient/client with the problem and what can be observed and investigated.

In healthcare again there is a need for co-production and Hodges' model can play a role in this. Sometimes the 'solution' may not be what is expected when a patient's choices are taken into account.  Hodges' model can work to the patient's strengths and the situation. The model can be used explicitly or implicitly to help assure the working out of the problems and the solution. A by-product of this is that we are prompted in consequence to ask questions and act on an individual's health and other literacies. What becomes evident given the challenges of productivity, demographics, public engagement is a gap in our understanding were co-production is concerned.

Myth #10: Innovation is Always Good

Berkun highlights how some innovations are not always good. H2cm may be challenging in terms of fears of 'runaway' reflection or navel-gazing. Could h2cm lend itself to a mechanistic response to problems. Is that a robot I can hear?

Could h2cm be a gift to those who wish to deskill the health and social workforce?

From models of care and theories of nursing to checklist A, B, C & D?

Use of the model on paper is one thing, but what of e-based forms of application? How can we assure accessibility to the model? Can we make an e-reflective workbench a reality for our students?

As noted in #9 the need for research to innovate in co-production, collaborative, person-centred care within developed and developing health care systems remains marked.

Scott Berkun (2007) The Myths of Innovation, CA: O'Reilly.

Tuesday, April 07, 2026

This blog "Welcome to the QUAD" is 20 years old

Yesterday, this blog celebrated its 20th birthday. That first post seems an age away now -

Welcome to the Hodges Health Career - Care Domains Blog

https://hodges-model.blogspot.com/2006/04/

Back then, I was full-time and on a secondment with the NHS's National Programme for Information Technology:

Independent report: Making IT work: harnessing the power of health information technology to improve care in England. Published 7 September 2016

House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts - The National Programme for IT in the NHS: an update on the delivery of detailed care records systems - Forty-fifth Report of Session 2010–12

In that first post, several links take you to the former website which is now archived, as per the note in the sidebar. Similar links have been updated to the web.archive.org site, but some may have been missed. Other links may be plain broke.

The blog began as an acknowledgement of the former site's limitations, hence all the posts on Drupal the content management system.* The intention was to create a stop-gap. So much for that! I still have the 'new' site in my head.

Personally, there's been much change: as ever in life, a mix of sadness and great joy. Regards the former, a manager from 1985 into the 90s, colleague and friend David McKendrick died in 2009. And coinciding with personal bereavements, Brian Hodges in 2022. I do miss chats with both of them.

With periodic backups of the blog's content (and old website 1998-2015), there been one effort at a spring clean. Posts that are poor (what was I thinking?), or items that are clearly time-limited - event announcements have been deleted. Many more no doubt remain with images - banners - that will be removed at some point. With 3381 (inc.) posts published, it is quite an onerous, yet rewarding task.

During the two decades I would like to thank researchers who have discovered Hodges' model, recognised (either) its value, utility, relevance and cited the model in their studies/projects.

Thanks too to several co-authors whose patience and understanding in working with me, their recognition of the model and value in their work, and assistance to assure open access is invaluable to bring Hodges' model and this project to the attention of a global audience and community.

If I can help you with Hodges' model - acknowledgement not a requirement(!): please let me know.

The online presence has been about the model, not business, or commerce, so there's a lack of analytics. There's a project for someone, as I notice 'Blog Analysis' as an online research method. 

People occasionally email and provide encouragement regards the content.  In a way the blog is my thesis*. 

Amid the time-dependent content, there may be much here that can demonstrate:

  • the holistic bandwidth of Hodges' model
  • the scope of application of Hodges' model
    • the transdisciplinary potential of Hodges' model 
  • how to apply the model, or at least this practitioner's use
  • the visual appreciative dimension through the model's presentation to reveal the relational nature of the situation / context at hand
  • many remaining questions are also to be found.

Thank you for your visiting! Here's to another 20 years ;-) !?

*I still live in hope: it's called dreaming.

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

comment - Hodges model in Learning Disability

Denise M posted a comment [Wednesday, December 27, 2006] which I've repeated below with a reply:

"I an currently writing up my literature review for a MSc and is using a combination of Brian's HCM and Maslow's hierarchy of needs model as conceptual framework to structure the needs of people with profound learning disabilities and multi-sensory impairment (PLD and MSI). I am ever so grateful for the numerous resources on the HCM. Like yourself, I was first introduced to the model when I was doing the ENB 806 in 1986. I have used the model in my career as community LD nurse and nurse tutor and has found it useful in assessing people with LD and in teaching as a framework for discussing aspects of care. I normally reference the chapter in Hincliffe's book. I would be happy to discuss what I am doing and when I have completed the writing up, to evaluate the effectiveness of the HCM as a conceptual framework, in combination with another theory."

Denise M
--------
Hello Denise - Happy New Year!

Your comment is very timely at the start of a year that I hope will see increased interest in Hodges' model and other 'global' approaches. Learning Disability is a key care group, one in which Brian Hodges also trained, practised and taught. I am very interested in discussing your work. At a recent NW (England) RCN Older People Nursing Network meeting a speaker highlighted the unique problems and solutions for this client group, in terms of the possible development of dementia, parents getting much older and subsequent care.

To contact me you will find an e-mail address (see biog page for tel:no.) on the main website.

With the Serres-Hodges paper now submitted, I can think about the future of the website and explore the possibility of using a proper Content Management System. (Recommendations most welcome.) So if you or anyone else have any possible material on your work please get in touch. It pleases me no end to hear that the existing references / resources on the site are a help. If I'm honest though, while much of the current content does need to be accessible, some should be 'archived' to make way for contributions that are practice / research based.

Since starting this blog things do seem a bit more dynamic. It is practitioners, students and tutors like you Denise, and the efforts of others such as Claire, Rachael and Shannon who can shape the future of Hodges' model. For Hodges' model to really arrive I would very much like to add the public (patients and carers) and the global health community into the mix. Hodges' model is something that can by its nature engage and involve everyone. The Learning Disability community MUST be included, within day-to-day service provision of course this group can slip through the net.

Your next step about evaluation sounds quite challenging, but fascinating in terms of what methods you may employ and the results that might be revealed. I and many other people would I'm sure be very keen to learn more. If I can assist in some way - just let me know, happy to comment on your text if you wish...

Thanks for your interest and to the others who have picked up the flag. It makes the effort at this end really worthwhile...
Good luck and I look f/w to an e-mail or chat with you soon.
Peter