Hodges' Model: Welcome to the QUAD: Search results for safeguarding

Hodges' model is a conceptual framework to support reflection and critical thinking. Situated, the model can help integrate all disciplines (academic and professional). Amid news items, are posts that illustrate the scope and application of the model. A bibliography and A4 template are provided in the sidebar. Welcome to the QUAD ...

Showing posts sorted by date for query safeguarding. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query safeguarding. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Living and Loving Dangerously

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group

identity - choices
 
Memory - Cognition
DEMENTIA - Early onset

Inability to consent
 
inhibition-disinhibition 

mental capacity
 


My liberty, my choices

"What! I'm married to you? Oh!"

Treatment - medication 

'Secure (safe)' environment

'Holistic assessment'?
 


Marital/Initimate Relationships
Social (our) identity

Existing relational behaviours

Interrelational needs
Interpersonal grief

Social identity/expectations

Yes, but we're married ... had 40 years together ...

Family bias, prejudices..
A 'new' step-parent ...

Access to support: 
relational - mutual vulnerability


Informed consent
Assumed consent

Rape, Sexual abuse, crime

Capacity to give consent

Consistency in decisions

Lasting power of attorney -
finance; health

External safeguards

Human rights

Access to supervision -
clinical & management


Prompts:

Previously post: Living and Caring Dangerously

Danny Leigh. Critic's choice - Films on release: Queen at Sea. Life&Arts, FTWeekend, 19/20 September, 2026, p.18.

https://depijp.rialtofilm.nl/en/films/queen-at-sea

So many difficult conversations. All on their own unique continuum in terms of sense-making for all concerned. 

A 'new' diagnosis at age 60; versus one at 44. Families seeking to control disclosure of the diagnosis from the patient. Clinical and family debate about this.

Finding a person locked-in the house, while their partner 'nips' to the shops. A person having their freedom to go out, on their regular walk  -despite acknowledged risks. (When they are known by people on their route - community care in action. Receiving a call from a neighbour; or the neighbour who knows where you park and can intercept you, on arrival or departure to express concerns. Or, even as you venture out for a walk with their neighbour of many a year. Categorise them as you will: [nosey, caring, concerned, public spirited, neighbourly, or (healthily) curious]?

Other discussions of grief at the loss of a person they have loved - in every way. A grief that presents new dark dimensions to what has gone before. Complicated by a state of early onset of memory loss. An ongoing disintegration of personhood and identity. An inability to consistently express thoughts, wishes, and choices. An inability to give informed consent. A loss taunted by retained physical desirability. What does love, sex, compassion mean now? What is the sum now, of love expressed over 'x' years? Hearts hollowed out, of what can be so important to a couple. Not vital to all. But for others, a source of conjoined affirmation, joy, warmth, companionship, a celebration of life and being human.

How to share that grief even amid close friends and family, who cannot cope themselves and withdraw? What of the preparedness of professions to manage such situations? What structures are in-place for team meetings, clinical supervision and inclusion in training, especially safeguarding?

From the bibliography (lower sidebar):

Hodges, B.E. (1989) The Health Career Model, IN, Hinchcliffe, S.M. (et al.) 1989 Nursing Practice and Health Care, 1st Edition only, London, Edward Arnold.

Adams, T. (1987) Dementia is a family affair. Community Outlook, Feb, 7-8.

Merritt MK, Procter N. Conceptualising the functional role of mental health consultation-liaison nurse in multi-morbidity, using Peplau's nursing theory. Contemp Nurse. 2010 Feb-Mar;34(2):158-66. doi: 10.5172/conu.2010.34.2.158. PMID: 20509800.

Murphy, K., Welford C. (2012) Agenda for the future: enhancing autonomy for older people in residential care.International Journal of Older People Nursing. 7, 75–80.

Kernohan, W. G., & Jones, P. (2023). Hodges’ Health Care Model as a Framework for Quality. Paper presented at Interprofessional work: developing oral care and the health workforce for the future, Brescia, Italy.
https://pure.ulster.ac.uk/en/publications/hodges-health-care-model-as-a-framework-for-quality

Jones, P. (2025). A Conceptual Mapping Exercise of Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards in Residential & Community Care Using Hodges' Model and Threshold Concepts. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70085. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70085

Jones, P. (2025), A Generic Model and Conceptual Framework to Prime Curiosity Across Health and Social Care Disciplines to Facilitate Lifelong Learning. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70252. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70252

Previously: 'capacity' : 'consent' : 'law' : 'safeguarding'


Friday, September 25, 2026

Living and Caring Dangerously

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group

mental health
 
Cognition

Inability to consent 

mental capacity
 


My liberty

Locked doors

Treatment - medication 

'Secure (safe)' environment
 

Family - friends

dignity, privacy, respect

vulnerability

Best interest decision


Lasting power of attorney -
finance; health

External safeguards

human rights

 

Sir Ranulph Fiennes ‘kept unlawfully in care home’ [ The Times ]

The explorer, 82, is being ‘deprived of his liberty’, according to the watchdog, and his wife Louise Millington-Cotes is refusing visitors.

Hannah Crowe. Friday, September 25 2026, 12.41am, The Times

 See also:

Living Dangerously: An Interview with Sir Ranulph Fiennes [Brighton Dome]
Wed 10th Apr 2019

From the bibliography (lower sidebar):

Hodges, B.E. (1989) The Health Career Model, IN, Hinchcliffe, S.M. (et al.) 1989 Nursing Practice and Health Care, 1st Edition only, London, Edward Arnold.

Adams, T. (1987) Dementia is a family affair. Community Outlook, Feb, 7-8.

Merritt MK, Procter N. Conceptualising the functional role of mental health consultation-liaison nurse in multi-morbidity, using Peplau's nursing theory. Contemp Nurse. 2010 Feb-Mar;34(2):158-66. doi: 10.5172/conu.2010.34.2.158. PMID: 20509800.

Murphy, K., Welford C. (2012) Agenda for the future: enhancing autonomy for older people in residential care. International Journal of Older People Nursing. 7, 75–80.

Kernohan, W. G., & Jones, P. (2023). Hodges’ Health Care Model as a Framework for Quality. Paper presented at Interprofessional work: developing oral care and the health workforce for the future, Brescia, Italy.
https://pure.ulster.ac.uk/en/publications/hodges-health-care-model-as-a-framework-for-quality

Jones, P. (2025). A Conceptual Mapping Exercise of Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards in Residential & Community Care Using Hodges' Model and Threshold Concepts. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70085. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70085

Jones, P. (2025), A Generic Model and Conceptual Framework to Prime Curiosity Across Health and Social Care Disciplines to Facilitate Lifelong Learning. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70252. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70252

Previously: 'capacity' : 'law' : 'safeguarding' : 'health career'

I can't count the number of times in a nursing home, when a visit by a friend has re-ignited the flame of memory, passion and personhood; even if temporary. It was never my place to thank the friends for visiting, but they've made a difference, so crucial to acknowledge the courage on their part. Making the journey, being present and with. So difficult too, for families.

Friday, June 19, 2026

'Curiosity': child safety and safeguarding c/o BBC News

'Teacher who killed his adopted son given whole life prison sentence

14:30 18 June

That concludes our live coverage of the sentencing hearing.

To recap what happened at Preston Crown Court earlier: A teacher who sexually abused and murdered the 13-month-old baby boy he adopted with his partner has been told he will spend the rest of his life in prison.

Preston Davey died in July 2023 at the hands of Jamie Varley, 37, who subjected the child to physical, sexual and emotional abuse during the final four months of his life.

Varley, from Blackpool, told police Preston had accidentally drowned in a bath, but a post-mortem examination discovered the child had suffered 40 injuries.'

Continued ...

◇

individual
|
INTERPERSONAL
: SCIENCES             
humanistic ------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL   
|
group
 
curiosity
 
 





PROFESSIONAL
CURIOSITY



Source (Various): BBC Live News https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/c4gyrewq8xkt

 Previously: 'curiosity' : 'risk'

Saturday, October 18, 2025

Just imagine ... caseloads, payloads and careloads

Just imagine ... no, not like that - really imagine!

You are in a situation. Unsurprisingly, let's say it's in health, or social care. We find ourselves in a care or nursing home, on a ward, or in the individual's home, even if the patient does not currently recognise it as such.

The patient is mobile. That is, and isn't a problem.

Physically, apart from thoughts about a chest, or urine infection, yes they are mobile, but they're also confused - disoriented.

We are concerned about their safety. 

Noisy, increasingly agitated, they are making it clear they want to leave.

Their carer, family, or staff are trying to limit the patient / resident's access to the exits, be that the front, or back door, the spare room, their room, or main entrance. They are not in agreement about where they need to be. Persuasion and distraction aren't working either. They appear to lack the level of mental capacity required to decide for themselves what needs to happen.

It is one thing to have this assessment of the situation running through one's mind; but quite another to 'pick up' a care concept mentally and carry it over the care (knowledge) domains of Hodges' model.

Hodges' Health Career - Care Domains - Model
Try it for yourself ...

Have a think about the following care concepts: mobility, capacity, consent, confusion, mobility, liberty, a locked-door while spouse/partner goes shopping, and safeguarding? 

As we engage in critical thinking, these concepts have a literal payload. They carry varying degrees of informational value, salience that helps us prioritise, what else do we need to factor in, what help is needed, and when; how do we  decide what to do?

As a concept is evaluated against Hodges' model, it changes. It is as if it morphs subtely, or starkly as other concepts, by association, are brought into play.

This process is influenced in so many ways; our training to date, our prior experience, biases and cultural baggage we might also carry, who else is present (this is of course potentially both a positive and negative), past and current role-models, our (team's) preparedness - what to do if .., teamwork, access to leadership (who is 'duty'?), and our confidence in them (Oh no!). And, them in us.*

Vitally, there is the small matter of our understanding, attititude and response to the person in-front of us. 

The delivery of healthcare is often stressed as emotional labour. Whether we use Hodges' model or not, perhaps the labour, the physical and psychological work involved, is experienced through carrying and feeling the careload. A reason too for supervision.

*Do seek help - advice if needed.

Further reading [ please contact me if needed - h2cmng AT yahoo.co.uk ]:

Jones, P. (2025), A Generic Model and Conceptual Framework to Prime Curiosity Across Health and Social Care Disciplines to Facilitate Lifelong Learning. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70252. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70252

Jones, P. (2025). A Conceptual Mapping Exercise of Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards in Residential & Community Care Using Hodges' Model and Threshold Concepts. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 31: e70085. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70085

Saturday, May 31, 2025

Globally - seeking the ink of scholars

The Ink of the Scholars:
Reflections on Philosophy in Africa


Since the late 1980s, in trying to understand Hodges' model, especially its political dimensions beyond nurses as advocates, the mental health act, choice and self-determination. To be followed by consent, then informed consent, mental capacity, human rights, equality, protected characteristics, safeguarding, equity, social in-justice; I've then questioned my assumed neutrality of the model. 

Allied to this is the fact that Hodges' model is one of many models and frameworks, largely created in the developed world. What alternative viewpointsof nursing, care and philosophies are there? Do these challenge Hodges' model? Or, can Hodges' model also encompass them, in a complementary manner?

Serendipity, or ADHD, seems to follow me around. In addition determined to extract value from my purchase and reading of the weekend FT, I learned of potential key read:


Prempeh, C. THE AESTHETE. Koyo Kouoh, The curator of 2026 Venice Biennale talks whisky sours, working from bed and being the "high priestess of the okra church". HTSI, FTWeekend, 3 May 2025,pp.21-22.

'THE BEST BOOK I'VE READ IN THE PAST YEAR is a book on African philosophers, The Ink of the Scholars: Reflections on Philosophy in Africa, by Souleymane Bachir Diagne, one of our most brilliant thinkers. He challenges the idea that there isn't a philosophical framework to African societies. There are ideas around Africans being the great architects of hospitality and Diagne reflects on what the African approach to humanity is. What does it mean to be careful, mindful and caring? It's not just about welcoming people to your home or feeding them. Hospitality is carrying people, making people feel comfortable in your environment - it's intellectual and emotional. Everyone should read Diagne, full stop.' p.21. 
 

Shocked: I have just read of Koyo Kouoh's passing - RIP. 

Souleymane Bachir Diagne, & Jonathan Adjemian. (2016, May 23). The Ink of the Scholars: Reflections on Philosophy in Africa. CODESRIA Books Publication System. CODESRIA
https://publication.codesria.org/index.php/pub/catalog/book/40

See also: 'hospitality'

Wednesday, February 12, 2025

Book review #3: Handbook on the Ethics of AI

I've started several 'gap' lists, including a draft post or two. Seeking to help bridge the theory-practice gap is an original purpose for Hodges' model.

Friedman's chapter 5 Responding to the (techno) Responsibility Gap(s). It is almost as if Friedman's title is parameterised. We could insert the domains of Hodges' model (plus, spiritual - safeguarding!) in there. Then there is the magic of languages, for responsibility substitute accountability and do a deep-dive applying Hodges' model in a specific domain. Friedman notes it is not entirely accurate to talk of a single "responsibility gap". Can this provide evidence for the situated potentiality of Hodges' model's and role in fostering situational awareness? Although there is an ongoing roll-back of CSR - corporate social responsibility, I scribbled in the margin:

INDIVIDUAL
|
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
GROUP
user
user
user
corporate

Of course, 'user' still applies in the political domain, as we are all citizens; users of the State (note also the socio-technical utility of keeping the 'user' in sight). There is also personal ethics, and the legal duty of care - as a nurse (in my case) and for a member of the public. Discussion on notions of responsibility, in light of AI, especially self-driving vehicles, and autonomous machines (weapons) is much needed. Regulatory gaps are recognised; amid current news of debate on the degree of regulation of national and international financial systems. Nyholm's four-fold formulation on responsibility is invaluable as examples are provided. There is a reference to nine notions of responsibility, and the link to accountability and retribution.  I like Friedman's  discussion of responses to responsibility gaps as; optimists - technological approach; human-centred and hybrid approaches; plus pessimists (4.3). The latter includes debate and campaigns to 'stop the killer robots'. Did this chapter, have a positive effect in extending thoughts about events in the middle east? There are two points here I will return to in the final post.

For students, Schwarz's chapter 6 takes readers back to a literally pivotal development in ethical thought and debate: Trolleyology, with the addition of algorithms and killer robots. What Searle's Chinese Room (noted p.276 here) argument is to AI; so trolley-based dilemmas are to ethics. A point made by Schwarz, referring to the development of subsequent variations. (Following on from #2, Brian Magee's interviews with John Searle on philosophy of language and Wittgenstein are also well worth a listen.) Schwarz's chapter (and the whole book) could be read in preparation for an undergraduate course: computing, law, policy, philosophy, and ethics, for example. The challenge of determining responsibility and accountability "the problem of many hands" (p.71), is not limited to AI. This is a global issue in achieving justice for many previously healthy, competent, quite 'ordinary' people.

The question posed above, applies "equally"(!) here too: 3. mathematical morality for war. Ever since reading of argumentation through the Open University and other sources, I'm sure this is applicable to Hodges' model (with its 'own' algebra)? I'm no mathematician but the book provoked excitement rather than anxiety as I read: 'Principle of Permissible Harm (PPH) and probabilistic reasoning - with formulae (pp.88-89). There are some important (imho) 'take-away' messages here, but I don't want to spoil things. Nurses need mathematical skills, in drug calculations and are assessed on the same. Statistics are used in research, of course but maths is hardly the primary motivation for entry into the care professions: 
'Designing technologies in a way that takes into account broader human-centric values is an important and laudable approach to responding to new and emerging technologies in any arena. It cannot, however, serve as a substitute for moral deliberation and the act of taking moral responsibility for harmful acts, especially when lives are at stake. Reducing this to a mathematical problem ignores everything that cannot be captured in discrete numerical terms or as data points. And in situations where people and their lives become nothing more than data points, non-computational aspects, such as relational or embodied dimensions of human life, are marginalized if not entirely obscured. The real world is not reducible to binary logic, it is rife with contested, contradictory, and clashing values that might all be equally relevant It is complex in ways that cannot always be neatly captured or mathematically modeled. In other words, ethics cannot be "solved."' p.91.
More to follow ...

Handbook on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence. David J. Gunkel (ed.). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. ISBN: 978 1 80392 671 1245

https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/gbp/handbook-on-the-ethics-of-artificial-intelligence-9781803926711.html


Related previous posts: 'general + AI'

Saturday, July 06, 2024

Take II? Fit for Government . . ?

As a community nurse, driving is obviously pretty essential to your being able to work. I have come across non-driving community nurses (earlier this year) but they are still few(?). As a boy going to work with my father you could see how dependent he and workmates were upon a string of vans, cars and be able to drive both being on the 'right-side' of the law and his health. It was always an 'event' a new van, fitting out with racks, shelves, nooks, hooks and crannies for all sorts.*

Then as a community nurse older adults you come across individuals who still have their driving license, still have their car on the drive / front, and still have the car keys. Perhaps family have suggested to mum, dad, brother, sister, aunt: "Look, isn't it time to call it a day and give up driving?" Ouch! There's a crash - in itself.

Re-working the two-part draft paper on deprivation of liberty safeguarding, threshold concepts, Hodges' model within residential care, some thresholds are difficult, challenging to call. But some are safety critical, and perhaps need a more 'proactive' stance, without giving way to ageism. Is it the local community's job - the public's job to proffer a diagnosis: and what about persons on the world stage? Diagnosis by social media?

I quickly admired those people who, though reticent, gave up the literal fast-lane. Inevitably you wonder how you will react when the time comes. Will you have the humility, the goodness of grace to hand over the keys? To call it a day. With an ageing population, I've warned the children when driving to expect the unexpected. Cars going the wrong way. It was a struggle for my father: but safety as it so often does - did the trick - with the impetus of physical illness.

Sometimes, at work, after a family trying, and a fracas, when they've tried to hide / remove the car keys, suddenly a near-miss has upped-the-ratchet. Neighbours have seen the 'driver' reversing out into the road, with numerous car horns announcing the event. Then perhaps you are intercepted outside, a call comes to the day center (the transport is also going), the community team, or the GP's surgery (the neighbours have helped with medication).

I've had to speak to GPs for them to visit, meeting them on occasion. Do GPs - family physicians still have the same gravitas today?

This is a care transition: what can be a difficult one. A helpful point (diplomatic argument) that often gets through is the matter of car insurance and the status of the existing policy?

Does a political leader carry insurance?

It is difficult for all, a person's human rights, choices, freedom; their life story, former career perhaps, their health career - most definitely.

With events in the USA and the Democrat Party, and seeing the cover of The Economist I had to TAKE II.

Individual
|
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES                   
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :    POLITICAL 
|
Group

cognitive state

memory

insight

Fitness for Office:
Mentally & Physically
Legally
The Economist


safety of Others

community - duty of care -
safeguarding
 (however realised)

This is global problem that is set to increase and not just for reasons of health.

Ack. The Economist

Owen, D. (2009) In Sickness and in Power: Illnesses in Heads of Government during the Last 100 Years, London: Methuen Ltd. ISBN: 978-0-413-77689-1

Listen also ... BBC Radio 4 Moral Maze 

'The Morality of Stepping Down'

Previously:

*I suspect he's still driving around somewhere. x

Wednesday, February 28, 2024

HIFA Discussion: Alcohol Use Disorders - Do people understand the harms of alcohol?

Dear All (with further editing since posting)

The discussion, points, angles, questions ... are coming thick and fast it is difficult to keep up.

Many thanks for the summaries; and of course the discussion which archived also acts as a resource - repository:

https://www.hifa.org/news/hifa-announces-deep-dive-discussion-alcohol-use-disorders-starts-5-february-2024

I wonder whether the question: 
"Do people understand the harms of alcohol?" must always be placed in context?
It is radically different when asked of the tee-total, dry, safe drinker; and someone (still) actually in their alcohol drinking?

It occurs to me that alcohol, even more so than 'other' substance misuse (heroin...) represents what must be *the* contradiction, paradox in healthcare - except the tragic loss that is suicide.

Contrast substance misuse inc. alcohol, with 'help-seeking' and 'The Sick role'

https://www.england.nhs.uk/blog/ed-mitchell-2/

Plus, the (medical) sociology of the decision to consult/refer, and how in mental health (UK), the mental capacity act is apparently being misapplied ('policy-drift'?**):

https://www.lawsociety.org.uk/topics/blogs/are-mental-health-and-capacity-laws-at-risk-of-being-toxic

https://www.communitycare.co.uk/2017/08/23/flawed-use-mental-capacity-act-key-theme-safeguarding-adults-reviews-report-finds/

Individual

   |
      INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC  --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
 SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
Group

continental drift

policy drift?


Previously, I highlighted how as a Community Psychiatric Nurse 1985-1995 (adult) .. if a patient/client was not working to control/reduce their alcohol consumption they may be 'counselled' re a pending discharge and referral back to their GP - family physician. In supervision with the team's manager they would want to know what is 'happening'. It being important not to create (social) dependency, or worse support someone in their alcohol misuse.

There was a sense, still is(?) that in substance misuse (across forms) - the individual has to reach 'rock-bottom', literally the 'gutter' that is the point they decide (really?)** to live, or carry on to suffer irreversible brain damage, or premature death. Regards the 'brain damage' it was a struggle for 45-60 minutes given the impact upon short-term memory, what time, .... is it indeed? When the patient was not living alone, how did the relative, family cope?

Is having to reach the gutter, the bottom, a trope/myth? In psychosis rather than assume the patient is beyond being reached prior to being medicated there are psycho-social interventions that can be commenced: being available / with. Here though this is usually 'first episode'. There is no analogue here, unless first admission to an in-patient unit is taken as a golden opportunity? But this also depends on its nature (funding, staffing - expertise), a general adult mental health ward, or specialist unit.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0048347/

What is the current strategy?

In terms of 'HIFA' - and the person that counts**, not only do they not have the 'information'; they do not have the EXISTENTIAL INFORMATION as it relates to them: 'Health Information for YOU'!

Again in Hodges' model we can contrast the dichotomy/polarisation of INDIVIDUAL :: GROUP.

The model's being situated; and able to encompass data, information, knowledge (facts, for example, and their delivery) - wisdom (Multi-contextual / transdisciplinary..).

I admire people who work in these services (learning disability and palliative care); as they must be severely tested as they retain an ability - the humanity - to 'see' the person whatever the patient's situation with their lack of awareness (capacity..?) and its critical salience.

Peter Jones
Community Mental Health Nurse and Researcher
Blogging at "Welcome to the QUAD"
http://hodges-model.blogspot.com/
http://twitter.com/h2cm
h2cmng at yahoo.co.uk

Location: It was just a cappuccino.

**Which points to the relevance of the POLITICAL care/knowledge domain in Hodges' model.

Friday, September 01, 2023

Brian E. Hodges (1942-2022) RIP Creator of Hodges' Health Career Model

The end of 2022 and start of 2023 brought loss, reflection and change in terms of family, friends and educational ties. My children said goodbye to their grandmothers in the space of two months. 

Brian E. Hodges c/o Family.
Then I was contacted by Brian Hodges’s daughter Sarah, with the news her father had died. November through to January saw me attend three consecutive funerals. I’m grateful I was able to visit Sheffield and say goodbye to Brian and meet his extended family.

Yes, it has taken a while to post this. For six months I have been sorting, clearing, rationalising books, papers with a house-sale now imminent, liaising with Brian's family too. 

It is fitting to share this sad news now and celebrate lives well-lived, cast in the promise of a new academic year. I think Brian would have liked this - the potential, and prospects for students in the semesters to follow, lecturers wrestling with how best to communicate and engage their students.

I first met Brian in 1987 when he was a Senior Lecturer at Manchester Polytechnic - which is now Manchester Metropolitan University. Brian taught on the ENB 911 Care of the Mentally Ill in the Community Certificate course. On the course Brian explained his eponymous model. This was more than a decade before Project 2000 made nursing an undergraduate programme. Brian created the model as a response to this. Brian’s qualification in Learning Disability Nursing is key to the inclusion of individual, group (carers) and the POLITICAL domain.

The model contributed to our assessment on the course, which required we complete a case study applying the model to a client/patient on a placement which was conducted with another service. Seconded from Chorley my placement experience was at Bolton. I still have my case study and a set of Brian’s original lecture notes.

Straight away I knew there was something special about Brian’s model. I suspect I’d been primed after watching Tony Buzan’s TV programmes in the 1970s, ‘Use Your Head’ and related books on mind-mapping. By the time I joined the Internet-age it was 1997. I’d written some microcomputer programs on the ZX81 and BBC Micro ‘B’: Nursing Process, Computer Aided Patient Assessment; HAEM; and Shades of Grey. Several were published by Open Software Library (no longer operating).

An ongoing interest developed in nursing theory and models of care, from reading about the nursing process. An early thought about creating a computer program about Hodges’ model crystallised in March 1997 when I came across the Nursing Development Site. This was hosted by the University of Alberta, Canada. Seeing that Hodges’ model was not listed, I contacted the site’s administrator. The response was: “Why don’t you create something and let us know.” Brian was very patient and offered his thoughts via email exchanges (saved, but in Turnpike format). In 1998 I finally got in touch with Alberta and they added a link.

The notes below are from the resulting website (1998-2015 now archived). The product of an interview with Brian at Manchester Polytechnic and my interpretation of model:
“Brian thought up HCM on the then British Rail train service, commuting between Sheffield and Manchester in 1983. He was stimulated by the need to impose structure on a curriculum for a BSc Nursing Studies course. Having defined the model in 1983 a scheduled teacher was unable to take a class, providing an opportunity for Brian to share the model and his thoughts with students. Despite this impromptu start, within a short time academic colleagues recognized the value of HCM in curriculum design and development, in addition to clinical practice.
 
A problem for practitioners has always been ensuring a comprehensive assessment has been made. The HCM facilitates that process, as an aide-mémoire, especially critical when faced with child care / abuse assessment and care evaluations. HCM was adopted as a tool for use by students on courses. Not surprisingly a key area of application is Health Visiting. Other nursing fields includes the use of case studies in post-basic education - Community Psychiatry Nursing Certificate; community and mental handicap - now learning disabilities.
 
Key phases in development
 
The main development work following initial conception, was up to 1987. Due to illness in 1990 Brian has been unable to engage in in-depth development work with the HCM. Hence Brian's bemused surprise at my contacting him. Despite this there are many educators, clinicians and no doubt health care managers who having been exposed to HCM carry it, like myself, as part of their mental toolkit. So if you have taught or used HCM in the past, or (even better) use it currently Brian and I would be delighted to hear from you. Given the duration of courses at Manchester then of course many colleagues in other parts of the north west of England have heard of HCM, used the HCM, or possess a college set of notes on HCM. Do you?” . . .

<> 

Sarah and family have kindly forwarded the eulogy which includes:
“Dad was born on 30th January 1942 to Vera and Gilbert Hodges, he was the eldest of three with a sister, Rita and younger brother Philip. He grew up in Kingswood, a suburb of Bristol and attended the local Grammar school. He loved being a Scout and was a member of the YMCA.

When he left school, he went to work for Boots the Chemist, telling us often about his’ behind the counter’ days. However, a conversation with a colleague led him to rethink his career and he applied to train as a nurse at a hospital for patients with learning difficulties. Being a male nurse in the 1960’s was quite ground-breaking, and so typical of Dad who was always pushing boundaries and taking the ‘road less travelled’.

Dad realised that he enjoyed teaching the students and became determined to raise the profile of nursing those with learning difficulties. This led to him to taking a year’s teacher training at Bolton College and with his new qualification he was determined to make an impact on nursing. In 1972 this lead to the move to Sheffield to set up a nurse training course at Sheffield Polytechnic and Middlewood hospital. He loved this job and the impact he could have on training nurses, alongside this he embarked on an Open University Degree and also developed the Hodges Health career model for nursing, which facilitated integrated care, person centredness, reflective practice and helped to bridge the theory and practice gap. He was very proud of this work, and it remains in use.
 
Alongside his work interests Dad decided that he would learn to sail, and not only how to sail, but also how to build a boat. The boat started life in the hallway of the house in Meadow Grove Road, and whilst it amused me and Sarah, there must have been a moment where Mum asked him to move it somewhere more suitable. He successfully built the boat and taught us all how to sail.
Back to his work life he was offered a job as a lecturer at Manchester University and later became Head of Nursing Studies there. He loved his job and invested a lot of time in encouraging his students with his indomitable wit and zest for life. Always wanting to learn more, he also studied for an MSc in Health Education, which meant he travelled to London and loved to tell us about his walks around Chelsea.

Life changed dramatically in 1990 when aged only 48 Dad had a severe stroke which led to a left side paralysis; and a medical assessment that he would not walk again. His sheer determination meant that he did in fact walk, although never regained use of his left arm, which made a lot of day to day tasks very difficult. He had no hesitation about asking strangers to help on his trips to London in his electric wheelchair.

Although Dad returned to work a year after the stroke, he found he could no longer do the job the way he wanted to and took early retirement. Being Dad, he did not stop working and continued to do some teaching, and travelled to other education centres as an external examiner. He also took up a number of volunteering activities which could make use of his skills. He became really involved in health care improvement through service user input and ultimately Chair of Shop Mobility in Sheffield.

One volunteering opportunity led to many and he took up a number of positions in both Sheffield and London. He loved to travel to London on his own on the train, where after his meetings, he would meet Sarah for dinner. He always said ‘focus on what you can do’ so that is what he did. After the stroke he learned to swim again and joined his grandchildren in the pool at Centre-parcs, and played badminton on one of his much loved family holidays.

He did not let the stroke stop him travelling at all and visited France, Florida, Barbados and even St Petersburg in his wheelchair. He also loved trips to Chatsworth for ice cream.

He loved listening to jazz music and rock, had learned to paint and draw. He loved the theatre and bird watching and was an avid reader. In fact, he was interested in everything, knew so much on any topic you could choose, and always more up to date than those around him, often much younger, on all the latest thinking or technology.

His philosophy of life meant that even after the catastrophic event of the stroke, it did not mean an end to living and he found other opportunities which he grasped enthusiastically.

So many people were amazed and inspired by Dad for what he achieved. He was one of life’s cheerleaders always encouraging and supporting others to fulfil their ambitions and this is what we will take with us. When we are not sure in our lives going forward we know we will think ‘What would Brian / Dad / Grandad say’. He had many sayings which we will remember and whenever anyone was facing difficulties or challenges, he would say ‘You will be alright’, and we will be alright because he has have taught us to be so.

Above all he will be remembered for his sense of humour, his huge sense of purpose and service to others and for the determination to live life to the full and never be stopped by anything or anyone. He was so proud of his family and all they have achieved. He was an inspiration and encouragement to everyone he met.

This is the final page of Dad’s life, but it is not the end. Everyone who’s life Dad touched, and all the people present here today carries a little bit of him with them, his humour, his smile, his sayings, his tenacity. So, he will live on with all of us, it is a fond farewell and not a goodbye.”
<> 

Train ticket 28/05/97 (also from 1st website)
Since the Community Psychiatric Nursing (Cert.) course in the 1980s and our initial interview 28th May 1997, Brian and I met on about ten occasions. As noted above, Brian enjoyed rail travel and in the interview I had this image of a train with thought bubbles - Brian's reflections with the model taking shape.

Image from 1st archived site
Brian’s passing and his family's observations prompted recollection of a trip to London in 1996; to an IEE Colloquium on Thinking with Diagrams (Digest No: 1996/010).

https://digital-library.theiet.org/doi/book/10.1049/conferences-1996_010

I’m sure Brian met me there, demonstrating his independence, motivation and enthusiasm. I need to check but I’m fairly sure, even imagining he said he was meeting Sarah afterwards? My father accompanied me, we stayed with an aunt who lived near London Bridge back then. Happy memories for me too.

Brian knew of several sites across the UK, that used or took an interest in Hodges’ model. When the website went live in 1998, I’d hoped people with notes, insights, examples of application, pros and cons would come forward. Sadly this did not happen except for a few instances.

I’m so pleased to have met Brian and being able to carry his model forward. Even semi-retired, I rejoice in the freedom I have as a practitioner. As I believe Brian came up against many academic barriers in trying to validate, publicise and disseminate the model. There was no expressed cynicism in this however, but political realism about how the world – academia works. A lesson I know very well in trying to publish work.

I keep fretting about not completing the ‘new’ website, but perhaps I’m following Brian’s advice after all: “focus on what you can do”. Despite its limitations the blog is helping to spread awareness of Hodges’ model; learning each year of new publications citing the model. Hodges’ model isn’t just another 2x2 matrix—business/management consultancy style thinking tool.

The key is the model’s full title:

Hodges' Health Career - Care Domains - Model

‘Health career’ refers to ‘life chances’ and this was central to Brian’s values of person-centredness, advocacy, and ‘seeing’ the political in health, social care and his own educational development and health career. 

The work remains to take Hodges’ model forward, to pass on this ‘+’ shaped baton. I will reflect further, especially as I was initially determined to ensure that Hodges' model was not just left on the shelf. For me, Brian’s legacy is the increasing relevance of his eponymous model since its creation. Consider since the late 1980s developments in human rights, consent, mental capacity, safeguarding, protection of liberty, mental health act, prison health. Brian's model readily encompasses the person and the State - nationally and globally, access and provision to health services, primary care, sustainable development goals, the determinants of health. How do we switch from illness-directed to preventive, health educational services?

In addition, Hodges' model can conceptually represent all these - across time as a series of frames. Brian's model remains a gift to his students and today's learners; including, patients, carers, mental health and general nurses, district nurses, learning disability and health visitors. As suggested here - Brian's effort and work has proved a great gift to me (as friends, family and many student nurses on placement, mentored, signed-off will attest). Brian's model is not a be all and end all, he knew this. It is one of many tools, models and theories, but it can and must also help future generations: from self care, health care, to global health and planetary care.

Thank you Brian. RIP.

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Key Safeguarding Legislation [UK]

I have been catching up on mandatory e-learning for work, which included safeguarding. This included a review of forms of abuse:

Physical abuse
Domestic violence or abuse
Sexual abuse
Psychological or emotional abuse
Financial or material abuse
Modern slavery
Discriminatory abuse
Organisational or institutional abuse
Neglect or acts of omission
Self-neglect  [SCIE]

In addition to the list of legislation below, readers may wish to relate these forms of abuse to the care (knowledge) domains of Hodges' model. 

Remember the model is an idealisation, but it is a very useful starting point for reflection, critical thinking, problem solving, analysis and synthesis.   [ Re. (self) - see below. ]


INDIVIDUAL

|
 INTERPERSONAL    :     SCIENCES               
HUMANISTIC --------------------------------------  MECHANISTIC      
SOCIOLOGY  :   POLITICAL 
|
GROUP

(self)

(self)


"Care Act 2014

Mental Capacity Act 2005 / Court of Protection

Human Rights Act 1998

Domestic violence crimes and victims act 2004  (amended in 2012)

Mental Health Act 1983

Safeguarding vulnerable groups act 2004 amended by Protection of Freedoms Act in 2012

Sexual Offences Act 2012"
(list not exhaustive)


As a means to help understand a situation, the model is applicable in risk and public safety more generally. In assessing risk students often recognise 'risk to self' and 'risk to others', but self-neglect can be a key part of the picture.

 
My source/prompt: E-learning


https://twitter.com/imathematicians/status/1530724466073952261?s=20&t=eF1XRD9HbkSJ2XWWbIk2qQ

Wednesday, March 02, 2022

Draft figure: Selected processes and sources that can contribute/influence the content of Hodges' model

This draft figure is intended to ultimately show how the final application of Hodges' model, that is, the selection and placement of concepts in the care (knowledge) domains is not determined by a specific rule, 'law', or theory. The user of the model as a reflective, problem solving agent must justify their 'completed' matrix - addressing the four care domains. This could be a combined effort, with a colleague, fellow student, patient, or carer. 

Being situated the figure should highlight how the final result, output is not only dynamic, changing over time, but it is dependent upon context. Contrast using the model in a seminar, with a nurse and student reflecting on a forthcoming or post a best interests or safeguarding meeting.

The most important point here, across all healthcare, education and other use-cases, is that when applied the user of the model begins with a blank 'sheet' ... template 

Any thoughts welcome. [image updated 18 March 2022].

Draft figure: Selected processes and sources that can contribute/influence the content of Hodges' model

Friday, July 30, 2021

Review: iv Fundamentals of Person-Centred Healthcare Practice

Chapter 15 on 'Being sympathetically present' is a timely review of empathy, sympathy and compassion. As students learn and are exposed to experiences in practice and socialised (or not) in how these are practised this is very useful allied with exposure to the 6Cs. Mentioned in post iii: chapter 19 on Person-Centred Rehabilitation would benefit from the addition of reablement and resettlement. Given resort to a single chapter [22] on mental health it is understandable that the extreme form of trauma - physical and psychological experienced (but not necessarily wholly remembered) for people sexually assaulted points to forensic and Criminal Justice Liaison and Diversion Services. The authors here are to be congratulated on a feat of explanatory gymnastics. This just hints at the PSYCHO-dynamic* world that is mental illness, health and well-being (*physical and political).

Perusal of W2tQ reveals how readily Hodges' model can encompass the sciences and the arts (humanities). This is by design (the model's structure). The book stresses art with some (very well-balanced and executed) illustrations and prose. Once again (sorry) though, I thought of veterans, homeless, veterans, prisoners and newly released offenders and their circumstances. Being person-centred is very much attitudinal but this is physical not just cognitive and how we apply knowledge. Where this person is in space that is the centre of gravity. How best to approach, a person living with dementia and impaired senses, a homeless person lying under a bridge - even before we speak. 

 

I'm sure I read 'touch' in here, but it is not indexed. Post-COVID and in nursing as part of person-centredness this is an important part of communications skills, safeguarding and being safe. 

For the newly released prisoner, how prepared are they to be the person they can be, even before we are 'person-centred'?

"For the first time in 25 years the one-off payment given to adult prison leavers in England and Wales is to be raised. The Prison Discharge Grant will increase from £46 to £76, but what difference will that make?"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000y5sq

 

The book identifies different interventions and models relevant to the respective practice area, i.e. rehabilitation. Chapter 33 presents a personal challenge in (being a lifelong learner) whether you have a fixed or growth mindset, which of four archetypes of self-awareness applies to you (pp.322-323)? It's worth reading for heutagogy (p.327). I was prompted to consider the ongoing journey here. If anyone would like to test the reflexive credentials of Hodges' model (p.328) please get in touch. Salience is a key concept in Hodges' model. What is important to the patient - person? What is now? Are we only person-centred dealing with conscious persons? Again, perhaps a missed opportunity - care of the unconscious patient? I enjoyed chapter 30 on critical thinking. I was reminded of (verbal) accounts of people applying the Tidal model in forensic care. This proved not exactly straight forward, whereas, once learned Hodges' model can function as an aide-mémoire. If shared then collaboration may be enhanced since as the latter sections of this book show specific concepts need to be identified, articulated, agreed and applied.

The final chapter's title made me laugh a little: A call to action. Sometimes you can't win on the periphery of academia (a privileged position nonetheless?). KISS (Keep it simple stupid) applies to Hodges' model, but whether simple, or deemed complex the model fails to be recognised as a vital tool for all health and social care practitioners. Especially learners taking their seats (in-situ or online) on course 101. I take heart in believing that Hodges' model has a very long tail in relevance and global potential.

Once again model/framework envy creeps in, as I have no evidence (yet). 

Paradoxically (or not) this book will have me try to take note of instances when an interaction calls for a suspension of person-centredness: for me, the patient, client, carer - for us simultaneously.

This is the 'take-away' for me from this book which I also heartily recommend.

I will refer to 'healthful' in another book review.

SPIRITUAL
 
individual - PERSON - patient
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
SPIRITUAL  humanistic ---------------------------- mechanistic  SPIRITUAL
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
family - group - population
 
SPIRITUAL
Mindset :: Parity -
attitude aptitude
(My choices*)


Hodges' model - disassembly for care
- of esteem :: Touch
aptitude attitude



Hodges' model assembly of care
Culture
Child - Parent - Guardian
FAMILY- Social network

Be the 'person' the
Social Determinants of Health
predict/dictate?


prisoner release


grants and welfare

*(Are you joking - without attending to the politics of health and social care? Diet, green spaces, identity, community (facilities), housing ...)

Many thanks to the publisher Wiley-Blackwell for the review copy.

Review i

Review ii 

Review iii

Fundamentals of Person-Centred Healthcare Practice,  McCormack, B., McCance, T., Bulley, C., Brown, D., McMillan, A, Martin,S. (Eds.). ISBN: 978-1-119-53308-5 February 2021 Wiley-Blackwell.


Saturday, July 03, 2021

Two papers and a Conference

However much I try to multitask the result is illusory. Writing projects are many and the status of most is stalled*. Even those 'active' such as the SDG paper that combines Hodges' model, public health, specifically nutrition is on a sister journal and still awaiting word from the reviewers and editorial team. Where the paper remains active for me is that since last summer I've had the assistance of a co-author. This really does make a difference.

 Another paper I've posted about is the two-part draft [4400 Words / 46 Refs :: 4700 Words / 37 Refs] on:

  • Threshold Concepts
  • Hodges' model 
  • Liberty Protection Safeguarding (Deprivation of Liberty Safeguarding - DoLS)
  • Residential Care and Nursing Homes

Before the renewed focus on the SDG effort, the TC paper benefited from feedback (which will be acknowledged). Putting it down (yet again), it seemed a much more complete draft. Now, as the themes suggest, post-Covid, another revision-pass is merited. In compensation, as I find with Hodges' model and  each new year, the two-part paper's focus is even more relevant.

Next week I will once again share Hodges' model with a community of practice. Postponed from July 2020:

TC2020: 8TH BIENNIAL THRESHOLD CONCEPTS CONFERENCE, 2021

I wish I had data to back up and support the paper. I have routinely used Hodges' model implicitly in this care context as a community mental health nurse. Once again the work is descriptive. Before COVID struck, I was planning to address this and will as soon as possible. Now, I've sixteen slides to complete.

*Don't mention the website!


Wednesday, November 04, 2020

Lockdown ii :: Writing, Reading, Drupal...

As we start Lockdown 2 in the UK - England, plus the long nights to follow it's an opportunity to weigh up plans, projects and progress here.

I've nearly finished my review and posts on "The Power of the 2x2 Matrix":

Q. What is Hodges' model? A. It is NOT a 2x2 matrix

Next up - to read and review-  are two books:

Leave No One Behind: Time for Specifics on the Sustainable Development Goals, Homi Kharas, John W. McArthur and Izumi Ohno, Brookings Institution Press.
Leave No One Behind

Last weekend on behalf of my co-author I (re-)submitted a paper on public health, Hodges' model and the sustainable development goals SDGs.

It does pain me that the publisher kindly sent a review copy in the spring, but sadly it's not in the reference list. That subtitle is tantalizing. I will get to this after picking up "After Ethnos":
 

After Ethnos

To be clear, I'm a nurse not* an ethnographer or anthropologist, but this research approach featured large in studies at Lancaster University 2014-2016. 
 
 
A further rationale for reading this book is to maintain insight into research methods and methodologies.
 
Returning to the writing front, just before I found a co-author for the SDG draft, I'd worked on the two-part Threshold Concepts draft dealing with Deprivation of Liberty (now, Liberty Protection Safeguarding) c/o feedback from Mark Bird.
 
This is next up, especially hoping that the Threshold Concepts can proceed next July at UCL, London.
 
The other paper is a 'legacy' item which started in 2013 (yes, I know!). Mentioned here on W2tQ no doubt on diagrams, case formulations and h2cm. There is a paper here, he says? It is quite advanced in terms of words and references.
 
In addition to the legacy issues:
  • person-centred care;
  • integrated care;
  • holistic care;

the standout personal legacy - is this blog and the lack of a website. Soon I'll put twitter down and blog less to try (again) to focus on Drupal and related tools.
 
*I would like to think that successful nursing interventions (that really 'make a difference') calls for an  ethnographic and anthropological orientation.

Monday, October 21, 2019

An update papers, Hodges' model, website...

Here is an update on writing projects ...

WEBSITE - DRUPAL:

A few months ago I decided to cancel the web hosting. The same provider and for the second time. Lack of progress is nothing to do with them. Despite best intentions, the account was essentially redundant, apart from one occasion when I was ready to start transfer of a site including Brian Hodges' lecture notes, as part of what would be an archive. I still have the pages - HTML all ready to 'go' - somewhere... The host company were very good, offering to take me through the process. I will git back on the horse. The journey is still very enjoyable, even if frustrating.

Last weekend at the Northwest (England) Drupal User Group - NWDUG Unconference in Manchester, I gave an eleven slide presentation on the ultimate in vapour ware. Even with no site the day was very useful, the community great. At month end I will be following online DrupalCon Amsterdam. Really disappointed not to be there, but the currency situation nails it, on top of my not having earned the trip.

As posted last Tuesday -

Book: "The Empty Space"

- I've been crossing the Pennines and enjoyed visits to see Mr Hodges at his home. It would be marvellous to get to a point were I can 'demonstrate' some progress on the web front. The Drupal community continue to try to improve the migration and update processes. This can certainly help me. A Drupal developer questioned me a while ago if I'm being too loyal. Is Drupal the right tool? I am considering this ...

PAPERS:

As to papers I'm determined to try to clear the desks of draft papers. I'm not duty-bound to write, just learning-bound. In May a journal editor invited me to write about Hodges' model. The brief was more specific, write about the model but not in general terms. I was directed to relate the model to at least two public health themes.*

Trying to put a map on the map is challenging.
Everyone wants data, evidence, findings, method ...

Last month I arrived at a final draft and am now advised to answer my own queries and then submit. So sounds positive thus far. I really will diligently check the submission requirements.

The other paper is a bit of a saga, having started before the Part 1 - MRES studies at Lancaster in 2014. The paper overall concerns Hodges' model, threshold concepts and deprivation of liberty safeguarding. It is now in two-parts, feedback on part one has been favourable but still seeking people with time to read and critique- so hopefully on-track with this too.

*Public mental health is always also implied as far as I am concerned.

Monday, July 08, 2019

Inaugural Scottish Threshold Concepts Conference: TCs in Action [ii]

After Prof. Land's keynote and the previous post on 'work-as-X' I can see the value of the academically agnostic - neutrality of Hodges' model in terms of the spaces it affords. It can be used to reflect as a safe space or problematic, troublesome or unsafe. As an example, consider the task of reflecting upon the current state of residential and nursing home care?

individual - self
|
INTERPERSONAL : SCIENCES
humanistic ----------------------------------------------- mechanistic
SOCIOLOGY : POLITICAL
|
group- population











Next reflect upon residents and sexuality within these care environments. This could be from any perspective, or even work through several: resident, a new care worker, other team members, staff nurse, home manager, family member, GP, or inspector. ...













#UoDthresholdconcepts2019
Prof. Land raised the matter of extreme vulnerability and experience of Syrian refugees. Individual and Population are forced through a threshold that is catastrophic: that of identity. The scale of this event is being stressed as an urgent issue that must be accorded attention in parallel with physical relief

Perhaps, it is not just individuals who must encounter and pass through a threshold in their learning, their liminal journey. The problems we face demands that disciplines must find the disciplinary bridges that will enable them to solve the interdisciplinary and even transdisciplinary problems we face.

Geopsychiatry is a key bridge here. Research has determined that trauma can be intergenerationally transmitted. Governments, aid organisations and policy makers must take this into account and not just respond with physical relief. Unfortunately, the imbalance that is a lack of parity of esteem in general physical and mental health has its global-scale analogue in humanitarian crises and conflicts, especially those that displace populations.

Prof. Land referred to eduChaos and this is where 'lived experience' is found: not just in 'real time'.

#UoDthresholdconcepts2019

Uncertainty, kept repeating itself Prof. Land describing the work of Ilgen et al. (2018) and the need in (and through) education to find comfort with uncertainty. The challenge of this is acute in medicine and mental health care as Ilgen's work highlights. The previous post's nod to box-ticking and elsewhere the quest that is the 'comprehensive record' stresses at point of initial encounter - the initial assessment, perhaps to the detriment of an outcome oriented approach?

The question posed of "how professionals can manage the uncertainty arising from complex, ill-defined problems with conflicting assumptions, evidence and opinion" [another slide] is not just concept-bound as I tend propose. The terrain of Hodges' model can be used to map wells of uncertainty that help make the more certain, concrete data - information stand out. It helped me to see the situatedness of this discourse repeated. The definitions of 'uncertainty' and 'certainty' attributed to Ilgen et al. (2018) are a helpful adjunct to information science based sources.

In subsequent parallel sessions I switched rooms in  trying follow what was most relevant. First was,
'Where have all the empathetic professionals gone? An exploration of empathy as a threshold concept for the helping professions'. This provided a multidisciplinary insight into social work education, with overlaps that included safeguarding and child protection. Jayne Lewis's format had us engaged, well me clearly as I've no notes or photos. The talk of empathy made me recall twitter and student nurses remarks on their placements (accepting too that 'No news is good news') and student-mentor-placement relationships. If the practice/placement environment is stressed/contested for a variety of reasons, to what extent does this influence empathy role models, student experience and study of TCs? Do researchers need to record the emotional and political 'temperature' as a baseline measure?


#UoDthresholdconcepts2019


Next, on the programme; TCs, medical students and population health learning. From an acute angle (I was late arriving) Hothersall explained a study with a small sample, and yet findings that (as ever) call for more study, with implications for teaching in the lecture theatre, as a whole, in practice and relevance for me.

I'm sure there are many threshold concepts in public health and public mental health (to ensure inclusion). Even if specialty posts in public health are filled 2013-2016 (and amid recruitment pressures) I wonder if there is an issue for students (generally) in the perception of  'public health' and their respective discipline? Is there something in the old debate of pure - applied disciplines? Do medical and other students feel they must focus attention on the 'hard' learning rather than the 'soft' fuzzy concepts that public health encompasses? What has been the impact of the most recent series of re-organisations?



 #UoDthresholdconcepts2019

Of course, given the big themes identified, for me, the first lecture 101 should include a conceptual framework that can readily incorporate the (socio-)technical, (psycho- socio-) political, conceptual and much more.


The presenter also informed us that a paper is in press: 'The Clinical Teacher'. These findings of concepts that were troublesome for students appears to support my '101' role for Hodges' model - but then I would say that ...


Tierney's Exploring threshold concepts in the scholarship of teaching and learning was a rich source on a model of scholarship (Trigwell, et al. 2000) with tables also drawing on Perkins (1999, 2006) that I must try to follow-up as with Visual Art as navigation of affective thresholds: implications for the classroom.



The afternoon keynote discussed The dual development of professional identity as physicians and mentors, with Profs Hokstad and Kvernenes. Using a narrative reading (Reismann, 2008) the content and findings to me call for simultaneous duality in identity, the medical and the non-medical (practitioner - interaction with the patient and their family), clinician and mentor.

Being struck by the thought (on science, knowledge, holism - whole / part distinctions) of Goethe in the past it was a marvellous to attend Jonathan Code's session; Mind the Gap - Ontological discontinuity as threshold concept. I imagined Hodges' model and several leaves in various stages of growth.

It creates an overhead for conference organisers, but video recordings would be a great help. I think there is one more short post on this conference.


Ilgen, J.S., Eva, K.W., de Bruin, A., Cook, D.A., Regehr, G. (2018). Comfort with uncertainty: reframing our conceptions of how clinicians navigate complex clinical situations.
Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. Nov 2. doi: 10.1007/s10459-018-9859-5.


See also:
Inaugural Scottish Threshold Concepts Conference: TCs in Action [i]